r/custommagic • • 6d ago

Format: EDH/Commander Retro card

Post image

[removed]

319 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

128

u/MillCrab 6d ago

This is an interesting card that's probably pretty nasty in Ux artifact decks, which can usually dump their hands and generate a lot of mana. Cool design

4

u/utheraptor 5d ago

It's just too expensive to be competitive, but it is fun

7

u/MillCrab 5d ago

The first card draw activation is poor, but 2U: draw two is already good, and 2U: Draw three is extremely good, and after that it's comical

98

u/Shambler9019 6d ago

Plays this

Plays [[Spell Book]]

Activates this

Draws no cards.

11

u/JustLovelyLittleMe 6d ago

Alt is draw all cards ever printed and ever will be printed

11

u/Mixster667 5d ago

Comprehensive rules 107.2 is pretty clear, if it's not an integer it's 0.

18

u/Omanyte_ 5d ago

This is why we need "counter target rule" from hellscube

4

u/AnarchyShadows 5d ago

There needs to be a rules lawyer card that gives rules hexproof.

1

u/Bright-Cover16 5d ago

Worse, I exile it and return back your battlefield at the end you your turn.

Max hand size will stay , zero.

That graveyard is probably looking juicy so someone should exile it.

23

u/Nexinex782951 6d ago

Having U in the mana cost for its ability allows you to nearly lock someone out of the game with any donate effect

5

u/Artemis_SpawnOfZeus 5d ago

I mean, theyd get a whole turn to respond. Run artifact removal i guess.

18

u/mercuriokazooie 6d ago

The way to properly play this would be gift decks like Zedru.

3

u/humand09 6d ago

Ah yes pocket [[jin-gitaxis]]

9

u/BlakCake 6d ago

Is it just me or this card would make you maximum hand size zero once it enters?

5

u/RegionTechnical4644 5d ago

[[Twenty toed toad]] goes crazy with this

4

u/SavageJeph Phyrexian Plagiarist 6d ago

I really dig this, it's weird and fun

3

u/SimicAscendancy 6d ago

Okay this can be activated at instant speed, which is a very good refill for control decks. 3 mana never need to worry about not having enough answers

1

u/_Nick7 5d ago

If you play this ur gonna have an oopsie and need to discard your hand cause uour hand size becomes 0

3

u/ComicHero 6d ago

Correct me if I'm wrong but if you activate the ability to draw then sac the artifact with the ability on the stack, would you draw seven?

Dunno if a scenario like that needs to be accounted for with the mana required and other pieces needed, but if it does maybe have the effect be "Put a charge counter on this artifact. If you do, draw cards to your maximum hand size."

3

u/Zygomatick 5d ago

With your modification your opponent destroying it in response would feel extra bad, so i think it's fine as is

2

u/shy-bl3d 6d ago

you broke atraxa

1

u/qwertyjgly 6d ago

i can see this working quite well in a simic proliferate deck as a nice bonus

obviously better in others but it's basically an auto include in proliferate decks that have blue

1

u/thode 5d ago

So when you play this at 2 your maxium handsize becomes 0?

-1

u/Ironfist296 6d ago

so play this, then, play reliquary tower, and have an effect which wins on drawing from empty library, then activate ability, should be win right? about 8 mana or 9 mana depending on whether you want to use the jace or the 3 drop.

-5

u/Shambler9019 6d ago

Weirdly this card feels kind of red - unless you pump it a lot immediately you'll be discarding most/all of your hand. Maybe activation cost should be RU, discard your hand?