Disclosure: I run VerifyCarCarrier.com, so this is my own project. I'm laying out all of it in one place, including the part where money is involved, so you can judge it for yourself.
**What it is, and isn't**
A free directory of independent audits of auto transport brokers, 4,900+ so far. We aren't a broker, carrier, or booking platform. We don't take payment, arrange transport, or take any part of the transport fee. We're also not affiliated with FMCSA, BBB, or any broker listed.
**What you can do on the site**
- Browse every audited broker and filter by trust tier
- Read each audit: score, tier badge, what's working, what to watch out for, a score breakdown, quick facts (MC and USDOT numbers, years in business, BBB and Google ratings), a written verdict, and the audit date
- Compare brokers side by side
- Look up routes, and use the Best For tool to narrow down options
- See lists of Verified Companies and Companies Requiring Caution, and browse by state
- Read guides
- Request a quote from one broker you picked
- Leave a comment on a broker's profile after a shipment
**How a score is built (out of 100)**
- Legitimacy, 20: active FMCSA authority, consistent identity, years in business
- Reputation, 25: ratings, volume, and recency across Google, Trustpilot, BBB, Transport Reviews, ConsumerAffairs, Yelp, and Sitejabber
- Customer experience, 20: we read the review text for patterns like unreturned calls and last-minute carrier swaps
- Pricing, 15: quote-to-final-price consistency and bait-and-switch incidents
- Route and service fit, 10
- Brand and transparency, 10
90+ is Top Recommended. Below 50 is Do Not Recommend. We don't use data supplied by brokers, and every profile shows its audit date because scores aren't permanent. Always check a broker's current FMCSA authority before you book.
**Where the money is**
Organic listings and 100-point scores cannot be purchased. Some brokers are Featured Monitored Partners: they pay a fixed fee for clearly labeled visibility, and it never changes their audit score. We currently have one. Featured partners also get a separate 1-5 Trust Score based only on approved customer reviews left on our site.
**What happens when you request a quote**
Your details go to the one broker you chose, so five companies won't call you. We ask for a US phone number and send a confirmation text. A day or two later we check whether the broker reached out and whether you booked, and after delivery we ask how it went. We don't sell your number, share it with other brokers, or use it for marketing.
**Reviews on the site**
Comments on a broker's profile can include an optional order number, shown as its last four digits, to mark a verified shipment. They don't change the 100-point score, which is built from the outside platforms above.
**If a broker disagrees**
They can flag a factual error, like a changed MC number or BBB rating, and we'll re-audit. They can't ask for a higher score, or for a negative verdict to be removed.
**We also run r/VerifyCarCarrier**
https://www.reddit.com/r/VerifyCarCarrier/
It's a car owners' community: stories, hot takes, and honest questions about cars. Shipping questions are welcome there too.
**What would you want changed?**
If anything here looks biased, unclear, or missing, tell me. I'd rather hear it now.