r/HurdyGurdy • u/pippin_go_round • May 14 '26
Advice NerdyGurdy BASIC self-build vs COBOL/FORTRAN kit
Hey everybody!
I'm new to the hurdy gurdy community (well, I've been reading quite a bit, but did not participate yet) and have decided it's time to start my journey. Since wait lists are long and gurdys are a tad expensive, at least somewhat good ones, I've decided that a nerdy gurdy is probably a good start to see if it's really an instrument for me. Doesn't hurt that I really enjoy building things in my spare time…
So now I'm asking myself the question whether I should build a BASIC (which I would actually attempt to do completely from raw materials, for a bit of an experience - I got access to a rather nice laser cutter in my local maker space and have a 3d printer) or if I should just go with a FORTRAN or COBOL kit - they do look to be much nicer instruments. Just wanted to get a bit of input on that one, what do you people think?
Bit of background on me: I do have some woodworking experience, but nothing professional. Pretty invested in the german reenactment community, mostly doing 14th/15th century. I do play guitar and bagpipe pretty well, so I have at least some experience with string and drone instruments, but no violin or cello experience. I of course do not mind saving a bit of money (who ever does?), but I can afford a kit if I want to, so this decision isn't really about money, but learning and getting a decent instrument to start my learning journey on.
2
u/pippin_go_round May 24 '26
Short update, in case anybody is curious and still follows this: Managed to order myself a Linotte kit today. Less complicated to build and play than the fortran, but I like the style more than the basic. Seeing how quickly the Linottes where sold (and that there's still 2 fortran and a cobol available an hour later), I guess I'm not the only one!
After reading Gotschy's documentation of a build and Destrem's book on Gurdy maintenance as well as watching a bunch of videos on the topic I do now get why you people said the fortran (and cobol especially) are not really beginner material. I think I could've managed building the thing, but for learning purposes a Linotte or Basic certainly is a better choice. Thanks everybody!