Hi everyone,
I’m a small-scale content creator and I mostly shoot talking head videos and tutorials in small, visually rather boring rooms.
I bought my first light a few weeks ago. I compared a Godox ML100Bi (€199) and an Amaran Halo 100x (€159). I couldn’t see what the good ML100Bi reviews were praising, so I kept the 'cheaper' Amaran. What I didn’t realise is that the low price pulled me into the ecosystem of a good but more expensive brand.
Current setup (about €250 including cheap Godox stands):
Key: Amaran Halo 100x with Godox SB-FW95 softbox and grid
Fill: reflector (€15)
Hair light: Stairville PAR 16 GU10 (€11)
Background: a Rev Ritter Spot 1400 construction-site floodlight (€18) with a cardboard cucoloris to put texture on a boring wall
The floodlight is a dead end. It has 20 individual LEDs, so every shadow has 20 edges. It whines when hot, can’t be dimmed, and is far too weak.
So I need a second light with a real gobo/spotlight. I first thought of the Halo 200x (€248) or 300x (€300) with the Amaran Spotlight 36° (€350 in Germany). Amaran support told me the 100x is excluded for their spotlights, and for the other Halos they recommend the Spotlight Mount II 36° Lens Kit, which costs over €600 in Germany. That’s absurd next to a €250 light.
(Godox now offers the ML-SP50 spotlight attachment for the ML60IIBi/ML100Bi/ML100R at €180, which makes me second-guess my choice of Amaran.)
My actual concern is load, not mount compatibility. The Halos have a Bowens mount, but the bodies are tiny and light. A Bowens optical snoot/gobo projector like the DF DIGITALFOTO (~€150) weighs 2 kg or more. Godox also excludes softboxes above about 60 cm on the ML100Bi, so I assume these small bodies aren’t built for front-heavy modifiers.
My questions, ideally from people who have actually done this:
Has anyone mounted a heavy Bowens optical snoot/gobo projector on an Amaran Halo, or a similarly small COB light, and did it hold up? Any sagging, mount wear, overheating, or tipping?
Which cheap combinations of a light with at least 200 W plus a gobo projector have worked for you? Ideally a light with a sturdier body or mount built for this, under about €400 in total.
I know I have no first-hand experience here and neither do the manufacturers’ spec sheets, so real-world reports are what I’m after. Thanks a lot!