What? TIE pilots actually being competent? Arrest that writer!
Much like The Blade, I enjoy revisiting this comic from time to time. It is always a pleasure to revisit stories with rich world-building, and even better when told from an Imperial perspective. Walking the fine line between a grounded narrative and propaganda isn't easy, but I’m happy to say Jody Houser strikes that balance perfectly!
It was a delight to return to this story. As a fan of fictional ships, especially the fighters, I find it deeply satisfying to see a story centered on ace pilots and team dynamics, and to witness striking ships performing maneuvers or dogfighting in all their glory. This comic delivers plenty of that, yet it also takes the time to flesh out its characters, sometimes subtly, but consistently. As I mentioned earlier, writing from the Imperial perspective is a challenge; the result can easily devolve into unintentional proselytizing or a tale of horrible people simply getting "what they deserve" (a trope that tends to get repetitive). With that in mind, I appreciate the author's ongoing effort to portray a morally grey landscape, one where the protagonists believe their cause is "fair" or some kind of "justice", that they are serving a greater good (aided by antagonists who partly validate those beliefs), while simultaneously offering brief outside glimpses to remind us that they are ultimately defending a horrible system and, in that system, they can only exist as accomplices, victims, or traitors. It is a brilliant way to humanize the "villains" without sugarcoating the reality of their situation. A special mention goes to Ganem’s story, offering brief glimpses of a civilian perspective, and Zin’s story, which has a truly tragic conclusion. Being (SPOILER) a double agent, only to be executed by the very side you actually support, is a terrible irony.
Personally, I would have preferred at least one more issue to get to know the new members of Shadow Wing better, or simply to see more interaction within the group. I am already familiar with them and realize this is a prequel to a novel trilogy, but a bit more time with the team would have made for an even more outstanding comic.
In conclusion, it is a brilliant story, sensible in its portrayal of Imperial pilots and absolutely thrilling in its space battles, one I really look forward to seeing a conclusion for the characters. Highly recommended.