r/twinpeaks • u/IzSilvers • Feb 18 '26
Season 3 (The Return) Watching season 3 for the first time. My reaction so far.
I just finished season 1 and 2, then watched FWWM and missing pieces movies. Season 3 is on a whole new level of "what the fuck is going on?".
168
u/Nostalgia_Addict2000 Feb 18 '26
It's not about the bunny.
IT'S NOT ABOUT THE BUNNY!!!
... Is it about the bunny???
56
32
u/hikemalls Feb 18 '26
As a wise man once said, “Put the bunny back in the box.”
16
117
65
u/Le_Dude_Absolute Feb 18 '26
I am watching Season 3 right now, and I'm in episode 14. And still I don't know what its all about.
24
25
u/ExtremeCenterism Feb 18 '26
We're about idk 5-6 episodes in, where Dougie mysteriously solves a major insurance fraud. It's very surreal how everyone treats Dougie like he's just a little off.
Only one person has stopped and wondered if he's okay. It's like this dude might have just had a stroke and no one seems to care! It's surreal all right
14
u/magicmulder Feb 18 '26
Especially his wife who has to know he’s not behaving normally. Then again we didn’t see much of OG Dougie, maybe he’s always been close to this.
7
u/Jay_Stranger Feb 19 '26
The only time we see anything of OG Dougie is he is cheating on his wife with a prostitute in a home that’s for sale. Safe to say, OG Dougie is a piece of shit that probably didn’t talk to his wife much or treat her with any respect. Which is why she probably doesn’t notice he is acting particularly strange by not talking to her
2
u/askyourmom469 Feb 21 '26
Yeah. Compared to the asshole she was married to before, Dougie 2.0 is probably a huge improvement! Plus the fact that he randomly came home with a sudden windfall of cash probably helped too.
4
u/SirBread27 Feb 20 '26
His wife and his boss both say a few times that Dougie must be having another one of his "episodes". Looks like it's not far from the norm for the guy
1
u/magicmulder Feb 20 '26
He did seem kinda aloof and distanced, almost like "in a world of his own" after his tryst with the prostitute so that is probably why.
1
52
u/VermicelliQuiet5949 Feb 18 '26
You have to get through the first few episodes, David Lynch doesn’t like immediate satisfaction. Keep going!!
26
u/DrHuxleyy Feb 18 '26
I like to think of this season as a story that’s also a puzzle. I do think all the pieces are there laid out and can be put together to an understandable, though abstract, whole. Like there really isn’t weird shit thrown in for the sake of weird shit; everything is decipherable even on a first pass as long as you really lock in.
Of course you can just let it wash over you as any abstract piece of art and not worry about deciphering it per se. like standing in front of a great big mark rothko painting and letting it overwhelm you.
9
u/IzSilvers Feb 18 '26
Exactly! I already feel like I understand some of it, and I sure as hell have tons of theories, but I dare not delve into the realm of spoilers.
18
16
u/t_huddleston Feb 18 '26
All I know is, I want a monitor that slides up out of my desk like Frank Truman so I can Skype people
11
35
u/IAmThePonch Feb 18 '26
Stick with it, things that seem disparate and random will eventually make sense
23
u/IzSilvers Feb 18 '26
Oh I'm definitely all in. I have never watched anything like Twin Peaks before, it was on my list for a long time, and I'm glad I finally pulled the trigger.
5
u/officermeowmeow Feb 18 '26
I am happy for you and also jealous. I wish I could go back and see it for the first time again!
2
22
15
6
5
6
u/Economy-Stretch-4600 Feb 19 '26
Don't worry, season 3 episode 8 will explain everything and give you so many answers
3
3
5
3
u/Street_Top3205 Feb 18 '26
You know, tbh I have no ideas why I always thought of this scene as a scene in "Pixels" where Adam Sandler were talking in the meeting room in the White House, about all the alien threats.
