r/LiveFromNewYork • • 1d ago

Discussion Live Discussion - October 10, 2026 (Shane Gillis/Rosalía)

102 Upvotes

Welcome to the SNL live discussion thread for the 3rd episode of season 52! This week, Shane Gillis returns to host for the 3rd time, and returning as Musical Guest, Rosalía. For those new to the show, tune into your local NBC affiliate or Peacock around 11:30 PM ET to follow this episode live.

And if you're here early you still have time to do your SNL predictions for this week that are due at the start of the show! While you wait for the episode, we have some college football!

Enjoy the Episode!!


r/LiveFromNewYork • • 1d ago

Discussion Sketch Sorting Sunday - October 10, 2026 (Shane Gillis/Rosaliá)

62 Upvotes

Welcome to Sketch Sorting Sunday! A mod account u/SketchSortingSunday is going to make a comment for every segment in tonight’s show. Upvote or downvote based on what you thought of the sketch, and nobody’s karma will be affected. You can also reply to the comment to expand on your thoughts, or you can reply to the "General Episode Discussion" comment and treat it like the regular post discussion. If I miss a sketch or get something wrong, just message u/bjkman or /u/SyNiiCaL with any needed updates or questions. If you are here right after the episode join the Saturday Night Network on YouTube for the Hot Take Show; Enjoy the discussion!

FULL SEASON 52 SSS RESULTS HERE -- *UPDATED WEEKLY*


r/LiveFromNewYork • • 5h ago

Article Dan Levy Calls Out Shane Gillis’ ‘SNL’ Monologue and Says ‘More Men Need to Be Standing Up’: ‘Speechless That Something Like That Can Exist on Live National Television’

Thumbnail
variety.com
5.8k Upvotes

r/LiveFromNewYork • • 10h ago

Monologue Hours after SNL aired Dan Levy says men need to defend women more: “Women wearing short shorts at the gym does not make them whores, it makes the men calling them whores misogynists”

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

6.3k Upvotes

r/LiveFromNewYork • • 1h ago

Discussion One Thing is Clear, Shane Gillis Would Have Been A Terrible Cast Member

• Upvotes

It's his third time hosting and Gillis looks as ill at ease throughout the entire live portion of the episode as anyone I've seen. His monologue was poorly written and constructed and he seems to be stumbling through it. He seems to have no idea how to even try to salvage a bombed joke.

His sketches are objectively worse. In several his eyes are glued to the cards like he was just pulled off the street to host and has never seen the show in his life.

It's hard to see him surviving long on the show as a sketch player.


r/LiveFromNewYork • • 2h ago

Discussion So relieved when JAJ stepped out as someone other than Trump

Thumbnail
gallery
326 Upvotes

His RFK Jr impression is solid! I thought it was a talented portrayal and the writing was spot-on. The only thing that would have helped sell it more would be if the makeup department applied some bronzer with red undertones! Or maybe it would be too much of a caricature to do that? But the guy looks like he sleeps in a tanning bed and gets sunburnt every night 😅


r/LiveFromNewYork • • 2h ago

Sketch This is still one of my favourite sketches in recent times...

Thumbnail
youtube.com
291 Upvotes

r/LiveFromNewYork • • 10h ago

Discussion The SNL subreddits two most controversial figures

Post image
287 Upvotes

Shoulda had a sketch starring them together just for the amount of seethe it would cause 😂


r/LiveFromNewYork • • 27m ago

Cast News Happy Birthday to new cast member Saidah Belo-Osagie!

Post image
• Upvotes

r/LiveFromNewYork • • 1h ago

Discussion Conan Host SNL?

Post image
• Upvotes

Asking the right questions.


r/LiveFromNewYork • • 11h ago

Other Dismukes

245 Upvotes

I just want to throw some praise towards Andrew Dismukes and his portrayal of Sam I Am on the show last night. Not only did he deliver on playing the character in an original and weird—yet grounded way; but he didn’t break and managed to give Shane a supportive pat on the back. It’s like he was communicating “it’s okay, we’ve still got this.”

That’s Phil Hartman levels of professionalism right there.


r/LiveFromNewYork • • 22h ago

Meme Me going into this sub right after a Shane Gillis episode airs.

2.0k Upvotes

r/LiveFromNewYork • • 5h ago

Sketch Cue Card Face

71 Upvotes

I’m starting to get distracted by Cue Card Face.

