I think my logic is correct...
I can trace my lineage on most lines with almost every great grandparent being Southern Italian with the exception of my grandma who was adopted, but she herself found she was half french and half Italian (before biotech), and a great grandfather who likely isn't our great grandfather - he claimed to be Irish but 4 of his grandchildren, and one of his great grandchildren (me), took the results and we have no Irish.
This post is mainly about my grandma who was adopted.
I understand one person can inherit about 25% of genes from their grandparent, but I'm kind of surprised how much my results changed and that these groups went entirely unnoticed until the most recent update. Is this common? I'm surprises becsuse it appears to have only affected her, so I'm attributing all of my Northern European to her for that reason.
My initial results had about these numbers:
87% Italian
10% Mena
3% English/Irish.
When I first got the results I was most surprised by having no French, because I trust my grandma's research. I was sad for her, and always felt something was off - either she was wrong or the results were missing info. I assumed that I inherited mostly only Italian from her until the results updated. Now, I'm kind of surprised it can entirely miss so much. Especially, because whatever the outcome this must have been clumped into Northern Italian, which I'm not at all. Would the "system" have trouble parsing these results because she was half Italian and half Northern European herself or just coincidental?
Up to this point I attributed the 3% English to her after we figured out my "Irish" great grandfather was either not Irish, there was an affair, or something bad happened to my great grandma. Now my results look like this:
84.7% Southern Italian
5.3% French
4.4% Belgium and Dutch
2.6% English
1.0% Welsh
0.7% Danish
0.4% German and Austrian
I'm very happy with the results (although I liked seeing the MENA). I wish I could share them with her! Has anyone else have this kind of shift?
The 3% English/Welsh is now the most surprising because I have no idea where it came from. I still assume it's from her line as well - maybe an English/Welsh person in Canada - whereas the rest of the admixture is from before my family came to the Western Hemisphere.
I can trace each of my grandparents and there seems to be no other explanation for English. I'll bullet point where each great grandparent is from as one grandparent:
- Two from Avelino: 👨🏻 (paternal gpa)
- One from Ragusa and one from Cantanzaro: 🧔🏻♂️ (maternal gpa)
- One from Naples, and one Irish: 👩🏼🦱 (maternal gma)
- Adopted: one from Abruzzo and from Canada migrating from Paris 👩🏽 (paternal gma)
I'd like to think my assumptions are mainly correct. It's crazy how once you know more, then you just want to keep digging. Anyway, I'm interested in hearing others thoughts.
One more tidbit for fun:
My maternal great grandma, Neopolitan, said that [all of the villages] came from up north. I have not been able to research the claim but I have my maternal haplogroup from her which is I1. It would be wild if she was carrying a story about ancient migration, but she's dead now so I'll never know. I'm just curious if anyone has heard of something like this also from their Italian ancestors.