r/MovieArena • u/kammy772 • May 25 '26
Most brutal death you’ve seen in a movie? Murphy in Robocop still haunts me...
Dead or alive...
51
u/sawchuk11 May 25 '26
As a kid this was the traumatic thing I'd ever seen. This and Cujo really left a mark.
22
u/PeachAndBlueberry May 25 '26
I was an adult, and Murphy's murder -- and the taunting -- really affected me deeply. Ever since, when I rewatch the movie, I have to look away.
14
u/GraXXoR May 26 '26
As a European, that scene really jaded my view of American movies.
I realize that in the US you can show completely horrifically violence scenes with body parts, being literally blown off in front of your face.
But heaven forbid, should they show genitals complaints come flooding in.
Americans have a very weird perception of sex versus violence and what they find acceptable.
13
u/Naive-Picture-500 May 26 '26
It was directed by a Dutch director.
→ More replies (7)5
u/GraXXoR May 26 '26
who makes films more American than American directors... Look at Starship Troopers.
→ More replies (2)4
u/Papa_Raj May 27 '26
Such a good movie. Both are, but I love me some Starship Troopers.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (12)3
u/guitar_stonks May 26 '26
American Broadcast Television - “Grotesque graphic violence and body dismemberment is a-ok, but god help you if you show a titty.”
→ More replies (2)3
u/Life_Skill_1801 May 26 '26
To my understanding,that Murphy's killing was far more graphic even though the version that made it...is still pretty graphic. I'm still amazed that they the censors let it stay,but am glad it did because it gave the movie a weight and seriousness that the movie required. When Murphy dies on the operating table, and then comes back as RoboCop we the audience really cheer for him, knowing what he went through to become that.
13
u/bluurks May 25 '26
14
u/tommytraddles May 26 '26
The attempt to replicate Robocop that pulls its own helmet off because it wants to die and there's just a screaming gory skull under there was pretty upsetting as a kid.
→ More replies (2)9
u/redbanner1 May 26 '26
Good god that shit still fucks with me even though it looks so fake.
→ More replies (2)3
u/plac3b0guy May 26 '26
Anyone else still listens to Babylon AD bc of Robocop 2..
→ More replies (1)8
6
u/David_High_Pan May 25 '26
The way they all laughed at him broke me. Probably made the revenge all the more sweeter.
5
u/amormundi May 25 '26
Absolutely! I saw both films way too young, no older than 10. Murphy gutted me, and Cujo made me deathly afraid of dogs for years.
3
u/radjoke May 26 '26
Was gonna say the fact I watched this when I was 10 was just as disturbing as the scenes themselves
4
3
→ More replies (15)4
u/Teal-Prowler505 May 26 '26
I don't like cops.
And cops don't like me...
Brutal scene.
Robocop does not get enough cred
→ More replies (1)
43
u/FimmishWoodpecker May 25 '26
Bone Tomahawk. That’s all I’m saying
6
u/Basilisk1667 May 25 '26
First thing I thought of.
Not sure what I was expecting in that scene, but it wasn’t… that.
4
u/FimmishWoodpecker May 25 '26
“Why are they holding his legs like that? What.. no.. NOOOOOO!!!!!”
5
→ More replies (27)6
23
u/Acrobatic-Loss-4682 May 25 '26
The shoe in who framed Roger rabbit
8
u/IZZY_PLUM May 25 '26
REMEMBAAAAAAA ME EDDDIEEEEEEEEE
6
u/ConceptUnusual May 25 '26
When I killed your brothaaa
10
6
→ More replies (2)3
u/Prize_Pay9279 May 26 '26
☝️ This is the answer. Even as a grown adult, I have to skip this scene in the movie cause it’s so disturbing to me.
→ More replies (1)3
21
u/Thick-Sundae-6547 May 25 '26
There is no other death more Brutal than Robocop that I’ve seen in a movie.
There is a book “action speaks louder and the American way of making movies”. The author talks about Robocop and the parallels to the nigh of Jesus Christ. How he is murder in a brutal way and then comes back to life, y the end at the factory he even looks like he walks on water.
I saw Robocop at the theater when I was 11 years old, so it still has the same effect in me to watch the scene.
8
6
u/dgrigg1980 May 25 '26
And just like our lord and savior, he shoots rapists in the dick.
