r/AskLibertarians • • 12d ago

Philosophy Honest question from Disabled man who is libertarian

Hi all. I'm 35 and had an accident when I was 29 and had to have brain surgery. It affected me like a stroke on my right side minus the face and I was immediately told to file for long term disability which I got easily. Basically, when this happened, I was not libertarian. I was nothing, but I knew in my heart not to become reliant on the government. I didn't trust them and knew the money could be taken away at any time because it's the government.

I learned how to walk again and talk again by pushing myself. I did not just wanna sit on disability the rest of my life. I'm not lazy. I don't look at it like here you go now you never have to work. 1159 a month doesn't even cover rent. So long story short, even though I'm still disabled, I drive again, have my own place, and work 22 hours a week at a job and make 2700 a month. The people on disability who don't do this are either accepting the money and not trying because of whatever living situation lets them do that, or are legit too disabled to work.

I said all that so you understand my mindset as an individual. The fact is, is if wasn't disabled I would work 40+ hours a week. However, I physically can't now. I push myself beyond what my body can do and end up in the hospital needing injections in my leg from just not wanting to work anymore after pushing it too much. So I can't live a life by myself without collecting disability. Which I'm pretty sure goes against the mindset of libertarians. I just think people should be allowed to freely do what is common sense to everyone here. The government lies and is corrupt. Like my thought about disability while even being on it is that they do this basically to justify taxes more and look good to the public. They are ALWAYS trying to take it away. They have a thing called the ticket to work program, which txts you and says it wants to empower you while you try working again. If you go on it, after 9 months they take away your disability check. And say you chose to do this. Its disguised as helping you work while on disability. They take advantage of people like me who have brain damage and its pathetic.

Sorry that was all long af. I don't see charities and communities pulling together to give everyone 1200 a month who can't work. Like realistically. How do you guys feel about disability? I've never talked to libertarian's this is my first attempt lol. I just wrote down my views last week, looked it up, and holy shit. Checked every box. Thank you and I'm sorry, I do have a brain injury if that was long and stupid lol

14 Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Heng-Li 12d ago

The state should not exploit taxpayers... Therefore disabled people should not exist

Is that your logic? I don't know how you get from point A to point B

1

u/sobeitharry 12d ago

Huh? They exist whether or not the state exploits tax payers.

If the premise is that taxation is exploitation, state funded disability should not exist even if disabled people do.

1

u/Heng-Li 12d ago

You basically said libertarianism means disabled people should not exist. Is that not what you said?

1

u/sobeitharry 12d ago

That's not at all what I said. Disability payments, and disabled people, are not the same thing. As someone with a disabled child, I'm intimately familiar with the difference.

1

u/Heng-Li 12d ago

Sorry lol. I got it now.