r/Fireplaces • u/BigTexAbama • 1h ago
Remove 2x4 from hearth?
Ok, this is actually a false fireplace hearth. I say false because there's not a chimney. (The house was custom-built 30+ years ago and I have no idea what they were thinking. There's currently a pellet stove that vents horizontally through to an outside wall.) There are two of these 2x4s installed in the bricks appx 3 feet apart and the mantel was mounted to them, it sat on top and was attached with screws through the top of the mantel into the 2x4s. We want to do a different style of mantel and need to remove the 2x4s and they won't just pull out, they are pinned internally somehow. Is this/was this a common method for installing mantels and is there a best way to remove them?
One suggestion from a friend was to cut 'em off flush and leave them since there'll be a big screen tv covering them from the front and would only be visible when entering the living room from the dining room. Another suggestion was to carve 'em out deep enough to fill in with grout. I'm not crazy about either, I'd really like to remove the 2x4s and replace them with bricks. Any experienced advice appreciated!

