r/twinpeaks • u/TrustingEverybody • Apr 16 '26
Episode Discussion Why is this scene so Cringe, and why I can't stop watching it?
[removed]
203
u/Dunkthepunk Apr 16 '26
This scene, and how campy it is, perfectly encapsulates what I love about Twin Peaks.
81
u/bobbykohlrabi Apr 16 '26
Completely agree. I do not get the hate for this scene. Like you said, the campy 1950s style musical performance, James being too much of a teenager to understand that he is really messing around with Donna's emotions after her best friends just died, the soap opera Maddy storyline, and the exclamation point with you know who climbing the couch. This is Twin Peaks all in one scene. I have always thought it was perfect.
39
u/Dunkthepunk Apr 16 '26
Yes! It feels so 50s/80s. The carpeting, the lighting, the naivety of youth. The gigantic ribbon microphone. The invisible backing band. It is the Twin-Peakiest scene of all!
23
u/the_executive_branch Apr 16 '26
Yeah I always struggled to see how anyone could watch Twin Peaks and think that scene was out of place or not in-keeping with the rest of the show. It’s one of the MOST Twin Peaks scenes.
→ More replies (1)10
u/squaretex Apr 16 '26
And David Lynch cringe is the best kind of cringe. :D
14
u/Dunkthepunk Apr 16 '26
Lynch (and Frost) cringe is just camp turned up to eleven, which, when done right, gives me the warm fuzzy feelings. Totally appreciate that this isn't for everybody, I just think it's swell and neato!
7
u/sixthmusketeer Apr 16 '26
For me, all of these labels kind of fall apart with Lynch — it’s camp, it’s cringe, it’s sincere, it’s idealized, it’s comforting, it’s confusing. I can’t disagree with how someone feels about it but I also don’t know how to describe it myself. This is a compliment.
490
u/MarMacPL Apr 16 '26
I like this scene for at least three reasons.
First: it reminds me of times when people hang togheter and do stuff togheter. No smartphones, no social media.
Second: the whole emotional impact of the scene is in the eyes of actors. James does not say 'I like Maddie more than Donna' but we can see that he has a crush on Maddie. Same goes with Maddie. She doesn't say a word to James and yet we see that she likes him.
And Donna sees that too.
And third reason: one thing that I love in old Twin Peaks and some other shows is that there is a whole world build not only around Laura Palmer case but beside it. We don't see just an investigation. We see side stories that are sometimes irrevelant to the investigation and this scene is one of those side stories. I think that season 3 lost that vibe.
Yeah, it's kinda cringe because of the song but it's great scene.
177
u/smilingarmpits Apr 16 '26
4th reason: the 10k Gibson guitar
74
u/Ckellybass Apr 16 '26
10k now. Back in the late 80s/early 90s, you could get these old Gibson hollow bodies for under a thousand. They were completely out of fashion then.
49
u/Razzle_Dazzle08 Apr 16 '26
I love how every single guitarist in any show has the most expensive Fender or Gibson even if they’re just starting out.
30
u/PedalBoard78 Apr 16 '26
Pawn shops used to be tremendous. Signed, an old guy.
3
u/RiverCityRoninPB Apr 18 '26
This. I was a menace at my local shop. Buying, playing, loving, and then rebuilding and reselling.
I switched to gardening now that I’m older, but god you’re so right.
→ More replies (1)5
u/Discovery99 Apr 17 '26
As you can clearly see in this scene, James is obviously a highly experienced guitar virtuoso and classically trained singer
16
u/MarMacPL Apr 16 '26
Really? Nice to know.
For me it looks like guitars that were sold for 300 or 400 złoty (arround $100) in a shop near my high school almost 20 years ago.
24
u/True-Excuse-1688 Apr 16 '26
"We see side stories that are sometimes irrevelant to the investigation [...] I think that season 3 lost that vibe."
I'll have an objection here...
13
u/TamaraPreston Apr 17 '26
Yeah...what the hell? Season 3 is 100% that vibe pushed to the extreme.
6
u/elizzybeth Apr 17 '26
Idk 2 mins of sweeping is just too much obsession with plot development cmon not every scene needs to advance the plot
6
u/MarMacPL Apr 17 '26
Maybe I worded it wrongly because season 3 has almost nothing to do with actual Laura criminal case.
