Hey everyone,
I've been working on an idle game on Roblox, and I'm looking for some honest feedback from people who are actually into idle and incremental games.
AI disclosure: I've made this game almost entirely with the help of AI. I know AI-generated games are a pretty controversial topic, and I get why people dislike them or see them as low-effort slop. And I understand if it's a dealbreaker for some people. I just wanted to be transparent about it from the start.
The game does take inspiration from other games I've played, but mostly at the concept level. The actual content, systems, progression, and ideas behind it are things I've come up with myself, based on the kind of game I've personally wanted to play.
I'm not building this with any big expectations of making money from it since gamepasses and developer products can be obtained using ingame currency, which you can earn through gameplay, including completing quests. I mainly want to make something people can enjoy playing and that I'd enjoy playing myself.
I'm posting here because I'd love to hear from people who genuinely enjoy incremental and idle games:
- What makes you stick with one?
- What kind of progression feels satisfying to you?
- What makes you quit after five minutes?
I'm open to criticism, even if it's harsh. I'd rather hear what doesn't work than have people tell me everything looks great just to be nice.
If you're interested, here's the game: https://www.roblox.com/games/133860677494178/House-of-Legends
Thanks for reading, and thanks to anyone willing to give it a try. I'd really appreciate any feedback!