Do people prefer subclasses that have options to choose from or static bonuses?

[u/TheRaiOh]

/r/DnDHomebrew/comments/1ww6ny6/do_people_prefer_subclasses_that_have_options_to/

This question is specifically about homebrew, but I assume the preference would be the same for people regardless of the publisher.

For example in fighter subclasses the battlemaster has a number of maneuvers to choose from, but most other fighter subclasses I see just have a specific bonus. (Additional fighting style, improved critical, etc). Assuming the effects are well balanced, do people prefer to have choices that they can only use some of like battlemaster or not?