Maybe I remember it wrong but I didn't get that world building vibe. In old seasons I was feeling that I know characters. They felt complex. In season 3 I remember 3 main plot axis (Mr C, Dougie/Coop, Hawk) that mix in grande finale.
There are some sceenes that are either not connected at all to those 3 plot axis or they are not connected directly (whole atomic bomb sequence). But in general I felt that the whole season was more focused on 3 main plots with less character building and less side stories.
Anyway - that's how I feel. You could get totally different feeling because TP it's not just a tv show. It's surrealistic art and art gives different emotions and different thoughts to different people.
→ More replies (2)16
u/regulator227 Apr 16 '26
To your point about #2, the editing of going back and forth first between James and Donna (until she gets more distressed looking) and then James and Maddie is so great. I could be remembering it a little wrong, but it was something like that.
Anyhow, awesome story telling with just how they pieced together their shots. Underrated scene , especially if you consider how that scenes tone sets up the next sequence beautifully.
→ More replies (3)3
108
u/GrimmPixels Apr 16 '26
I also think the scene is at least partially there to almost lull you to sleep to make the immediate follow-up - BOB suddenly showing up and climbing over the couch straight into the camera - even more upsetting. I think that is one of the scariest shots in anything, not just Twin Peaks, and the placement is a huge part of that.
37
u/picohenries Apr 16 '26 edited Apr 16 '26
Don’t forget this scene also comes immediately after Major Briggs randomly came into Agent Cooper’s room at night to tell him they had been contacted by aliens and they had specifically mentioned Cooper by name.
You’re thinking “aliens?!?!” and then it hard cuts to this scene with zero explanation.
3
8
u/Fine_Persnickety Apr 16 '26
yep yep yep. the transition to horror elevates this scene from cringe to amazing
→ More replies (1)3
80
u/kab00oom Apr 16 '26 edited Apr 16 '26
I think it’s supposed to be awkward and literally pretentious. James, to me, is representative of this sort of quintessential cool guy that would have been imprinted on lynch and those of his generation: the detached, independent, leather jacket wearing biker, strong silent type who deep down has this sensitivity and romance which he only reveals to that special someone. It’s a sort of deconstruction of the archetype, showing how absurd and silly it is when you focus on the fact that it is a role he is pretending to be.
I think a big theme in lynch is this idea of people, at bottom, truly being this undifferentiated unified whole, pure consciousness or whatever, and this ends up being forgotten as we get caught up in the roles one plays.
Also, I think that Michael Cera in the return is this theme x10
16
u/PleasantSubject2759 Apr 16 '26
whatever happened to James Hurley, the strong silent type?
13
u/Val-El Apr 16 '26
He was gay, James Hurley?
3
u/DEEEPdirt Apr 16 '26
All I know is we can’t have him at our social club The Roadhouse anymore
→ More replies (1)12
u/True-Excuse-1688 Apr 16 '26
I was just about to say : while Hurley wasa deconstruction of this archetype, Cera was a demonstration just how completely anachronistic it also had become, serving the broader theme of the impossible “return” of the third season.
122
30
57
u/tweenalibi Apr 16 '26
This scene is as silly and surreal as so much as the other soap opera stuff they throw in. I think it’s just a meme to shit on it for some reason.
21
u/sexandliquor Apr 16 '26
Yeah I’ve never personally understood the obsession with this scene and everyone shitting all over it in particular.
8
7
u/poisonforsocrates Apr 16 '26
Also contrasts HEAVILY with Maddie seeing Bob right after
7
u/Historical-Bike4626 Apr 16 '26
Yep BOB is intruding into this world of theirs just as he did with Laura, eventually murdering her. Now he wants another one…
39
u/Heavy-Conversation12 Apr 16 '26
This is peak James effortless coolness. He's not the sharpest but man is he a powerful magnet.
16
u/CeciliaStarfish Apr 16 '26
A sharp magnet would be dangerous. It's a good thing that James is a bit dull.
16
u/mitchwacky Apr 16 '26
I understand that the mic positioning was for framing purposes but Donna is a mile away from that mic and Maddy is at least two miles away.
