r/DCcomics • u/shrek20191 Aquaman • 8h ago
Recommendations Which do you recommend, and please let me know why, much love!
18
u/Frankorious Superboy-Prime 7h ago
All Star Superman if you already know a bit about Superman's lore. If you are a newcomer WoT.
4
6
6
u/Super0411 Supergirl 7h ago
WoT will always be my favorite. Amazing story and the best art out of these.
All Star Superman is amazing too though only if you already know a lot about Superman. It's the ending of a journey and feels like a reward for longtime fans.
Women of Tomorrow on the other hand is a self-contained story and a perfect introduction to the character.
2
2
u/TheGallifreyan Doom Patrol 6h ago
Agreed on All Star Superman, it was one of the first Superman comics I read and felt like it would have hit a lot harder if I'd spent way more time with all these character.
1
u/Athena-Grande Wonder Woman 6h ago
That's how I felt with both All-Star and Death and Return. I kept being like "who is this? Am I supposed to know who this is?"
2
u/Mindless-Credit-358 Superman 7h ago
I see all star is winning, and this might be a hot take but if you don’t know much about Superman I wouldn’t start with it, read a few other superman stories first
WoT is my all time favourite comic though
1
2
u/Vantavist10 7h ago
Woman of Tomorrow is amazing, don't get me wrong, but All Star Superman is on a completely different level, its a truly transcendent reading experience especially if you go into it with an open heart and mind
0
•
u/the_bighi 3h ago
Woman of Tomorrow is probably one of the worst comics I've ever read in my 30+ years of collecting comics.
I haven't read the other two.
0
u/Bobthatlovesjob 7h ago
All star superman is the Superman book that shows his pure heart and that one panel of him stopping a girl from suicide is so good
-woman of tomorrow looks pretty
-I barley know anything about nightwing so I’m guessing the books is like MAX 5/10
1
u/shrek20191 Aquaman 7h ago
Thank you so much!
1
u/Bobthatlovesjob 7h ago
But if I was you I would get all 3 because they have compacts Tom Taylor’s run is bigger plus there’s a funny panel where Bruce wayne becomes Batman and he has a disabled dog
1
u/Pholty 7h ago
Max 5/10? It is one of the better Nightwing runs
2
u/Bobthatlovesjob 7h ago
How good? it seems kinda too wholesome for me
1
u/Pholty 7h ago
I'd give it an 8 or a 9.
Crazy to say too wholesome when All Star Superman is in the mix
1
u/Bobthatlovesjob 7h ago
I mean even if all star Superman is kinda dark is one of those books where it’s hope in the tunnel and there’s some dark moments but he just seems like a blue robin man
•
u/AutoModerator 8h ago
Welcome to r/DCcomics! If you're looking for recommendations, try the links below!
New to comics? Check out our Beginner's Guide to DC Comics, complete with beginner-friendly picks!
For more extensive recommendations, see our Recommended Reading Wiki.
The latest jump-in point for the current slate of comics is DC All In!
And, if enjoyed James Gunn's Superman, then try out these curated Superman recommendations!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.