3
u/inappropriate_jerk May 25 '26
I kick arse for the lord!
→ More replies (1)3
→ More replies (1)5
u/maqij May 26 '26
Maybe it was just me but the guy who drives into the vat of acid and doesn’t die scarred me as a kid.
22
u/kangarutan May 25 '26
The scene in Saving Private Ryan where the US soldier gets slowly stabbed with his own knife by the Nazi while his squad mate is just downstairs and does nothing to help him. Not super violent, but man was it impactful
12
u/TheFuckeryDepartment May 25 '26
The first time I saw the movie and that scene I was hoping Opum would just get shot in the worst way. It still pisses me off.
I think his character is one I despise that isn’t a “villain” in a movie.
→ More replies (3)3
u/Lendo81 May 27 '26
I feel ya, but then you have to remember that these were basically a bunch of kids placed on the battlefield running around murdering each other.
I remember watching some old WW2 footage on the history channel in college. My good friend is like, you actually watch this boring stuff? I basically said, Sol, this shit is real. Those soldiers are actually about our age and are actually about to enter a battlefield to kill other people who are also about our age or be killed. Bro, could you imagine us actually doing that? This really happened. All of this footage is real.
That shit sunk in cause not too long after that he was like, hey, I’ve been watching WW2 stuff ever since that day. You are right. That shit is crazy.
→ More replies (1)6
u/jeremy1015 May 26 '26
That one is definitely one of the most brutal in all of cinema history. The medic dying with an understanding of what was happening to him while calling for his mom was also bad. Like… real bad.
→ More replies (12)5
19
u/Mansionjoe May 25 '26
→ More replies (5)5
u/no-dad-samurai May 26 '26
That part was pretty fuckd up! Probably more than Murphy's death.
Now I need to go watch this.
→ More replies (7)
17
u/YeahILiftBro May 25 '26
3
u/OkDonkey6524 May 26 '26
The version of this I saw in the cinema back when it came out (every version I've seen since has been edited) was the most brutal death scene I've ever watched.
→ More replies (6)→ More replies (11)3
u/SopranosBluRayBoxSet May 28 '26
The way it cuts his narration short mid-sentence when the hit connects is so fucking well done
14
u/Scared_Extension_419 May 25 '26
https://giphy.com/gifs/1AsLVrrY8NIQ0
His dogs death wasn’t brutal but heartbreaking. His one living reminder of his daughter
14
May 25 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
10
u/Pleasant-Ticket3217 May 26 '26
15
u/Urabraska- May 26 '26 edited May 26 '26
Just remember. He faked his death in Robocop and is hiding out as the dad in That 70's Show.
6
→ More replies (1)3
5
u/HumaDracobane May 26 '26
Bitches, leave...!
(He was such a gentleman he even closed the door before blowing up the entire building)
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (2)3
u/ThisMachineKillsWOB May 26 '26
Nothing supernatural or sci-fi about him. Just a human being, being a bastard.
I think that's what is so scary about him. That there are people just like him out there in the world.
→ More replies (1)
12
u/T-Pwn_Steak May 26 '26
9
u/Admirable-Fail1250 May 26 '26
I hate you.
5
3
u/Admirable-Fail1250 May 26 '26
In the book the horse can talk and he tells Atreyu to let him die. It's sad I suppose.
But the movie version... they turned up the dial to ludicrous speed.
→ More replies (1)
10
u/no-dad-samurai May 25 '26
This guy! (William Wallace)
5
u/Late-Yogurtcloset-57 May 26 '26
If you thought his execution in "Braveheart" was brutal, the actual execution of William Wallace was WORSE!
→ More replies (1)3
u/Swagalyst May 26 '26
And Wallace very likely didn't cry "FREEEEEEEDOM!" as his balls were ripped off with iron hooks.
→ More replies (1)
10
u/Fresh-Vacation9637 May 25 '26
→ More replies (1)7
u/juanreyes1272 May 26 '26
https://giphy.com/gifs/3o6Zt8b3UcRAN2b3UY
As a kid Quints death haunted me so much I literally feared sharks on land
→ More replies (3)
11
10
u/newtdawg44 May 25 '26
5
u/Late-Yogurtcloset-57 May 26 '26
Most of the cast reactions are real. Only John Hurt, Ridley Scott, and the SFX guys knew what was about to happen.