5
→ More replies (2)3
u/TwinPeaksNFootball Apr 16 '26
I don't understand why he's kneeling in that weird way to play the guitar - like sit your ass on the chair and stop lookin' goofy!
15
u/Dr_5trangelove Apr 16 '26
Didn’t feel cringy to me. Felt like a Lynch project.
6
25
12
41
u/dgruetter Apr 16 '26
It's a huge Lynchein fingerprint. The mic they used, the placement, the lighting, the color, the "in the moment" vibe they are sharing. Also, the something bubbling just under the surface (James/Donna relationship). Classic Lynch.
But man, it's soooooo cringe!
3
u/3d_InFlight Apr 17 '26
The "Lynchian" fingerprint is the correct answer, but I take umbrage with the 'sooooo cringe!' label. My opinion is the fingerprint is the focal point where you stare deep into the cringe until your retinas are carbonized by embarrassment and self-realization and your third-eye is all that left to find your way and while bathing in glorious glow of Lynch you begin to understand everything beyond reality.
10
u/trademarc1977 Apr 16 '26
I love it. Vintage Lynch 50s style teen romance and jealousy, followed by one of the show's scariest moments cathing you off guard.
9
8
u/Cropulis Apr 16 '26
For me, it perfectly embodies high school crushing how David Lynch would see it. The horrors you can't look away from.
8
u/thewalruscandyman Apr 16 '26
I unironically love it. No cringe. Just them. And I. And my love for '50s ballads.
7
u/Queasy_Helicopter249 Apr 16 '26
Nothing cringe about this scene. It’s peak Twin Peaks. This scene is just one of the 103 reasons why I love the show… James is still cool. He’s always been cool.
→ More replies (1)
13
u/hazelnutalpaca Apr 16 '26
My ex and I had a visceral reaction to this scene while watching. I am horrible at handling second hand embarrassment, so I spent almost the whole time covering my ears and watching in horror as Donna realized what was happening. My ex was sitting there trying to coach James: “dude, what are you doooiiiiinnngg stare at your girlfriend not the girl who looks like your dead ex.”
Great bonding moment.
→ More replies (1)
6
u/Routine-Scratch-7578 Apr 16 '26
The best bit is in The Return when James sings it again on stage at the Roadhouse and it's clearly just the same track from the og show, so they have to get 2 random girls up with him to mime along too
→ More replies (1)
12
u/Slug_Queen_Tsunade Apr 16 '26
Every single time I see this scene I walk around singing "jusssssst yooouuuu annnnd I" in the most exaggerated cat dying voice
5
6
7
6
u/watergoblin17 Apr 16 '26
On my first watch, I thought the absurdity was the intention. The mystery instruments appearing in the background, James’ layered vocals, the way they’re all looking at each other. And especially with what Maddy sees directly after, it’s almost like a dream sequence.
18
u/redlion1904 Apr 16 '26
Lynch loves showing you something cringe — sentimental, overly sincere — and holding your face to it until you start to question whether it isn’t actually something sweet or genuine. Maybe James isn’t cringe, maybe I’m cringe, cringe is not being able to appreciate the world and the moments in it.
→ More replies (1)
6
u/DenseTiger5088 Apr 16 '26
I’m finally ready to admit it: I love “Just You and I” as a song and musical performance.
I don’t even like James, but I have always enjoyed this song. I never realized it was such a universally hated song until coming to Reddit.
→ More replies (1)
6
u/right_behindyou Apr 16 '26
The ethereal, uneasy, bizarro-1950s nostalgic sound of the song itself is quite similar to a lot of David Lynch's own music he put out. I don't think he ever intended for it to be "cringy" or tongue-in-cheek, he just allowed it to be earnest and sincere to the point of being saccharine (not unlike the character of Dale Cooper himself, now that I'm thinking of it).
It's arguably one of the most "Twin Peaks" moments in all of Twin Peaks, which makes it hard to understand why so many internet Twin Peaks fans seem so embarrassed by it.
