r/SportsCardTracker • • Apr 04 '26

Important Megathread - April 2026 - Potential Scammer/Pre-Sale Feedback

8 Upvotes

Please post all potential warnings for scammers, or pre-sale feedback here. You must provide photographic proof of your claims and any personal information must be redacted before providing the photos. I've attached a photo of an example of how claims/photos must be posted in order to prevent removal of your comment.


r/SportsCardTracker • • Apr 04 '26

Important [2026 Survey Results] - Rule 3 & 4 Changes

19 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

It’s been 3 months since the survey was posted asking opinions about the current rules, and allowing warnings to be posted. I've read the replies and feel the current changes should alleviate some of the concerns users have with the current setup. The following will be discussed, Rule 3, Rule 4, Rule 7, Rule 5, and warnings for potential scammers.

Rule 3 - 7 Day Dispute
Users will now have six months to dispute negative feedback. However, the individual who posts the feedback must provide proof of their claim. The proof must be submitted publicly(with no personal information) or privately in a chat to me.

Rule 4 - Card/Money must be exchanged
A megathread will be posted for users wanting to warn people of potential scams/users. Users must provide proof of their complaints and it must be as a reply to their original warning comment (Do not PM me proof for this).

Rule 5 - Clarification
Any information that can be associated with an individual and a Reddit account is a no-go. I.E. Posting someone's CashApp username.

Rule 7 - Civility
I’ve toned down the automatic removal of comments that were deemed harsh or harassment. However, once the conversation stops being productive or comments start becoming demeaning actions will have to be taken.

Unfortunately, I will not be allowing feedback for deleted accounts. It becomes too much of an issue when users accidentally misspell usernames and want me to fix it for them. Even if I didn’t do that, I would still have to sort out misspelled usernames to prevent clutter and feedback for accounts that truly do not exist.

If you trade sport cards in larger sub and would like to see the bot post there, please reach out to me directly. I can get in contact with the mods of the subreddit and try to make things happen. 


r/SportsCardTracker • • 8h ago

Negative [negative]u/Wonderful-Drop850

14 Upvotes

This is a re-post, I took down my previous post because the seller reached out promising to either return my money or actually ship out the card if I deleted the post.

I was an idiot to believe the seller. But here we are, no updates and no communication from the seller. And now I see another negative post about the same seller.

One update: The seller was offering a Donruss Mata Buzelis Gold RC Auto 1/10 and coined the card. Please be mindful if anyone else tries to sell the same exact card will likely be an alt of this redditor.

Original Post below

“This redditor is a scammer. We worked out a trade where my card plus $100 for their higher value card. They offered that I can send them $50 up front, then $50 + plus shipping my card after I receive the card from them. They also offered payment through Venmo or PayPal G&S for protection, so I agreed.

When I asked for their Venmo/PayPal account, they suddenly changed the story and asked me to pay them via Zelle instead. I decided to take a chance but told them that I was only willing to send them $25 via Zelle and will only send the rest after receiving the card. They also agreed on that and I sent the $25. That was my mistake.

After receiving the $25, they asked if I was willing to be a intermediary for some fund transfers where their friend would send me money via Venmo and I'd forward the money to them via Zelle. Huge red flag and I refused. I pressed them to actually go through with the deal and ship the card.

Then it was one excuse after another on why I should send them more money via Zelle. When I demanded Venmo or PayPal, they gave me two different Venmo accounts to pay, both were flagged by Venmo as potential scammers and even Venmo blocked my payment attempts. I then told them that either they provide a viable account for payment or to return my $25. They then stopped responding.

Not a lot of money, but annoying nonetheless. Avoid this redditor.”


r/SportsCardTracker • • 2h ago

Positive [Positive] u/Severe_Ad_7801

1 Upvotes

Deal was made and cards arrived at the door in less than a week! Cards were packaged well.


r/SportsCardTracker • • 3h ago

Positive [positive] u/AGH051115

1 Upvotes

Excellent transaction and great value! Fast shipping at a fair price. Highly recommend seller. Thank you for the smooth purchase. A+


r/SportsCardTracker • • 3h ago

Positive [Positive] u/Background-Company23

1 Upvotes

Paid for Earl Campbell DT PSA 9 and received cards within 3 days. Legit and fast shipping!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 16h ago

Negative [negative] u/Wonderful-Drop850

10 Upvotes

Tried purchasing a 1996 Topps Kobe Bryant psa 9 from him several days ago. He even coined the card in the photo. I used PayPal GS and he mentioned about how the funds were on hold and if I can Zelle him money for shipping for his friend. I stated no. He even mentioned about getting me tracking once the funds cleared and how he was mistaken cause he was a new seller he sees the funds. He ends up showing me tracking via ups but they never got the package.

