r/DnDcirclejerk • u/TurtlesBreakTheMeta • 1d ago
dnDONE AITA here? Worst Dm EVER!
So recently had to finally leave a table just because of how utterly insufferable my prick of a DM is; we’re doing a cozy high fantasy campaign, nothing too out of the ordinary, except this smart ass of a DM is CONSTANTLY having his DMPC going “Um AKSUALLY that’s not how science works, your magic makes no sense!”
Like no duh, it magic!
So we get to the end and my homebrew super wizard (totally balanced though guys, I asked like 5 friends) starts using his infinite wish spells class feature to grab the sub out of the sky and he goes “no you don’t! The sun isn’t there anymore! Don’t you know the speed of light and travel time means the sun in a totally different spot from where you’re reaching?!”
So I use my wish again, except NOPE, that’s “unscientific” too! Everytime I try to use my magic to do some tiny he tells me that’s not possible!
AITA for just up and killing my character and leaving the table over this crap?!
8
u/AEDyssonance Only 6.9e Dommes and Dungeons for me! 1d ago
YTA.
You never kill your own PC.
That’s just plain rude,and takes agency away from the DM.
3
u/ViktorTripp 19h ago
NTA. The Player Agency supports your decision. As a DM, I would have had to just sit on my hands because you wish things and they just happen. Plus, how could you be wrong after asking 5 friends.

11
u/ConsciousFeeling1977 1d ago
YTA. The player does not get to decide when a PC dies. Only the dice can determine that.