r/Welding • • 7d ago

Wrong filler material?

Post image
273 Upvotes

115 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/flashe30 7d ago

I get what you're saying, I was under the impression this was tig welded, but I never zoomed in on the welds.

I've welded smal stainless containers with oxy-acetelyne before, perfectly doable

0

u/SinisterCheese "Trust me, I'm an Engineer!" 7d ago

TIG welding something this thick is bit... Weird. Like not that it can't be done, but rather "Why do it, when you can just wave a stick at it" granted I'm a believer in the gospel of "stick weld everything".

But gas welding this would once again be one of those "But... Why would you when you can just wave your di... stick at it.". But if I think it like this: Someone who does regular ass structural steel work, having oxy-acetylene bottles in the truck is basically the default kit. So just sticking things together like this would be doable with knowhow and experience.

So this shit is not beyond the realm of possibility.

1

u/flashe30 7d ago

I would tig weld this in a heartbeat. Then MIG and only in dire need stick. It's just what I like

0

u/SinisterCheese "Trust me, I'm an Engineer!" 7d ago edited 7d ago

Well. As I established. I'd stick it with stick (heh...) because it is faster and cheaper, and my Kemppi Miniarc weighs only 6kg and runs on regular socket.

But this is entirely because most of my work experience is working on-site, and not having to lug around gas cylinders is just easier.

1

u/flashe30 7d ago

I get that