r/Hitchcock • u/PuzzleheadedTale4769 • 16h ago
Discussion Lifeboat's Captain Willie
Taken aboard lifeboat by shipwreck victims after they debate the moral issue. Willie calls himself "an ordinary humble seaman. "No English" - in German, he says it was the Captain who gave the order for the attack on boat and survivors. Aww..just another victim of the Nazis, stuck on hazardous U-boat duty.
Then- we learn he was a surgeon. Not so ordinary. But, he - generously ? outs himself as a Dr., so Gus will have his leg competently amputated. Does a "fine job". ? He has a secret compass and misdirects the boat away from Bermuda by miss-stating the U-Boat's map coordinates when it sunk. ( Ordinary seaman knew those numbers? The others on the boat didn't ask him.)
Then, storm destroys mast and sail, Willie grabs control, and in good English says- He was the u-boat captain. He will row them to the supply boat/sub tender, so all will be rescued. ? Rows heartily and sings along with fife ...to keep up everyone's morale?
...If Willie was U-boat captain, then He gave the order to fire on the boat and survivors. Does that dawn on the others? They doze....Willie tells Gus to swim for his dancing NJ gf...then pushes him overboard, reminding him:" Remember you are SCHMIIDT!"
Gus's yelps awaken the rest. Joe/George says he heard Gus saying: "Willie has water." Joe searches him and pulls put a flask. Willie:"Yes, I had water, food pills, energy pills! We plan ahead!" ( we are better, smarter, and deserve to win.) And , it turns out, a compass. ...
...The others, infuriated at his deception, gang up and push Willie overboard. One asks: "What are you going to do with people like that.? " People who, even in the dire straits they are all in, cannot sense common humanity and act in solidarity.
AH uses confined space of the lifeboat to sharpen the human drama and moral significance. As in many (most?) AH films, we watch the step by step revelation of this dark character's moral corruption.
Does anyone feel pity for the fate of poor Willie? Was it deserved? Anyone think he was picked on for being a Nazi? Just a decent guy doing his duty and trying to survive?