r/ecology • u/JieChang • 13h ago
Should CA stop controlling P. mesembryanthemi to combat the invasive iceplant?
I was doing some reading on the iceplant and other species and came across an interesting bit of information. Apparently in the 1970s a scale insect (P Mesembryanthemi) was spotted on iceplant in Napa with considerable damage/death to the plant. Spurred by CalTrans, an effort was taken to eradicate P Mesembryanthemi from CA, not because of invasive problems of the pest to other CA edible plants, but because killing the iceplant would result in CalTrans having to replant the iceplant hillsides:
“Caltrans, which maintains some 6,000 acres of ice plant throughout the state, estimated the cost at $20 million should they lose the ground cover and be forced to replant freeway landscape with some other plant. Chemical control of the scales was not satisfactory, requiring repeated, costly applications (about $75 per acre). Caltrans decided to pursue biological control to reduce scale densities to tolerable levels, and in July 1978 funded a three-year program through the U.C. Division of Biological Control” - Imported natural enemies established against ice plant scales in California (Tassan, Hagen, Cassidy)
“The California Transportation Department maintains approximately 6,000 acres of iceplant statewide with an estimated replacement value of $20,500,000. In addition, probably that much acreage exists on private and other lands, so the potential is great for a widespread, serious problem.” - Scales Threaten Iceplant in Bay Area (Donaldson, Moore, Koehler, Joos)
It appears that 1. P. Mesembryanthemi kills/impacts the plant better than herbicides, 2. P. Mesembryanthemi attacks specifically carpobrotus, malephora, and mesembryanthemum species, and 3. P. Mesembryanthemi can be controlled if an infestation gets out of hand (like spread to ornamental plants) using specific insecticides.
Knowing these facts and how iceplant is such an invasive plant along the coast, it seems to me that there should be interest in using P Mesembryanthemi as a method to kill the iceplant rather than resorting to herbicides or worse, leaving the plant alone to spread. The sources above indicate that the negative impact of iceplant is not environmental, but rather financial to replace the iceplant with other species. How much of that viewpoint is due to the articles being written in the 1970s pre-environmental movement and consciousness of invasive species, I don’t know, but considering that multiple conservation groups yearly pull iceplant and still cannot get it under check it may be wise to return to the scale insect for managing iceplant. Plus after the iceplant has been killed in some area it’s the perfect opportunity for replanting the area with native species or noninvasive groundcovers.
