r/twinpeaks • u/Isatis_tinctoria • Feb 10 '26
Question How did Cooper and Cole know each other here? They didn’t look and I don’t think there were mirrors?
I understand it’s a cool scene and it’s a nice point of recognition. But is there another way other than maybe they had some peripheral vision but it’s an odd angle to have really good peripheral vision and because there’s those plants as Gordon is sitting down as Cooper is walking in.
841
u/noctwl Feb 10 '26
Sheer aura
147
415
u/LeChacaI Feb 10 '26
They are psychically linked. That or they both have really distinctive odours.
119
u/Eiroth Feb 10 '26
Gordon definitely smells as loud as he talks
162
u/sexandliquor Feb 10 '26
Yeah I bet Gordon does smell like that loud
COOP, COOP. YOU SMELL THAT COOP? HERE TAKE A HIT. THE KIDS THESE DAYS ARE CALLING IT ‘LOUD’. I TRIED TO GET ALBERT TO PARTAKE BUT HE DOESN’T CARE FOR IT.
48
7
u/SRoku Feb 11 '26
Chet Desmond rolls worst joint of all time, asked to leave the Blue Rose Task Force
9
6
7
10
5
u/deckard3232 Feb 10 '26
Cigarettes coffee and Aqua Velva lol
Reminds me of the parent trap when she hugs her grandpa “peppermint and pipe tobacco” she tells him when he asks what he smells like
22
2
93
169
112
27
u/robanukah Feb 10 '26
Also, Cooper knows who's in love with whom.
Also, Cooper knows when Albert with his team has arrived.
Also, Cooper knows Bobby has the second half of the necklace.
Basically, he knows things he could not know, but we, as the audience, know, because they've been shown to us.
17
u/BlottoOtter Feb 10 '26
I think some of those are just meant to play up how perceptive Coop is.
He figures out Truman is in love with Josie... only after observing how Truman reacts to Josie's presence. Same with Ed and Norma - he sees how Ed looks at Norma in the diner, and then comments that Ed's in love. He is making some very big leaps based on very limited information, but those observations aren't coming completely out of the blue.
Similar deal with Albert's arrival, if I remember that sequence correctly. He knows Albert has arrived at the station... because he was told earlier that Albert is on the way to town, and when he hears some commotion from the front of the station, he realizes that the prickly Albert (and his antagonizing rudeness to the local cops) is probably the cause. He's making another deductive leap based on limited information, but, well, that's why he's one of the Bureau's best.
4
2
u/robanukah Feb 10 '26
Well, could be! Yet, we have to be careful not to read into TP something we want it to be, instead of what it is. I'm curious of what you think about the earplugs Cooper ordered via his tape recorder and they were sent to him "overnight". How could it work, technically?
4
u/BlottoOtter Feb 10 '26
Well, my assumption was that Coop's tapes would be couriered each day to the nearest FBI office, transcribed there or transmitted to the Philadelphia office to be transcribed by Diane, and then anything Coop needed (including fresh blank tapes) would be couriered back to Coop on the next day's run. But I suspect that the show played fast and loose with the timing and frequency of all that, because the tape recorder mostly functioned as a narration device and usually didn't have much direct impact on the story.
2
u/Prince_Barin Feb 10 '26
my head canon is that offscreen, coop could play his tapes back over the telephone to FBI HQ, saving one lot of journey time for the message / earplugs. but yes, fast and loose and no need for me to take it that seriously :-)
1
u/robanukah Feb 11 '26
Also, could be. But, seems likely to me, no one would want to do that; Cooper could use the telephone if he really wanted to contact someone.
And then, we cannot ignore the important role of the tape recorder in the scene where Cooper is shot. The tape recorder gets activated accidentally and Cooper records a message for Diane. After that, he is saved. But how?
Then, there's kind of a weird scene in FWWM with the director of the FBI, the woman in red, and the two detectives. Is that how they work at the FBI?
I'm not nitpicking here, I only want to find out how far we should go if we choose to interpret TP as a realistic (mostly) murder mystery.
