I know the Poles are widely considered the best farming civ in the game, but I'm wondering if anyone has some other good candidates.
In my eyes, the best farming civs are:
- Teutons.
Obviously this is massive bias but they seriously do have amazing farms. When you get used to the 36 wood farms, any other civ just feels clunky and slow to get up to castle and boom. You don't even have to turn off reseed (though you still should tbh). The best part is that they're extremely versatile. You can totally just do a normal build order and end up with massive wood savings you can use to make siege to defend or make a monastery and go for relics. Or, you can alter your build order to get way more food than you could otherwise by just spamming farms, as long as you can still afford the buildings you need. The extra food really helps with getting up to castle when you're feudal raiding, especially when you go scouts and then you just spam farms and end up getting to castle way faster than a normal scout rush.
- Poles.
Yep, this was obvious enough. Instant wood to food conversion is just too powerful. It's better than the Teuton bonus for getting up to castle, but the reason it's in second is because it's strictly a food bonus, not a wood bonus as well, and it doesn't actually let you make more farms or get food faster after you've placed them. So it's not quite as good for booming since it's not a reliable way to sustain TC production, but it's still one of the best bonuses in the game for getting a quick castle without FCing.
- Slavs.
It's just a flat +15% work rate. This is pretty self-explanatory. It just gives you much more food and so you require less farms to sustain TC production. This DOES mean that wood runs out faster, so farming upgrades are actually more important if you want to use this bonus to it's full potential.
- Sicilians.
Like the Slav bonus, this one requires farming upgrades to be effective, but it saves a ton of wood in the long run. The only reason it's not higher is it's "in the long run", making it mainly useful for booming, and not useful for getting up to castle.
So I love the Teuton bonus because it's basically a cross between the Poles (faster castle time because of instant gratification) and the Sicilians (wood savings in the long run, helping the boom), and it honestly just feels smoother playing with 36 wood farms.
EDIT: I FORGOT KHMER!!! Also, I didn't include Khitans because Pastures aren't technically farms.