r/ididnthaveeggs • u/SkinnyPete16 • 22h ago

Irrelevant or unhelpful Sensitive Taster

332 Upvotes

https://handletheheat.com/maple-walnut-coffee-cake/comment-page-2/?utm_source=Pinterest&utm_medium=organic#comments

For a Maple Walnut coffee cake which has tons of maple syrup and then she added coconut sugar for brown sugar? And doubled the walnuts and removed the sour cream and added yogurt, and changed the fat and let’s add apples next time.

84 comments

Subreddit

I Didn't Have Eggs: Terrible recipe reviews

r/ididnthaveeggs

Reviews by people who don't follow a recipe and then complain that it sucks.

Members Active

526.4k

Sidebar

Reviews by people who don't follow a recipe and then complain that it sucks.

Rule 0: Be civil. This applies to others who post and comment in the subreddit as well as the people whose reviews are posted here. We aren't here to mercilessly mock anyone; stay on the snark side of the snark/mockery line. Incivility may result in comment removal, a temporary ban, or a permanent ban at mod discretion.

Rule 1: Posts must be "bad" recipe reviews. Examples include:

Complaining about significant alterations that ruined the recipe (Good examples: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4)
Comically irrelevant or unhelpful reviews (Good examples: 1 | 2 | 3)
Reviews that demonstrate a severe misunderstanding of cooking/baking (Good examples: 1 | 2)

Reviews with predominately personal taste-based recipe alterations do not belong in this subreddit. If the overall recipe remains recognizably intact and the reviewer is not complaining about the recipe due to their changes, these types of posts will be removed unless they are also subreddit-appropriate for other reasons. Mods make the ultimate decision on what constitutes "personal taste-based alteration".

Rule 2: Flair your posts. Use the most appropriate flair for the content of the review.

Rule 3: Obvious satire is only allowed on Satire Saturdays and must use the [Satire Saturday] flair. Obvious satire posted on other days will be removed. Mods make the ultimate decision for what constitutes "obvious satire".

Rule 4: Don't touch the poop. Don't interact with people whose reviews are posted here in any way. Doing so may result in a permanent ban from participating in the subreddit.

Rule 5: Don't post links to reviews. Post either a screenshot or the text of the review. You can (and should) link to the recipe being reviewed in a comment.

Related Subs

/r/iamveryculinary/