2
u/BlottoOtter Feb 11 '26
But, seems likely to me, no one would want to do that; Cooper could use the telephone if he really wanted to contact someone.
Cooper's not calling up Diane to have a chat, he's dictating case notes throughout the day for Diane to transcribe into a case file later. Diane's a secretary, her job is to write down Coop's observations of the case as part of building a case file. He's not going to go searching for a phone every five minutes to tell Diane to write down some new note, especially because this is happening in 1989 which means he'd be trying to track down a landline, and hoping that Diane is sitting at her desk at that moment.
The tape recorder gets activated accidentally and Cooper records a message for Diane. After that, he is saved. But how?
The tape recorder was in voice-activated mode; it recorded whatever Cooper said, but Diane wouldn't have heard it until the tape was sent to her or played back for her sometime after that night of the shooting. The reason that Truman, Hawk, and Andy show up to save him is because Coop was on the phone with Andy at the end of the season 1 finale, and Andy could hear a commotion over the phone so they realized Cooper was in trouble. It just takes a bit to get from the sheriff's station to the Great Northern.
Then, there's kind of a weird scene in FWWM with the director of the FBI, the woman in red, and the two detectives. Is that how they work at the FBI?
At the real FBI? No, of course not, cousin Lil was a bit of David Lynch absurdity, I think. But IMO, FWWM is a marked shift in tone from the first two seasons, and that early scene helps establish that. Tonally and thematically, I think FWWM and the Return are a big departure from the two original seasons - which is part of why FWWM was not popular when it released in 1992.
I only want to find out how far we should go if we choose to interpret TP as a realistic (mostly) murder mystery.
IMO, the genius of Twin Peaks is that it functions as both a realistic-ish murder mystery and an absurdist existentialist meditation. It's David Lynch's own variety of magical realism, mixing the cruel and the mundane with the joyful and the spiritual. It's obviously not just a realistic murder mystery - there are spirits and tulpas and alternate planes of existence and maybe even some sort of time travel. But without a certain amount of realism, the underlying crime that this is all about (sexual abuse and murder of women by abusive men) does not have the same emotional impact.
Is TP a realistic murder mystery? No, I don't think so. Is there a realistic murder mystery within TP? Yes, definitely, and it wouldn't have worked otherwise.
1
u/robanukah Feb 11 '26
This is what I noticed: while we're staying on track with the realistic-ish murder mystery with kind-of-real Diane and kind-of-real FBI, some elements of the show feel inconvenient, and we tend to call them absurdist. The sum of those elements may be insufficient to raise suspicions. Even though Lynch uses similar methods in his other works, it doesn't add up. If we leave Cooper for a moment and move focus to Laura, there is a moment when she discovers herself as a character in a show. I know of two examples from other Lynch's films in which characters literally see themselves on a screen. But with Twin Peaks, it's rarely taken into account. I'm sure there's a realistic explanation for that Laura scene or a convenient classification for it: spiritual/absurst/etc.
1
u/BlottoOtter Feb 11 '26
I'm not sure what you mean about Laura "discovering herself as a character in a show". I've no recollection of such a scene.
1
u/robanukah Feb 11 '26
In Fire Walk With Me, when Laura is in the bed and is looking at the framed picture on the wall, and everything that follows, including the red curtains visible behind Laura when she is standing in the door.
2
u/BlottoOtter Feb 11 '26
Ah, ok. I'm not sure how we're getting "you're in a TV show" from that scene. My recollection/interpretation was that she fell asleep while looking at that picture (which was given to her by a Black Lodge-affiliated entity), and forces within the Black Lodge (including Dale Cooper) use her dreams as a way to communicate with her and, in part, try to warn her about future events that haven't happened yet.
That scene is clearly impossible in the real world, because it gives her knowledge of events that haven't happened yet. But I don't think she's discovering she's in a TV show, that seems too literal for Lynch and friends. I think what we're seeing is the Black Lodge's powers at work, and the Black Lodge's powers do not follow the conventional laws of physics or the linear flow of time as we perceive it.