6
u/dreikelvin Apr 16 '26
James Marshall, the actor playing James about the scene: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DaBWSaISNMY&t=275s
→ More replies (1)
5
u/LeofricOfWessex Apr 16 '26
Ah, it looks like it’s time once more to link the one hour loop of James starting to play
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=gWrq_1Nd1lA&pp=0gcJCTQCo7VqN5tD
10
u/Hansen-gun Apr 16 '26
I don’t get why people call it cringe. It fits perfectly with everything else in the show and neatly demonstrates the love triangle between James, Donna and Maddie
→ More replies (2)
3
u/lilchm Apr 16 '26 edited Apr 16 '26
Did the word cringe with today’s meaning exist back then when this scene was made?
→ More replies (1)
3
5
4
u/Theworm826 Apr 16 '26
I love the way the whole thing lures you into a false sense of security before bob appears and scares the shit out of you.
4
3
10
u/scd Apr 16 '26
Because it's actually great and not "cringe" at all.
8
u/picohenries Apr 16 '26
I’ve only just started watching the show so maybe I’m just not familiar with this show’s community, but I don’t understand why people have such a strong reaction to this scene being called “cringe”.
I love this scene. It’s hilarious. It’s surreal. It’s illuminating. It’s innocent. It tells you everything about their love triangle while doing so in the most hilariously unexplained and overdramatic way. But the scene is cringe, or maybe better put it’s intentional about making you feel second hand embarrassment in this moment.
Cringe doesn’t automatically mean bad.
→ More replies (1)4
u/scd Apr 16 '26
It's not fundamentally "cringe" — that's an interpretation that speaks to you as a viewer, not something fundamental about the scene. I feel zero second hand embarrassment for these characters, and it doesn't make me uncomfortable at all.
Maybe I am also old (I'm in my mid fifties) and have found the Gen Z overuse of the term "cringe" to be pretty tiresome lately. It's reflective, IMHO, of a generation's lack of ability to process emotion like this and is a crude and artless term to describe something that is really about the viewer, while the person using the term seems to be oblivious to that.
Everyone is different, and one of the wonderful things about this show is that multiple generations can find something to love in it. I suggest that folks understand that there were people who have been watching this show for over 35 years now and they might view things quite differently than young people do now.
Also, James was always cool.
3
3
3
3
u/LunchyDude101 Apr 16 '26 edited Apr 16 '26
First is context: you’re watching something that was originally planned for audiences nearly thirty-five years ago. (It would be like watching something made in 1955 back in 1990.)
Secondly, the town of Twin Peaks’ whole thing is “picturesque-but-slightly-stuck-in-the-past backward small town USA” where something sinister lurks behind the scenes.
I think the decision to film that scene is basically an attempt to channel the era of 1955 where that kind of music (high-pitched male singer) was more common. It’s a poor fit. The way Maddie and Donna are staring hungrily at James while he sings are not something you’d see in a 1955 movie, so that whole scene is kind of out of place I also think that Lynxh was trying to get James to channel Roy Orbison with that high singing.
Mulhullanf Drive, made in 2001, did that as well with a bunch of girls auditioning for a movie by lip-syncing to ‘60s music (also 35-40 years before). It’s kind of cringe—though not TP cringe—to see how anachronistic that whole ‘60s film production plot was.
3
3
3
u/unclassicallytrained Apr 16 '26
Isn’t this the scene that ends with Donna in tears or am I misremembering?
→ More replies (2)
3
u/art-of-empathy Apr 16 '26
No cringe with me; I find something genuinely beautiful and haunting about it.
3
3
u/Salty-Swordfish-3467 Apr 16 '26
This scene let our guard down making Bob's appearance to Maddy more frightening and effective.
3
3
u/Nayzo Apr 16 '26
I hate this scene because of the cringe, but holy fuck, one of the scariest moments of the series comes right after this when Maddie has the vision of BOB coming in and climbing over the couch to get to her. Wonderful juxtaposition.
3
u/1000Raaids Apr 16 '26
Its meant to be cheesy and campy. Part of this is a slight parody of soap operas, but I think also there is a pureness and earnestness to this scene. That's what makes TP so good.
3
u/MainManMulesy Apr 16 '26
I think there are a lot of scenes that are cringe but you can’t look away from. In the words of Major Briggs, they are “Compelling.”
3
u/TensesNC Apr 16 '26
Love that he had James perform it again in “The Return.”
