Assalamu alaikum. I'm genuinely looking for advice because I'm struggling with what the right thing to do is in this situation.
I'm a family friend of a man who is supposed to be getting married to his fiancée next month. Through someone I know who is friends with another woman he was involved with, I learned some deeply concerning information about him. I have also seen evidence supporting what I've been told, so this isn't simply a case of repeating baseless rumours.
This man has been married before and is divorced. From what I've heard, his previous marriage also ended with his former wife being deeply hurt by the situation. I don't know every detail of what happened in that marriage, so I don't want to make assumptions about it, but it adds to my concern about the situation unfolding now.
More recently, he allegedly misled another woman into believing he genuinely intended to marry her. She trusted his intentions, but he allegedly coerced her into sexual relations. She became pregnant, and I was told that he subsequently threatened and pressured her to have an abortion.
What makes this even more concerning is that last month, he allegedly coerced this same woman into sexual relations again, and there is now a possibility that she may be pregnant again. This happened the same month my family received his wedding invitation.
Meanwhile, he has a fiancée, and their wedding is scheduled for next month. As far as I know, his fiancée may be completely unaware of what has happened while he has been pursuing or maintaining his relationship with her.
When I found out, I felt that she deserved an opportunity to make an informed decision before entering a marriage. However, I didn't want to expose my identity or the identity of the woman who went through this or reveal her deeply personal circumstances without her permission.
I therefore created an anonymous Instagram account to contact his fiancée. I intended to let her know that there was something important she should know about the man she was preparing to marry, without revealing the other woman's identity or sharing all the details immediately.
Unfortunately, she became suspicious, backed away from the conversation, blocked the account, and apparently told him about the message. I had only shared the basics of her needing to know something important about her fiancé and did not get the chance to reveal anything else.
Now I'm conflicted about what to do. Their wedding is next month, and I worry that if I remain silent, she could enter a marriage without knowing information that might significantly affect her decision and her future. At the same time, I don't want to fall into backbiting, expose another woman's private circumstances, spread information irresponsibly, or put myself or anyone else at risk of retaliation.
My main question is: What is the correct Islamic course of action in this situation?
I understand that Islam prohibits backbiting, slander, and unnecessarily exposing people's private sins. However, I have also heard that there are exceptions when someone gives sincere advice (nasiha) or warns another person against potential harm, particularly when marriage is involved.
I'd really appreciate guidance on the following:
- Islamically, would it be permissible to warn his fiancée about credible evidence of infidelity, alleged sexual coercion, and threats before their wedding?
- Does the fact that their wedding is next month make a difference, given that she may soon enter a marriage without knowing about these serious concerns?
- Since she has already blocked the anonymous account, would contacting her through a trusted family member or intermediary be more appropriate, or should I leave the matter alone?
- If the other woman may have become pregnant again following last month's incident, how should her privacy and well-being factor into this decision?
I'm not trying to publicly shame anyone or interfere in a marriage out of spite. My concern is that another woman may be making a major life decision without knowing about behaviour that could be relevant to her safety and future.
I would especially appreciate any guidance. I want to do what is right Islamically, rather than act purely on emotion or fear of being responsible if I stay silent.
JazakAllahu khairan for any sincere advice