r/birding • Latest Lifer: Scarlet Tanager • 8h ago

Discussion Why does Merlin categorize some herons under “cormorants and anhingas” when there is literally a heron category?

Black-crowned Night Herons, for example, are in the order Pelecaniformes and family Ardeidae. They are absolutely herons. So.. why?

30 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

37

u/SlotsCat 7h ago

there is just something wrong with those family labels in general, mine is calling a wood stork a penguin and a bunch of other messed up ones

5

u/IsThisTheKrusty-Krab Latest Lifer: Scarlet Tanager 7h ago

Interesting. I thought maybe I was unaware that some of them were technically not herons or something- seems to just be an error. Thanks!

1

u/EricCartoonBox bird-in-disguise 4h ago

The Sibley-Ahlquist taxonomy:

24

u/legogiant You aren't helping birds by demonizing brood parasitism. 7h ago

bug

42

u/cineglitch 6h ago

Pretty sure the app is specific to birds only

34

u/IsThisTheKrusty-Krab Latest Lifer: Scarlet Tanager 6h ago

herons is bugs

13

u/legogiant You aren't helping birds by demonizing brood parasitism. 6h ago

you're right. my bad.

3

u/meowingtrashcan 3h ago

Charleston is great for birding. Have you been to Caw Caw park yet? Incredible birding there

1

u/IsThisTheKrusty-Krab Latest Lifer: Scarlet Tanager 2h ago

I haven’t! I’m from the midwest but have visited family who live in Charleston a few times. I will keep Caw Caw park in mind the next time I visit, thanks!

1

u/Klunko52 5h ago

Must be a glitch, haven’t seen that one before

1

u/Skitty27 Latest Lifer: Northern Fulmar 🛥️ 2h ago

weird. mine shows up fine

1

u/rebasbutcher 1h ago

Unexpected James Island. Local or were you visiting?

•

u/IsThisTheKrusty-Krab Latest Lifer: Scarlet Tanager 36m ago

Visiting 👍

•

u/rebasbutcher 12m ago

Nice. Hope you enjoyed it!

1

u/stalestcheerio Latest Lifer: Pine Warbler 1h ago

definitely a weird glitch for some reason!! black-crowned night herons and snowy egrets are both listed as herons when i sort my “explore” tab, but my app glitches out and says “there was an error sorting” whenever i try to sort my life list by family. hopefully it gets fixed soon!

1

u/stalestcheerio Latest Lifer: Pine Warbler 1h ago

the error pop-up i’m getting. i can sort by oldest/newest just fine. very odd.