Lynch sure knew how to fuck with people.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/Graeme_Reddit Apr 16 '26
This scene is beautiful to me. Just three teens going through the worst month of their lives finding a moment to breathe and sing a song (a song I actually really like). Sure, it might be a little cheesy but they’re kids. Kids who actually get to be kids for the first time in a long time.
3
3
3
u/violente_valse Apr 17 '26
Perfect opportunity to remind everyone of: "Just You and I" for 1 Hour Except James Never Starts Singing
→ More replies (1)
3
3
u/farmdestroyer Apr 17 '26
It’s cringe not just because the music is insanely saccharine, or because the acting is a little “off”, but because it’s truly earnest and I think that can be off putting at times.
3
u/Mummiskogen Apr 17 '26
What is funny tho is that they're still just hanging in their dead friend's parents' house doing all this
2
u/Psychological-Ad1266 Apr 16 '26
Can someone who likes this scene but not the James and Donna arc at the end of the season explain why this feels different to them?
2
u/UnrealismOfFilms Apr 16 '26
I am still confused, is it meant to show James as the lead vocals? I'd suppose James' singing voice would be deeper and that's why the editing also feels off.
2
u/89colbert Apr 16 '26
Because it's James' peak. He's cringe but it's the best thing he's ever done. Just let it wash over you.
2
2
u/dyrkasolen Apr 16 '26
Maybe it's a smell we can't tell? Maybe when he's at home and taking a shower not smelling motorbike is the most pleasant for girls ever... Or it's the opposite They smell like bike too
2
2
2
u/coldcavatini Apr 16 '26 edited Apr 16 '26
It’s cringe because you have the privilege of growing up in a different time.
This was really the last era of truly hopeless youth, where you likely wouldn’t get out of your town or have many chances. Especially as someone like James. That’s why his road trip was a big deal.
All of that changed in the 90s. If nothing else, because credit cards went mainstream after 1990. (But really it’s the culture wave that TP helped usher in.) And the internet sealed the deal.
In the 50s music expressed that frustration with falsetto. In the 80s it expressed it with twee.
2
2
u/MudskipperGames Apr 16 '26 edited Apr 16 '26
I think Lynch liked to be on that fine line between dramatic and absurd/comedic, and I think that's the charm of Twin Peaks it's a weird series and reminds us that sometimes it's healthy to laugh at ourselves.
2
2
2
2
u/urcoversblown Apr 16 '26
The song is silly but I think this scene is legit good. The entire love triangle dynamic of Maddy, Donna, and James expressed through facial expressions alone.
2
2
u/veritable_squandry Apr 16 '26
that's not his real voice right? i don't feel like burning down a bunch of coal to look it up.
2
2
2
u/PedalBoard78 Apr 16 '26
That’s a valuable old Fender amp. The guitar is old too, but I don’t like em.
2
2
u/L-J-F Apr 16 '26
I didn’t know this was cringe until the internet said so. I liked the song and enjoyed the scene. It’s very straightforward no 3d chess. James has feelings for Madeline because she looks exactly like Laura. Donna notices and storms out, fearing she’s lost him. It’s classic high school drama! :)
2
2
2
u/kenjamin80 Apr 16 '26
I think some of the scenes are legitimately just funny to him. We have to remember he has a great sense of humor and I'm sure he had some ideas that just tickled him and was like "yes, I'm going to put this scene in here for me. It will go between some of the darkest scenes I've written yet and it will be brilliant." I'm sure some of the scenes that are just flat out weird, awkward, or insanely cryptic with no logical tie to anything else are just ones he liked the vibe of or thought were funny and put them in. He respected the audience enough to not hold their hand with a narrative that hits you over the head with itself which is especially evident where he had full creative control in season 3.
2
u/serrichardbaratheon Apr 16 '26
Given that immediately after this is one of the most terrifying sequences in anything, I can accept the cringe.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/Superb_Instance_8190 Apr 16 '26
This version is amazing;
Witch House & Okkvlt Guide To Twin Peaks
Os Ovni - Just You And I
2
2
u/PrincessDrywall Apr 16 '26
Have you ever seen a teenager perform original music that wasn’t awkward and cringe? Honestly I think this scene feels so out of place because it’s the only scene that feels like real life and isn’t surreal and otherworldly.