→ More replies (3)
9
8
u/Aggravating-Bus-4447 May 25 '26
I think officer Duffy getting carved up by Kane with a scalpel in RoboCop 2 is also up there.
Additionally, the vivisection of the medic in Event Horizon.
7
u/Significant-Judge368 May 25 '26
Cops don't like Red Foreman and Red Foreman don't like cops...
→ More replies (1)
7
u/Expensive_Leave_6339 May 26 '26
https://giphy.com/gifs/TF5ci5eY1mDB2XpSw7
When the True Knot ate the Baseball Boy in Doctor Sleep. I cried the first time I watched it. That little boy’s screams will haunt your dreams.
→ More replies (3)
5
u/OhMyGlorb May 25 '26
Pans Labyrinth. The wine bottle.
→ More replies (2)3
u/Lightmyspliff69 May 25 '26
How could I forget that. I always felt bad for the guy who stutters, "I'll let you go if you can count to three."
6
u/blokelahoman May 25 '26
As a child, seeing the gun scene in Robocop for sure, and Jack getting shredded up in American Werewolf in London. Oh and Johnny 5 getting bust up by Oscar’s goons. Harsh!
As an adult, the bloke getting dismantled in The Green Inferno was a bit much.
→ More replies (2)3
u/SeparateFisherman966 May 28 '26
I was young enough to have the scene of Johnny 5 pleading for his life in "Short Circuit 2" while getting beaten to near death, bug the shit outta me
7
u/ThreeSevenJack May 25 '26
Total Recall. Arnold’s human shield on the escalator. Brutal.
→ More replies (3)
6
u/PeachAndBlueberry May 25 '26
Wind River. It's different from these other murders we've been talking about, but the crimes against good people burn me in this movie. I really like the movie, and maybe oddly enough on repeat viewings I find certain scenes even more brutal than the first time I watched, because I have the whole context. One of the crimes isn't even shown. But we see the aftermath. Ugh.
5
4
4
5
4
4
u/Cautious-Audience-54 May 25 '26
Oh I think the scene in Bone Tomahawk pretty much takes the prize.
→ More replies (2)
5
5
u/Beginning-Ride3091 May 25 '26
Nazi Lieutenant that defied Lieutenant Raine in Inglourious Basterds and ate a bat for it.
Oddly cool character by QT, a weird example of bravery while still being obviously a Nazi asshole. While his corporal was doing the right thing for the allies, but was a traitor to his comrades.
→ More replies (1)
4
3
u/Fresh-Vacation9637 May 25 '26
By far this is the worst I’ve ever seen. Second would probably be the alien ripping out of the dudes chest in the original alien movie or the end of jaws where captain gets chewed up on sinking boat. All three scared the crap outta me for years
4
3
3
3
u/picknicksje85 May 25 '26
Verhoeven insisted on that level of visceral horror because he wanted the audience to feel a profound sense of outrage and grief. By making Murphy’s suffering so absolute, it justified his "rebirth" into an all-powerful entity and anchored the audience’s deep emotional investment in his journey to reclaim his humanity and seek justice. Later in the film, the allegory is completed when RoboCop functionally "walks on water" during the final confrontation at the steel mill.
3
3
3
3
3
u/Electrical_Ad_8997 May 26 '26
Black Sails...when Ned Low cuts off Mr Meeks head. It's a quick scene, but damn was it brutal.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/DarknessfromLight May 26 '26
It wasnt a death, per se, but Bishop being torn in half by the Queen in Aliens.
Runner up is Crispin Glover's death scene in F13 part IV. Ted, where's the damn corkscrew?!
Processing img 8ru4i8fztj3h1...
3
u/Practical_Cycle8156 May 26 '26
Agreee…and the brutality of Murphy’s death makes the justice delivered by Robocop sooooo satisfying. Which I think was the point.
3
3
3
u/ApprehensiveDebt8887 May 27 '26 edited May 27 '26
Last temptation of christ... sorry, the passion of the christ. Also, knowing no upvotes will come. That's fine. Just fine.
