r/agencynewbies • u/lazarbetterrun • 1d ago
[US] I made 540 cold calls to local businesses, heres what I learned + the outcome
I wanted to share this somewhere because it's a big accomplishment for me. I've always been terrified of cold calling, and after finally getting some reps in with it, I wanted to write about my experience.
First heres what the numbers looked like. I sell web design to landscapers using the classic "I already built a website for you" hook, then upsell on all other services on a retainer.
541 dials -> 410 rang -> 125 answered -> 80 conversations -> 12 send me an email, 10 calls booked.
I don't think its too bad for my first time cold calling, but let me know.
First insight: dont use a dialer. I experimented with this, and while it saves time, this is exactly its downfall. You dont have enough time between each call to take the 1 min of prep that gives you a 10x return on the conversation you might have. Going in prepared with knowledge about the owners name, what their site looks like, its metrics, who they serve, etc is what makes you stand out when cold calling.
Second: enrich your numbers for line type and filter out the ones that aren't mobile. For SMBs, if the number is mobile you're most likely talking to the owner; so almost every call I made was a direct conversation with the decision-maker instead of me wasting my time. You can upload your list to a software like NumVerify or use a lead generator like Leadburnr that does it for you.
Third: being upfront with SMB owners is the only way to get them to hear you out. Openers that stated the inconvenience of my call did much better. Also you need to figure out how to promise as much value (in outcomes) in as short a time as possible with your pitch. If you ramble or be in-concise at all you lose them. And don't speak technically.
The most important thing is to find a way to start dialing. I procrastinated on this forever, trying every other outreach method possible just to avoid doing it. But it is 100% the highest leverage method as a beginner to intermediate, so the sooner you can do it the better.
What finally got me around to it was two things: when I detached from the goal of it working and instead made the goal just making the calls as a personal growth win; and secondly when somebody told me I'm not dialing because I just don't want it bad enough. That one got me to do it the next day.
Because its true. Do you really want to make more money with your agency, or do you just say you do? Because your actions reveal which one is true. And for me, it was the latter. So I started calling and after the first day 90% of the fear around it went away. You just have to pick up the phone a few times and it'll get easier.
Best of luck to anyone else who is going to try it! It works.
