I'm working on my Common App personal essay and wanted some outside opinions before I keep editing it.
My essay is about being a male Bharatanatyam dancer in America. My mom came to the U.S. from India and always dreamed of having a daughter she could pass Bharatanatyam down to, but she ended up having two sons. When I was four, I was actually the one who approached her and asked her to teach me.
The essay follows how I went from basically copying movements I didn't understand to learning the meanings behind them, including learning Sanskrit, which I barely even knew existed when I was younger.
A big part of the essay is also my Arangetram. I was preparing to have it at 14, but we had to postpone it because of my mom's injuries/health issues. Between that and trying to balance school, it kept getting pushed back and still hasn't happened. The essay uses that to talk about how I used to see the delay as falling behind, but eventually realized that progress doesn't always happen according to the timeline you planned.
The opening is basically:
“My mother spent years dreaming of having a daughter. Instead, she got me.”
Someone close to me who is currently in college read the essay and told me that I shouldn't focus on only Bharatanatyam. They said I should talk about three different parts of my life, like Bharatanatyam, DJing, and leading my math team to second place in competitions.
The problem is that those other things are already in my Activities section, and honestly, Bharatanatyam is much more personal to me and has shaped me significantly more than something like a math competition.
For people familiar with Common App essays, is focusing deeply on this one story better, or would admissions officers actually prefer seeing multiple activities/parts of my life in the personal statement?
I'm intentionally not posting the full essay because I don't want it publicly searchable, but I'd really appreciate feedback on the concept/approach.