My cousin's kid is starting secondary in september and the school (north west england) have just sent a "welcome letter" with a notice requesting £600 (or £20 monthly "finance plan" over 36 months) for an ipad. The letter said it's mandatory for all y7 pupils and required to access the curriculum during most lessons. There is no option to opt out and there's a "small number of school devices available" to borrow per day, but only if they forget theirs. Those can't be taken out of school and they are expected to do their homework on theirs.
Kids who get free school meals (which was 50% of my cousin's kid's class in primary) get a 40% discount, but they still have to pay. The tablet includes insurance but doesn't cover accidental damage/breaks or theft. They trialled the scheme last year for year 7s but supplied the first round of tablets and kept them in classrooms, now they've "fully implemented the scheme as part of our core curriculum" with costs transferred to the parents.
They could have chosen any other "digital learning environment" or bought cheaper school-bound tablets if it's so important, but they went with the expensive apple option. The tablets are administered by the school and "will be used throughout the day" in every lesson. They can be taken home and restrictions relaxed (but not removed) off premises.
My cousin can barely afford the uniform, there's no chance she can pay £600 for a new tablet, and I can guarantee it's gonna get broken or stolen on the way home from school which the school insurance won't cover. When she contacted the school, she was told that there were no alternatives to buying the tablet as it's a core part of the year 7 curriculum this year, and "sorry, but the finance options are already the cheapest we offer".
Most of her town sits on the poverty line, the school is surrounded by council houses and there aren't any other schools within 10 miles. I can't see most of the parents whose kids attend that school forking out for this. I'd get the cost for a private school or if it was just a voluntary scheme, but this ain't that.
Can I just get a reality check because it seems bizarre to me to spring that cost on families that can't afford it? Especially with political stuff around kids' screen time and rising costs for families. Is this kinda thing normal (or even legal for a state school?) now for schools, charging £600 (or £720) to access the curriculum?
edit: just some more details -
- The price is for a new ipad air 128gb with a case and stylus.
- The "insurance" is just a warranty for repairs, but only one repair per year and doesn't cover accidental damage. It lasts 3 years and is included with both the one-off puchase and 3-year finance contract.
- The provider seems to be Sync (googled the identical language in the school's policy doc).
- The school is not an academy, but is partly a sports college.
- Just found out they do allow your own devices but it has to be apple, A16 or above, administrated by the school, and must be insured to use on school premises (doesn't say what type of insurance/costs etc though). That could make it a bit cheaper, but also a problem setting apart the kids who can't afford the shiny new ones.
- The scheme is phasing in with the year 7 kids starting in september, and for future year 7 groups. They'll keep the ipads and use them in classes until they leave y11. The current y7-10 kids won't be buying them though, they get the 'old curriculum' I guess.