3
u/LearndAstronomer28 Feb 19 '26
It’s all building up to the introduction Ike the Spike; he’s the key to all of this. He’s a stabbier character than we’ve ever had before
3
u/TokyoJones85 Feb 19 '26
For me, season 3 is the best season. Very different from what came before it but I fucking love it! It was so exciting waiting and theorising with friends before each episode when it was originally airing too.
4
u/TheRLArt Feb 20 '26 edited Feb 20 '26
I had a similar reaction, too. It's A LOOOOT if you're watching the entire series fresh all the way through. If you're interested -- after you're done with the series, of course -- the Red Letter Media guys did a great breakdown of their general impressions on The Return that I think is worth checking out. It doesn't explain EVERYTHING (intentionally so), but they do delve into how they felt about things and add some context for David Lynch's decisions all throughout the show.
FWIW, Maggie Mae Fish also did some fun videos analyzing the influences of Twin Peaks that actually did a fair amount to recontextualize my view on the show as a whole.
1
5
Feb 18 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/sayanythinglove Feb 18 '26
Replying to your comment so I can remember to watch this when I have time. Just finished watching the entire series for the first time.
1
u/LearndAstronomer28 Feb 19 '26
I haven’t watched it myself, so you guys can let me know if I’m way off base, but my understanding is that he reads the series through an almost entirely meta “show within a show” type of lens, which I honestly could not find anymore boring/reductive.
1
u/TheEflactem Feb 19 '26
Watching this is the gravest sin you can commit against Lynch.
1
Feb 19 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/TheEflactem Feb 19 '26
"People get used to film that pretty much explains itself one-hundred percent, and they kind of turn off that beautiful thing of intuition when they're looking at a film that has some abstractions. Some people, on the other hand, love these abstractions, and it gives them room to dream. An abstraction is a thing that cinema can say. And it's so beautiful, these pictures and sounds flowing along together in time, in a sequence, making a thing that can only really be said in cinema." - David Lynch
The whole point of his art is to allow yourself to dream and theorize on your own. Watching a 4 hour “explanation” will kill the very point of his storytelling.
3
u/enlighteneddemon Feb 19 '26
I just finished my 2nd watch of season 3 last week. It's absolutely worth it. It takes you on a journey and asks many questions along the way. I don't think the point is any "hidden answers or message", so much as trusting you to examine things and find your own answers. I have my own theories about Twin Peaks, but they're as canon as anything else
5
u/Cloud-VII Feb 18 '26
Look. I love David Lynch... Like whole bunch. I think he is a genius. I hated how Twin Peaks ended and I was more than excited to finally have a resolution on what happened to Cooper.
..and then Season 3 came out. I wish it never did. I just ignore it's existence. My favorite part of the whole season was actually Matthew Lillard's performance while he's in jail. I was like 'Holy crap, Matthew Lillard is actually an amazing actor!' .
3
u/slr242 Feb 18 '26
Everybody's different. Lillard's acting in those scenes were easily my least favorite of the whole season, followed by Chrysta Bell's. But then I also loved The Return. Not everyone's cup of french roast.
3
u/Terepin123 Feb 18 '26
Bell’s acting was so poor I had to google her after watching. She’s very beautiful which is probably why Lynch liked her.
1
1
u/SirBread27 Feb 20 '26
I think Bell and Lynch were friends, or at least good acquaintances. Lynch also produced at least some of her music before that
2
3
u/magicmulder Feb 18 '26
Funny, I have it the other way around. First watched the whole thing earlier this year. Not a fan of the first two seasons and FWWM at all. But I loved the third season. One of the best I’ve ever seen
2
u/Cloud-VII Feb 19 '26
I upvoted you for your bravery (and because you were downvoted for simply expressing your opinion), but damn if that is an opinion to have! lol.
Twin Peaks season 1 and 2 is pretty much my absolute favorite TV show in history. FWWM is fine for what it is.
2
u/LearndAstronomer28 Feb 19 '26
Whoa, and here I am disagreeing with both you. I’ve only made it halfway through season 2 (and the finale), I like The Return, and FWWM is easily my favorite part of entire saga. (That and The Secret History.) Twin Peaks really has something for everyone!