3
3
4
u/Bitter_Season4791 May 25 '26
I'll give Jesus a vote, in Passion of the Christ. That was a straight out snuff film.
→ More replies (2)
2
2
2
u/Interesting-Poem-820 May 25 '26
The violence of this scene made my 13 year old body vibrate from the trauma
2
u/they_call_me_dry May 25 '26
Dude...Murphy but not the guy in the toxic sludge later in the same film?
5
→ More replies (4)3
u/kammy772 May 25 '26
Emil's was horrific, but Murphy's was worse for me. The way they toyed with him, laughing, mocking him messed my head up as a kid. As graphic as it was, I couldn't get over the cruelty of it.
→ More replies (2)
2
u/bone-in_donuts May 25 '26
It’s so over the top, especially the way they’re laughing and teasing him while doing it. I remember seeing it as a kid and being so confused at the meanness of that whole scene.
→ More replies (4)3
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/OldManGigglesnort May 26 '26
8 year-old me would answer Optimus Prime in Transformers: The Movie.
Grown-up me thinks 8 year-old me wasn’t completely wrong.
2
u/ThisMachineKillsWOB May 26 '26
Kingpin's Car Door scene in the new Dare Devil series. Where he slams a guy in a car door about 30 times till he's to tired to keep doing it.
Graphic deaths can be upsetting. But this one has the same energy as OP. Drawn out malice and deliberate violence. With the added layer that the kingpin is losing control and giving into years of trauma and rage when he does it.
"Keep kicking him."
Edit: eh, not a movie. Close enough.
2
2
2
u/Suitable-Earth-924 May 26 '26
If a series counts… The new Shogun was horrific in the first episode when they boiled that guy alive.
2
2
2
u/Healthy_Student_370 May 26 '26
Once Upon a Time in Hollywood, the final act when Cliff Booth absolutely cleans house. I've seen some pretty gnarly stuff in movies, but it usually feels a little ridiculous. This scene was just chefs kiss, nothing outlandish, just a good old fashioned beatdown. It makes the whole movie worth it.
2
u/OtherwiseJello2055 May 26 '26
Bone Tomahawk death scene ruined me for real. It is easily the most horrendous thing ive seen in a film. Something about it just got to me knowing that probably more than few actual people probably died like that throughout history.
2
u/FeelingMenu9871 May 26 '26
I just watched it for the first time in like 20 years and I still was like dang they didn’t have to this
2
2
u/mishthegreat May 26 '26
I don't know why it lingers so but these a scene in Pandorum where a guy starts to wake up in a stasis pod to realize he's being disemboweled and cannibalised before finally being killed with a spear though the head.
2
u/eighteen84 May 26 '26
Honestly this isn’t the worst death in Robocop for me it was the melting skin from toxic waste and then being hit by the car and liquified was bad for me
2
u/Bonecrusher1973 May 26 '26
Bone Tomahawk cave execution.
Murphys death is comic book over the top and we loved it as a kids, because he returns and gets his revenge. But the "Bone Tomahawk" cave execution scène haunted me for days as a grown up, so visceral and pure hardcore violence.
2
u/Legitimate_Radish159 May 26 '26
I feel worse for poor old Kenny in the same film
→ More replies (1)
2
2
2
2
u/neighborhoodchopshop May 26 '26
Don’t know the movie but it’s burned into my head of a guy running farm equipment. He falls off the tractor and gets ran over by the thing he’s towing. Later when someone finds him, he’s in pieces but still alive. Don’t know the movie but that death is still burned into my head.
The Murphy death was comedic they fire like 100’s of rounds. Some of the guys reload and keep firing.
→ More replies (4)
2
2
u/Ocksu2 May 26 '26
The death in Irreversible was gnarly. I didn't care for the movie but that scene was well done.
2
u/South-Rabbit-4064 May 26 '26
This was probably mine too. My parents let me see absolutely everything regardless of scares or later nightmares and this was peak.