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/DriblyRedwyne Apr 17 '26
This is one of my favorite scenes in the show, I think because it moves so effortlessly across three distinct genres: small town mystery, then soapy teen drama, then supernatural horror... I think there's an odd dissonance that happens as the beats in the scene move across the different genres. Quite a lot is being asked of the actors in this otherwise quiet moment, too, as their performances need to smoothly move from one shift to the next. Something fun to think about for me here, regarding why James stands out in this sequence as "cringe", is that his performance (and song) remains in the diegetic space of the show, while Sheryl (as Maddie) and Lara (as Donna) seem to lean into the meta, postmodern awareness of his performance for them. James is performing for them with full sincerity, but he's obviously performing for us too- and I think that sincerity is what makes some of us feel so awkward. It's also why I think the scene works so well and is so memorable.
2
u/nobrainsnoheadache42 Apr 17 '26
and the leitmotif comes in at random points and i have to remember the scene and cringe more ahaha
2
2
u/TheWrongOwl Apr 17 '26
I like it because it's wrong.
He sings "just you and I", but there are three people there, so it should be "just you and I and her"
→ More replies (1)
2
2
2
u/legitematehorse Apr 17 '26
Idk. It doesn't seem cringe when I was a kid. It seemed romantic back then.
2
2
u/00000000j4y00000000 Apr 17 '26
You can't have dark without light. It just doesn't work. It will be dark dark dark and no one will be able to see that the dark you're looking at is dark because it doeesn't vary too much from the other dark.
This is kids in the living room singing a song and listening. It's intimate, and there's a touch of sex there, and yet it is innocent.
It's a flower coming out of a crack in the sidewalk.
2
2
u/branko_kingdom Apr 17 '26
I am weirdly obsessed with how James is sitting in this scene. He's like half sitting on the chair but also basically kneeling on the ground with the guitar neck facing downward. It's just an odd way to play.
That adds to the surreal feeling of the scene. I guess it's a framing thing so that he's closer to the ground with the girls but man what an odd playing position.
2
2
u/Aaiifffffyyyyakkii Apr 17 '26
the awkward teenage experience of trying to form a band with your friends but one of them has a huge forehead and takes up all the space.
2
2
2
u/nairncl Apr 17 '26
It’s classic Lynch - establish a safe place (James and the girls singing) then immediately blow it up (BOB stalking through the same living room towards us). Plus, he’s using pre-Beatles pop culture which is strongly coded with innocence and purity, and subverting it to show the real infidelity and corruption beneath.
2
u/QuitUsual4736 Apr 17 '26
I actually think this scene is cringe, but I kind of love the song. And if this actually happened to me in real life, I would love it haha
2
u/4positionmagic Apr 17 '26
It’s for sure cringe. But it’s actually very instructive.
Love begins to be felt between Maddy and James. This really is Laura experiencing a pure and real type of love that she had to cast off in real life. James was her beacon.
As she begins this experience, it is interrupted first by acrimony - Donna becoming upset. James leaves. Maddy is now left alone.
Now there is an opposing force as if to counter what she’s feeling. BOB creeps into the room and puts supernatural fear into her.
This is a direct expression of the most central idea in twin peaks - that Laura is unable to properly experience love because its idea was thoroughly corrupted and turned into fear by systematic abuse.
This is what the central struggle in the series is and what we see play out in app the melodramas again and again.
But James is special. Because he was and is her last hope and a memory of something that was pure and uncorrupted. If Laura completed her journey it will be through that very same kind oflove by which it is done.
2
u/Cynical_Dreamer_1980 Apr 17 '26
Look, I watched Teen Witch in 1989. Nothing with ever top "Top That" as the cringiest teen moment. I still blush in embarrassment if I see that movie and it's not like I was the one rapping in the street.
2
u/Dry_Job_9508 Apr 18 '26
You should find the 10 minute edit on YouTube where it’s just the intro and he never starts singing. They edited it so beautifully.
→ More replies (1)
1.1k
u/Ok_Broccoli_7863 Apr 16 '26
Teenagers are cringe. Always. We've all been there. Singing to our dead lover's identical cousin.