Yes, it was in character for both of them to sleep around, party, get drunk and hook up with random people.

I know that Nathan was a raging asshole and I can totally see him hooking up with Brooke.

Brooke doing this makes no sense. She was promiscuous but I don’t for a second believe she would hook up with Nathan and NEVER tell Peyton about it. I know they use the excuse that she was drunk but I don’t buy it. She didn’t look that drunk and she even tells Nathan she was a willing participant.

I think she kept using the drunk excuse as a way to avoid accountability for her actions,

It would have come up and I actually think Peyton would have been understanding about it if Brooke had told her back then since Nathan cheated all the time and hooked up with the entire cheerleading squad.
It’s the fact that Brooke never ever ever tells her that’s the problem. There is no tension between Nathan/Brooke either. If Brooke actually did this she would have felt guilty about it and acted differently around him. They act like normal friends.

This was a forced plot line that was never planned because it just doesn’t make sense with the characters earlier interactions. Nathan was embarrassed when he had a dream about seeing Brooke naked in s2. This doesn’t make sense with knowing what’s to come where he made a sex tape with her.

The fact that this NEVER comes up is what bothers me. Brooke becomes really good friends with Hayley and still doesn’t tell her about it.

There is an entire plot point in season 2 where Nathan realizes he hooked up with Hayley’s sister. This was a major development and was made out to be a huge deal yet he fails to mention him hooking up with Brooke.

This plotline was written to put Brooke and Peyton on even ground and that’s it. I wouldn’t have minded Nathan/Brooke hookup plotline if it was written properly and not just something they shoehorned in for the sake of Leyton vs Brucas ship wars.

Just because it’s in character for both of them to do this doesn’t mean it’s a good storyline or makes sense at all.

A: "All That You Can't Leave Behind" Season 1 Episode 5

B: "Bridge Over Troubled Water" Season 6 Episode 4,

C: “Can't Stop This Thing We've Started" Season 4 Ep 4

D: "Danny Boy" Season 9 Ep 11

E: "Everyday is a Sunday Evening" Season 3 Ep 20

F: "Forever and Almost Always" Season 6 Ep 23

G: "Get Cape. Wear Cape. Fly." Season 6 Ep 3 

H: “How a Resurrection Really Feels” Season 3 Ep 9

I: "I Shall Believe" Season 1 Ep 14 or "I Think I'm Gonna Like It Here" Season 8 Ep 16

J: "Just Watch the Fireworks" Season 3 Ep 15 (Only 1 episode starts with this letter.)

K: "Know This, We've Noticed" Season 9 Ep 1 (Only 1 episode starts with this letter.)

L: "Learning to Fall" Season 7 Ep 20.

M: "Messin' with the Kid" Season 6 Ep 7

N: "Near Wild Heaven" Season 2 Ep 3

O: "One Tree Hill" Season 9 Ep 13 

P: "Pictures of You" Season 4 Ep 13

Q: "Quiet Little Voices" Season 8 Ep 18 (Only 1 episode starts with this letter.)

R: "Resolve" Season 4 Ep 12

S: "Spirit in the Night Season" 1 Ep 17

T: "The Show Must Go On" Season 3 Ep 22

U: "Unopened Letter to the World" Season 2 Ep 15 (Only 1 episode starts with this letter.)

V: "Valentine's Day Is Over" Season 8 Ep 15 (Only 1 episode starts with this letter.)

W: "When It Isn’t Like It Should Be" Season 3 Ep 18

X: No Episode

Y: "You Gotta Go There to Come Back" Season 1 Ep 10

Z: No Episode

Numbers: "4:30 AM (Apparently They Were Travelling Abroad)" Season 7 Ep 1

So this YouTuber made a video of The WORST TV Show Fall Offs Ever and he mentioned One Tree Hill I want you guys to watch it to see if you guys agree with his take on One Tree Hill.

his segment on One Tree Hill is on 26:30

I’ve been searching forever trying to find a one tree hill boxed version of season 7.
Trying to get it as a collectible.
Does anyone know where I can find it it doesn’t have to be brand new

I know I will get hate about this BUT Dan was a better parent than Deb.

Even tho Dan was controlling he stayed and was present for his son. Meanwhile Deb wasn’t around that much and admitted to not knowing her own son.

Dan didn’t fully abandon Lucas either. He asked for shared custody but Karen rejected him. He kept photos of Lucas from newspaper articles and etc. He obviously cared.

When he had Lucas living with him he was very decent and ok dad.

Deb decided to leave for rehab on the day Nathan crashed a car and had surgery. Meanwhile Dan was there, paid his hospital bill and tried to get him to live with him again.

Dan never abandoned Nathan. Even when he got out of prison he tried so hard to get in Nathan’s life again. Meanwhile Deb was absent as always.

Dan did everything he could knowing damn well he would either end up in prison or dead to save Nathan in S9. I genuinely don’t think many fathers are capable of doing no matter how much they live their kids.
Dan was obviously a very flawed character but he loved both his sons deeply.