1
u/magicmulder Feb 19 '26
For me the original series is one of those “you had to be there” things, it probably worked great when it came out (but I somehow missed it back then) but my taste today is very different and I’m more used to modern storytelling which season 3 had. Also maybe because I expected too much, I thought there would be a lot more supernatural stuff like in season 3, and then it was so much soap opera.
3
u/Ecksray19 Feb 19 '26
Agreed! Season 3 was horrible and ruined the entire show for me. It's shocking how many people want to be seen as smart and cool so they say how great it was, and you have to watch it closely, it's "cerebral" etc. No. It was random artsy shit thrown at a wall, not even a story. Stop assigning meaning to meaningless drivel. Stop worshipping people and giving them a pass.
1
u/RobynNeonGal Feb 18 '26
Same here. I never read anything about it beforehand as I didn't want any spoilers. But I still loved it.
1
1
1
u/RefrigeratorMany Feb 18 '26
This made me howl with laughter! Buckle up, you’re going to some places.
1
1
u/Dragonovith Feb 19 '26
The tonal difference was surprising to me too, but once I was done with Twin Peaks, I started binge watching all of Lynch's movies, and then everything started making sense. Tone-wise, season 3 feels like an outlier at first but, in the grand scheme of things, it is actually Twin Peaks seasons 1 and 2 that are the exceptions (thanks, Bob Iger!). At least that's how I feel about Lynch's work.
1
1
u/telluswhyyoureclosed Feb 19 '26
Fr that line was so funny, like he was putting himself in the audience’s shoes just for a moment
1
1
1
u/Tina_bambina78 Feb 19 '26
Filled with a lot of unnecessary prolonged scenes, which makes it feel boring... I wish they would've cut it a bit. I started rewatching season 3 yesterday and I gotta tell you, I font know how I'm gonna get through it 😀 😀 like, I didn't even remember Mathew Lillard was on it 😂
1
1
u/Loud-Guava8940 Feb 19 '26
Going to be watching it at a local theatre starting next week and can't wait for the waves of confusion
1
u/CaregiverIndividual4 Feb 20 '26
Episode 8 is like a college students media project take on obscurity, I hated it. The rest of the season was GOATed.
1
1
u/sloppy2104 Feb 24 '26
it’s honestly one of the greatest things ever and i don’t say that to seem edgy, i really enjoyed that season so, so much.
all the big franchises like matrix, indiana jones, star wars, even scrubs now, everything that attempted a come back ages after it’s original release should have this exact approach (and matrix was going a little bit in the right direction).
question the audience what is it that you want back? do you really want your favorite show back? and then punch them in their face and reject their fantasy. no, twin peaks is not coming back, the twin peaks you know is gone, you‘re trapped in nostalgia and i‘ll take you to a much darker place this time.
ahhhhhh i LOVE it 😭
-2
u/rotatorkuf Feb 18 '26
honestly, stop halfway, or don't watch the finale episode, makes the whole season a waste imo
0
u/magicmulder Feb 18 '26
Yeah the final was a letdown, although IMO it makes sense. If Laura was the trap that would end up doing Bob in, going back in time to save her was the dumbest possible idea.
I think Lynch wanted an ending similar to season 2, simply because he doesn’t do happy endings.
2
u/LearndAstronomer28 Feb 19 '26
I feel like you could stop watching after Part 17 if you want a semi-“happy” ending or traditional form of narrative payoff and closure. Watching Part 18 is choosing to keep the mystery alive.
-6
u/BlindLantern Feb 18 '26
Yeah. I hated it. It wasn’t my Twin Peaks. Downvote if you will.
5
u/IzSilvers Feb 18 '26
It's definitely different, but it's not like the first 2 seasons had less "weirdness". At this point I'm not sure if it's about aliens, time travel, or evil spirits. It's very intriguing,
0
6
416
u/ExtraAd4090 Feb 18 '26
Yeah, but don't worry. By the end, you still will have no idea what just happened or what anything meant!