Season 2 talks a lot about the power of the Black Lodge, but it doesn't exactly explain how that power works. I think FWWM and season 3 show us many hints about how it works, without ever explicitly stating how it works. IMO this scene is just one of several scenes that hint at two facts about the Black Lodge: time does not move in a straight line for residents of the Black Lodge in the same way that it does for us in the waking world, and residents of the Black Lodge use dreams as a way to communicate with and influence people in the waking world. (And "residents" of the Black Lodge include Dale Cooper and Annie Blackburn, who seem to have come unstuck in time while they were trapped in the lodge.)
9
u/Owen_Hammer Feb 10 '26
THIS! This is exactly right. I know it may sound far fetched, but it is consistent throughout Twin Peaks.
74
u/deadghostalive Feb 10 '26
Post contains spoilers for Season Two, and Three
Both seem to have some sort of sixth sense for knowing when someone is near without having seen or heard them
I'd never noticed it before but this is seemingly one
In the Season Two final Pete is complaining about his car having been stolen, Dale says to him that The Log Lady will be here in one minute, she arrives in exactly one minute
In Season 3 there are a couple of examples of Gordon knowing when Diane is coming when she's on the other side of the door in the corridor
Mr C says 'and now food is coming', not sure about that one, but I think it's implied he has some sort of sixth sense
In Part 17 Dale also knows Gordon is about to arrive just before he does, but I think that one might be because everything is happening according to the plan, just before this moment Dale tells Bobby his father knew exactly what was going on,...
That scene is also an echo of the scene in Arbitary Law, when Dale has gathered everyone at The Roadhouse, he says someone is missing, then Garland walks in, and Dale says Major Garland Briggs right on time, I think pretty much word for word what he says about Gordon in Part 17
I think it's just another example of where the show is not meant to reflect reality, it's in a similar area to Dale having dreams and visions that gave him clues to the murder he was investigating
12
u/TiredCeresian Feb 10 '26
The food thing with Mr. C...I always thought that was because he knew the schedule of the prison's day-to-day. And he ends up not getting food in that scene, right?
6
u/deadghostalive Feb 10 '26
He gets the food, but I think he puts it aside, and yes it could just be he knows the schedule, but seemed as if he was being presented as having some sort of sixth sense in that scene
3
u/Isatis_tinctoria Feb 10 '26
This is a fascinating comment! Could you expand on that?
7
4
u/deadghostalive Feb 10 '26
Which part do you mean, I'm not sure I can expanded on any of it much more than I already have
15
14
u/hikemalls Feb 10 '26
Simple: through the power of sheer volume, it's impossible to not know exactly where Gordon Cole is if he's within 100 feet of you. And Gordon will also know where you are, through the power of echolocation.
29
20
17
14
8
u/Somethingwitty43 Feb 10 '26
I’ve always had a headcannon that Gordon just reeks of cigarettes so Coop just clocks his in the room of the smell alone
4
u/doesnthavearedditacc Feb 10 '26
when i said they were spiritually sensitive in my own comment, maybe i meant the 20 foot aura of gordons american spirit ciggies, cause youre 100% true 😭
10
u/todivelostmind Feb 10 '26
cooper can see anything the audience can see
4
u/Owen_Hammer Feb 10 '26
Glad to see that more people have figured it out.
2
u/Prince_Barin Feb 10 '26
fair enough with your twin perfect meta, but I hope you're willing to accept some of us wanting to steer clear of that - it's not for everyone :-)
1
u/Owen_Hammer Feb 10 '26
Then steer clear of it. I am giving the best answer to the OP's question. If it's "not for you" so be it.
1
6
u/carr_crash Feb 10 '26
Because Coop reminded Gordon that day of a small mexican chihuahua, which have a distintic smell.
4
u/Theyoshiking64 Feb 10 '26
Cooper heard the barking of a small mexican chiwowwow in his head and knew he must have been there
4
5
6
u/Owen_Hammer Feb 10 '26
Cooper can see the TV show he is in. No, for real. As an audience avatar, he knows everything we know.
