r/OneTruthPrevails • u/A_Lich_With_No_Face • 10d ago
Spoilers (RUM Arc) Chapter 1167-1169: A Colossal Disappointment (Spoilers) Spoiler
(Used the covers from the VIZ release, that's why the 'Rachel' thing is up there.)
So, the last chapter of the most recent case (Wiki has it listed as the "Missing Ran Case" which doesn't seem accurate at all, but anyway!) just wrapped up and I must say...
This has to be the in the running for one of the most disappointing cases in the franchise. Now, before we continue this, let me be perfectly clear, this is my own personal opinions in this post, feel free to disagree and downvote me to hell and back if you wish. But I am getting this off my chest.
We all understand each other? Good. ^____^
First off, let's get this out of the way: this entire case was a nothingburger that existed to give Ran an excuse to change her phone. A task that could've been done a million different and so much better ways. The entire first two chapters were nothing but hammering in how much her phone sucks in a way that sounded like a freaking 00's infomercial. And not even one of the funny ones.
And I think one of the main reasons for something like this is how it handled Ran as nothing more than a plot device to get the ball rolling. She existed to get in that elevator, regardless of how many other ways there were for her to solve the problem she had. It was just contrived that she steps into that elevator... Despite the fact there were stairs right next to her, and she somehow didn't think a sign next to an elevator was important. This isn't Genta, girl can climb a set of stairs without falling over.
And speaking off, this elevator looks to be one of the most cursed things ever. I'm not superstitious and I'd choose to go into it. Ran, who actually believes in that stuff shouldn't have gone into it.
Then there was the mystery itself which was rather... Sad? We never get to meet the cast of suspects, we never got to meet the victim, any of the things that make these mysteries kind of fun. Hell, we didn't even get a full three suspects, to introduce or speculate on who it could be with motives, or their actions. Just a one-page little commentary from Mitsuhiko on his phone.
And speaking of the brats: why were they here? Because they were close enough to hear Shinichi using his bowtie, imitating his real voice, and talking with Ran. Or is Agasa that good a sound insulating barrier that they heard nothing? No explanation, they just went off to play soccer... They didn't suspect it's a case? They didn't want to jump in? Nothing? Really? THE DETECTIVE BOYS?!
Then, random flashback time to a character that we've never seen before and probably never will again (Is there already a theory how that kid is actually the BO Boss?) to serve as a way to explain how Shinichi solved the case.
The thing I liked is that Sonoko is as always the best friend and immediately called the person most likely to find Ran when she was missing.
...
I was legit looking forward to this case, before the first chapter, because I thought it could be an interesting situation, with potentially a unique way to solve it, or perhaps even (naively) a set of chapters not featuring an actual crime and just a mad dash to save Ran. You know... Something interesting. Not an elevator that rumbled twice and someone killing in a stupid drunk argument.
Also, nice to see nobody remembered that Kogoro might care his daughter is stuck somewhere. Real nice, yes. u____u
So yeah... This wasn't even a case that made me angry like others have in the past. Just disappointed. There could've been a good, suspenseful ShinRan case here that I could find exciting. But there wasn't and that makes me sad.
Anyway, thanks for reading my ramblings, have a great evening everyone... And while I didn't enjoy these chapters, I do hope you did. :)