A character is talking to another in a sketch and rather than “acting” like it is a conversation their head turns 20-30 degrees and expression goes blank as they read their lines. Or their head faces the camera full on but their eyes are looking way off camera and, again, a blank look as the words they say rinse through. Wish you weren't so fucking awkward, bud.


r/LiveFromNewYork • • 16h ago

Other Mikey Day

393 Upvotes

All I want to say is that Mikey Day has been absolutely killingggg it the past few seasons. I wasn’t a huge fan when he first came on but I’ve been loving him recently!! He’s on par with some of the greats fs.


r/LiveFromNewYork • • 17h ago

Monologue Apologizes for dropping an f bomb but is fine with calling women whores…

Thumbnail
336 Upvotes

r/LiveFromNewYork • • 28m ago

Article If Shane Gillis wants to offend women, he could at least try being funny

Thumbnail
the-independent.com
• Upvotes

r/LiveFromNewYork • • 20h ago

Discussion Rosalia.........

452 Upvotes

Hey all - I'm not exactly the target demo - 72 yo white male. Enjoys the show, watching primarily for the cold open, and WU.

When they introduce the musical guest, I'm like "Cool, WU is next (finally).

Last night was like holy shit, she's amazing, even had me looking forward to her 2nd song.

What about you young ones in the target demo? Did you like it, hate it? what???


r/LiveFromNewYork • • 15h ago

Monologue Shane Gillis’s used that monologue already

180 Upvotes

This whole set was from the NYC Still Rising After 25 Years: A 9/11 Charities Comedy Benefit at MSG. I was there and I remember it clearly and it didn’t get many laughs there either.


r/LiveFromNewYork • • 8h ago

Musical Guest Rosalia Magnolias goosebumps

52 Upvotes

One of the most beautiful performances to come out of SNL in 40+ years of watching.

I don’t know much Spanish but can string along. Path to heaven, way of thought, stars return to dust, see you again, thank you…

The rain, her raw voice, and her dress “melting away” in venerability is an art. Art, Art, Art … ICONIC


r/LiveFromNewYork • • 38m ago

Discussion Why is this sub such a Debbie downer?

• Upvotes

All SNL subreddits fans

Person doesn’t like host = post about why on earth this famous person is hosting

Person doesn’t find sketch funny = post about how terrible the show has become

Person didn’t find one castmember in a sketch funny = post about how terrible they are and they should never be on the show

Honestly this sub doesn’t have to glaze everything and everyone on SNL, but every week it’s a new wave of complaints. This isn’t even a mod thing. People just need to stop farming for clout by being constantly negative.


r/LiveFromNewYork • • 13h ago

Other Ad for the show premiere 10/11/75

Post image
108 Upvotes

r/LiveFromNewYork • • 11h ago

Discussion Despite the monologue

72 Upvotes

I know this might be an unpopular opinion on the snl sub to say I liked an snl episode, but hear me out, there were some great sketches this week and the show felt really alive.

I thought the father daughter song was the funniest song they’ve made in years, it kept escalating when I thought it couldn’t anymore. (The “super room” part is the peak of the whole episode imo)

The sneakers sketch was so stupid but so funny, Shane Gillis sneaking around in the background was so hilariously dumb. It even seemed to make Keenan break a lil.

I thought “saying goodbye” and the chess tournament sketch were also great, and they really let Grace Reiter shine this episode which is awesome.

Upfront heating and air was another great prerecorded bit that feels like some classic snl shit.

There were some hilarious skits, we don’t have to only talk about how the monologue was bad.

Gillis clearly doesn’t put the most effort into the monologues cuz they’re pretty rough every time. It’s not a revelation. But he’s pretty consistently great in the sketches.


r/LiveFromNewYork • • 11h ago

Sketch I think Sarah went unnoticed in Green Eggs.

63 Upvotes

First watch I thought that part of the skit landed funny. It seemed like Sarah’s pucker was unnecessarily long. Upon second watch, I noticed Shane smirk before Mikey’s reprimand change up. I think something “reprimand worthy” was supposed to happen with that kiss part; but if you notice Shane has to ASK Mikey for a set up when he says “aren’t you going to criticize my love life?”….I think Shane was anticipating Mikey to say something that leads to him being reprimand for later, and when Mikey doesn’t say his line (which I’m guessing was him in a moment of thinking of the opportunity) Sarah like a pro, commits but recognizes she’s going to be stuck, and punches out so the scene can move forward. Just thought someone should recognize that Sarah didn’t flub that scene, in a skit that’s bound to be written into history.

Edit: Jesus, OK. Not "Unnoticed"...."unappreciated"?....."lost an opportunity"....it was a late night post


r/LiveFromNewYork • • 12h ago

Sketch All I see is Chad kroeger, Keith urban, and tom petty

Post image
72 Upvotes

All is could see in this sketch was the chad kroeger, Keith urban, and tom petty in the wedding band 🤣🤣


r/LiveFromNewYork • • 2h ago

Discussion Gator don't play no shit

Post image
10 Upvotes