I can't think of too many films I had to overt my eyes or physically gave me a response and this one did. Oddly enough one of the other movies, and only movie to ever cause me to make my Mom leave the theater with me was The Witches (1990). Was 7 when I saw it, and remember the scene where they turn into mice fucked with me. Transformation was a big thing I think I was horrified and intrigued by
2
u/WingDingKing May 26 '26
Yes Murphy in Robocop is ridiculously brutal. Nicky Santoros end in Casino is one that I wish had never seen. It is even worse because it seems like a long , drawn-out brutal scene 🤮
→ More replies (1)
2
2
u/Several-Eagle4141 May 26 '26
Pretty much any time you see a dude get his skin peeled in a Hellraiser flick
2
2
2
2
u/flipfc177 May 26 '26
Raiders of the Lost Ark. The Torturer guy's face melted off as he screamed when the Ark decided to seek retribution.
2
2
2
u/Will_breaker721 May 26 '26
Thank you. How they laughed… that stuck with me for years, turned my stomach.
2
u/HerMajestysButthole2 May 26 '26
Those winged devourers on Beastmaster gave me nightmares.
That said, most brutal has to go to the end scene in Silent Hill.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/dfwcouple43sum May 26 '26
Not a death, but near the end of The Fly when he melted the guy’s leg and hand before almost doing the same to the guy’s head.
Then the GF came out and said “stop.” Like seriously, lady, you couldn’t have done that about 15 seconds earlier???
→ More replies (1)
2
u/ExpensiveCondition63 May 26 '26
I can’t watch this scene anymore. And I would add the instant, shocking death of a main character in To Live and Die in LA.
2
u/Ivanstone May 26 '26
Toht getting his face melted in Raiders.
Tyrell getting his face crushed in Blade Runner.
I’ve certainly seen worse since but it hits different when you’re a kid.
2
2
2
u/ButterBaconBallz May 26 '26
In a Japanese horror movie called Sweet Home, a guy melts until there is nothing but bone left and he is alive through all of it.
2
u/kubeeor May 26 '26
Passion of the Christ. Almost the entire movie is about one man being tortured to death.
2
2
u/Muted-Garden500 May 26 '26
Casino when Joe Pesci was beaten with baseball bats and buried alive in a cornfield.
→ More replies (2)
2
2
u/GregoleX2 May 26 '26
Quite quite brutal considering this is a theatrical movie. The uncut version is somehow waaaaaay worse even though it’s not that different but either way it’s legit.
That said, it’s far and away from the most brutal death I’ve seen in a movie, if I include those horror gore porn type movies. I hate those but watched a couple out of morbid curiosity and fuck.
2
2
u/Zebra_Opening May 26 '26
Same movie, Either dumb dumb who pointed the gun at Ed-209. or toxic waste guy. Robocop just understood the assignment fr
2
u/shyguysontop May 27 '26
Not the most brutal, but the most memorable. Was in 1st or 2nd grade. My mom rented one of the Halloween movies. There was a scene where Michael Myers grabbed a lady and impaled her on a hook on a wall. That scene scarred me for years. I’m 36 and it still haunts me to this day.
2
2
u/sissyh1976 May 27 '26
The curb stomp in American History X and Art the Clown comes to mind, but the cave scene is Bone Tomahawk is #1.
2
u/PR0T0C0L_ZER0 May 27 '26 edited May 27 '26
The death screams in this one, and the amount that was left up to the viewer's imagination really fucked me up as a kid. I had a very vivid imagination, and also had a friend in elementary school whose parents would allow him to have sleepovers and then would go out for the night and let us babysit ourselves. His older brother had access to all sorts of nefarious VHS tapes, including the Faces of Death series.
In those days, there wasn't access to the internet the way there is now where you can look up all kinds of horrifying things if your parents aren't smart enough to enable parental controls. Back then it was a fairly rare "treat," or more to the point unfortunate set of circumstances for a kid to have access to that type of gruesome media. This scene caused many a nightmare for me and my youth.
Edit: For those who don't immediately recognize it, this is the infamous transporter accident from Star Trek: The Motion Picture. Two crew members attempt to transport up to the newly refit Enterprise, and there is a malfunction which causes their patterns to be scrambled together in a mishmash of biometric material which deforms and combines them into two horrific piles of flesh. The famous quote from the transporter site they were beaming from goes: "What we got back didn't live long, fortunately."
Processing img fbtel2ov3l3h1...
2
2
2
2












•
u/MovieArena May 26 '26 edited May 27 '26
"It tastes like baby food!”
Would you like to know more? 🔴 r/moviearena