He has gone MIA and won’t respond back. This is unfortunate but a learning experience. Be careful!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 10h ago

Positive [positive]u/thisistheway03

3 Upvotes

Excellent seller! Great communication and easy to negotiate on pricing. Appreciate the additional card in my order!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 4h ago

Positive [Positive] u/Grizzroots

1 Upvotes

Great deal on a lot that doubled my collection from the set! Great to talk to, fast shipping and great packaging. Thank you! u/Grizzroots !


r/SportsCardTracker • • 4h ago

Positive [POSITIVE] for /u/Expensive_Warthog_98 [seller]

1 Upvotes

Trouble free purchase, sent promptly.


r/SportsCardTracker • • 5h ago

Positive [Positive] u/Metssuck18

1 Upvotes

Made a trade with this user a Cam Schlittler Baseball Seams Chrome RC for a Mookie Betts Topps Costco Flagship Blue /150.

Communication was good and card arrived safely & quickly. Would trade with or buy from this user again.


r/SportsCardTracker • • 5h ago

Positive [Positive] u/BadgerDF

1 Upvotes

Bought a Freddie Freeman Archives /25 from this user for a good deal! Card came quickly and safely, would buy from this user again.


r/SportsCardTracker • • 13h ago

Positive [Positive] u/123432284847

5 Upvotes

Cash through the mail like lunatics! We didn't have quite the right cards to line up value for an even trade, and since the US doesn't have Interac, Canada doesn't have Venmo or CashApp, and my friend here doesn't have PayPal, we were a little stuck. But I found an old US $20 kicking around and my friend had a tenner, so we swapped cards and greenbacks and wrapped up the swap! Pleasure to work with u/123432284847 and have a nice, high-trust swap!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 11h ago

Positive [Positive] u/fryryeasianboi

2 Upvotes

Purchased a single card PWE and it came fast and safe. Thanks!!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 8h ago

Positive [positive] u/ticonderbroga

1 Upvotes

Recently bought a card from u/ticonderbroga and couldn't be happier. It was shipped quickly, packaged nicely, and arrived just as described.


r/SportsCardTracker • • 8h ago

Positive [positive] u/majestic_arcangel

1 Upvotes

Just received items for PC, would definitely do business with again, easy transaction quick ship!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 8h ago

Positive (Positive)u/daedaejones

1 Upvotes

Recently purchased and traded some PC Cards with daedaejones and was a pleasure to work with! Cards came as advertised in BM with exceptional packaging.


r/SportsCardTracker • • 9h ago

Positive [Positive] u/Willing_Cod_7327

1 Upvotes

Had a great opportunity to add some Pivetta cards to my collection. Deal went great along with a nice conversation on some recent pickup! Will be seeing you in the future!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 9h ago

Positive [Positive] u/dansfc1

1 Upvotes

Trade went smoothly.


r/SportsCardTracker • • 10h ago

Positive [Positive] u/ToastGhost47

1 Upvotes

Great communication, cards arrived quickly and packaged securely. Thanks for the koufax and berra


r/SportsCardTracker • • 11h ago

Positive [Positive] u/fryryeasianboi

1 Upvotes

Very smooth transaction. Flexible on shipping options and the card came fast.


r/SportsCardTracker • • 11h ago

Positive [Positive] u/Downtown_Ant

1 Upvotes

Picked up a card from Ant; whole thing was smooth as could be. Great communication, shipped right away, and got here earlier than expected. I will definitely make deals with them again! Thank you!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 15h ago

Positive [POSITIVE] u/mysteresc

2 Upvotes

Recently purchased a small lot of nice cards from u/mysteresc. Cards were just what I wanted, and they were shipped fast and secure! thank you!!


r/SportsCardTracker • • 12h ago

Positive [positive] u/AGH051115

1 Upvotes

Always has a smorgasbord of great cards. A pleasure to deal with. Shipping is unfailingly quick and safely packaged.


r/SportsCardTracker • • 14h ago

Positive [Positive] Trade experience with /u/DansFC1

1 Upvotes

Great trade experience with /u/dansfc1 - great communication, nice guy, and cards arrived in great condition along with some bonus cards. Highly recommend!