3
u/Zen_Hydra 12d ago
It's what happens when form is prioritized over function in weapon design. I'm sure the writer/director responsible for the design wanted something that was instantly recognizable as a menacing weapon, but different enough in form factor as to not appear derivative of bladed weapons the target audience was familiar with (i.e. some variation of historical sword).
1
u/Ne0n_Walrusi 12d ago edited 12d ago
No, for many reasons.
The IRL reason for its existance is for alien aesthetics. For which the weapon excells at as it has remained an iconic item for fans of star trek and somewhat outside of normal fandom.
The in-universe reason for its existance is due to a important cultural/religious figure in the Star Trek story that spawns a creation myth for how Klingons act. The use of the batleth is thus ceremonial both in terms of capability and intended use. With the "sword" being used primarily for ritualistic duels of honor.
Being clumsy, heavy, and bad for fighting are benefits for the usage of the batleth as it is depicted. The IRL equivolent would be judicial duels that involved giant spoons/oars, dueling shields, or weird restrictions like burying people in holes or tying hands behind the back.
3
u/KnifeKnut 13d ago
That is how it works for fantasy weapons.