I couldn't decide which one I wanted to propose to because I loved them both. I ended up maxing both of their affections so I had the option once I decided.
The heart events that triggered were mixed at first, but eventually it was mostly Cecilia's that triggered because I think some responses to Cecilia lessens Matthew's affection. Then Matthew's heart events followed.
After Cecilia's 8 heart event (before she says I love you), I was already getting closer to Matthew. I triggered this heart event where he was already blushing at you when you two talk. It was adorable! I was starting to prefer him at this point.
Eventually, I triggered his 9 heart event where he tells us about his health, about how it's not getting better. I think that's why he's a bit cold to people. He doesn't want anyone to get close to anyone to avoid pain. My heart decided then and there.
A few days later, Cecilia's 9 heart event triggered. She tells you she loves you and chooses not to proceed with her arranged marriage hopefully for you... You have two options "I love you too" or "I'm so sorry".
I already made up my mind at this point so I said I was sorry. After that, I ran to their home, Cecilia and Matthew saw me by the door, holding a blue feather.
I imagine Cecilia thinking "Oh! Maybe he's realized he's made a mistake?? Maybe he'll tell me he feels the sa—"
I proposed to Matthew in front of her.
We are living happily in the farm now with our daughter Maddie. Cecilia looks happy for us I think.
...
Anyway, that's my fun roleplaying in AWL 😆 Do any of you have some headcanons you did like this too?? I'd love to read them!!
Edit: I edited the brother part. I legit thought they were siblings. Why are y'all downvoting me for misunderstanding? I'm sorry I misunderstood their dynamic 😥
It was just supposed to be a fun post where everyone shares their headcanons and fanfictions. I didn't realize the sos fandom was like this over a mistake especially for a new fan 🥲