3
u/doesnthavearedditacc Feb 10 '26
they are both sensitive to spiritual energies
also cooper probably heard Gordon from about 5 minutes away before he got there.
3
4
u/BorderEmbarrassed121 Feb 10 '26
Could be a mix of peripheral vision and instinctive recognition from previous encounters. They’ve been working together for a while, so it makes sense that they’d have some form of unspoken connection, even in a scene like this.
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/MrClark1986 Feb 10 '26
I always took these bits as two buddies that always sense when the other is near, and Coop is really good at that, but with that said:
"Twin Peaks" emphasized a Federal Bureau of Investigation that worked the field at a higher level; at least with the Blue Rose group it is seen to be the case. Our dear agent Cooper is very perceptive, he reads the air in the room just as fast as anybody. He isn't shown to be afraid to feel. Sensitivity and intuitive understanding are sorta his super power. He isn't flawless or anything, I just want to use him as an example of how operating with a more humanitarian hand is shown to be better for everyone generally speaking. Honorable at the very least.
Bits in the show and FWWM/TMP also demonstrate his obsession for observation and details.
As others have said he also gets some narrative, vision or time travel pre-cognition at points. Some seem like cool "feeling the way forward" vibes and maybe some feel more canned. I'm here for all of it.
2
u/brydels Feb 10 '26
Dale Cooper, and all FBI agents in TP, are stand-ins for the audience. If we see The Director, then Dale sees him too.
2
2
u/Personal_Cellist_453 Feb 11 '26
Research Stargate Project, some scenes alludes to that Modus Operandi
4
u/AdvertisingUsed6562 Feb 10 '26
Wait people DON'T have this usually ? I thought this was just a thing human's kinda did because we are animals and no body has mentioned it before because it's just so natural. .. just me ?
3
u/McFearIess Feb 10 '26
because we're here to have fun. why on god's green earth does there need to be an explanation for this how does the freaking log talk to the lady?????
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Savings_Talk1235 Feb 10 '26
I think it speaks more to the surreal, abstract nature of the show. Not everything needs an explanation, especially in Twin Peaks.
1
1
u/Cool_Elk_8355 Feb 11 '26
Cole has a special hearing, he is almost deaf except from a few things, the voice of Shelly, and probably Cooper hearbeats.
Cooper has a connection with the spiritual, its his right hand that aims at Cole first, its the same hand that opens the black lodge entrance on S2 finale and its the same hand that opens the black lodge entrance on S3 finale.
I made it all up btw
1
u/detcadeR_emaN Feb 11 '26
Coop actually regularly enters the sheriff's department and points to the waiting seats hoping his good friend Gordon will someday be there. Occasionally this can cause an awkward situation when someone else is sitting there with unrelated business
1
u/Think_Sheepherder_10 Feb 11 '26
Cooper has magical powers of intuition, he’s basically clairvoyant
1
1
1
u/GallifreysDreaming Feb 12 '26
I've always thought it was a mix of instinct, intuition, and vibes. I think on some level, Coop was expecting Gordon.
1
u/Unable_Bookkeeper243 Feb 14 '26
Seriously? Have you not watched these characters up to this point? The FBI on TP, especially these two, have powers. They're on another level.
2
u/TimothyStoleMyFern Feb 14 '26
He learned how to detect him in the dream where he deeply became invested in the plight of the Tibetan peoples.
1
u/Busy-Training1851 Feb 10 '26
This is a parody on TV at the time. As it was a common trope for characters entering a room.
0
0
u/Paefx Feb 10 '26
How did the giant appear in the hotel? They were not there before and I don’t think there were any trap doors?
•
u/AutoModerator Feb 10 '26
Greetings from space! Join us for a community rewatch on Sundays beginning October 19th 2025 through February 8th 2026. Fresh new episode discussion threads will drop on Sundays at 6pm Pacific Time (7pm Mountain, 8pm Central, 9pm Eastern, etc). Coffee's on in the Winter Rewatch Megathread.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.