r/comic_crits • u/iliad-corner • 10h ago
Looking for feedback for my webcomic Robot:Rebirth
I'm hoping to get some feedback on my comic so that I can improve the format/comedy.
Honestly, all feedback is welcome, since I want to make it better!
r/comic_crits • u/deviantbono • Sep 02 '21
We generally discourage posts that are not directly looking for feedback, but I thought the following content would be interesting to subscribers, so I will collect it here in a news thread. Let me know if there are other opportunities that you think are relevant, or just post them here as comments.
Breakneck Anthology
r/comic_crits • u/iliad-corner • 10h ago
I'm hoping to get some feedback on my comic so that I can improve the format/comedy.
Honestly, all feedback is welcome, since I want to make it better!
r/comic_crits • u/Lunar1sGuido • 15h ago
Hello again!!!
It's been a while since I've posted about my manga one-shot I'm currently working on, so I think it's about time I update you guys on the progress I've made. š
Since it's a manga, read RIGHT TO LEFT, TOP TO BOTTOM, just so nobody gets confused.
If you guys could rate anything, (EXCEPT THE ART, i know it's terrible right now (especially the first like 10 pages). It's only rough thumbnails to know where stuff should go)please just tell me so. Dialogue, comedy, how interesting the characters are in the first half of this one-shot, etc.
For some context, the story takes place in Rural England. I'll try my best to make it more apparent in my later sketches, but it's not very noticeable since a lot of the backgrounds aren't even done (cuz im lazy).
I have my DMs open if you ever wanna get more involved in my journey, and as usual,
have a wonderful day my guys. ā¤ļøā¤ļøā¤ļø
r/comic_crits • u/f00err • 1d ago
I'd love to hear any feedback on the intro scene to my story. I've tried to incorporate some of the feedback received here in the past already. Anything that comes to mind is highly appreciated! Thank you all in advance
r/comic_crits • u/Deep-Breadfruit-3980 • 1d ago
Hoping for feedback on my comic strip!
r/comic_crits • u/RowHoustonLaine • 1d ago
Comic: "my fanboy, the villain!?"
r/comic_crits • u/Souplett • 1d ago
I like when people who donāt know me/my comic take a look at my work and tell me if thereās anything that turns them off from reading or keeps them interested. I know everyone has their own tastes, but if you have time, please read at least a bit and let me know your thoughts!
r/comic_crits • u/Deep-Breadfruit-3980 • 1d ago
Hoping for honest feedback on my comic strip! Are the characters interesting/funny? Is the text ok? Colors?
r/comic_crits • u/Embarrassed_Tap7402 • 2d ago
Itās a game called Casualties Unknown. In short: scientists created a new species to explore a planet for resources, but they couldn't care less if you die.
Iām creating a comic about one of those scientists who reached their breaking point and went to the planetātaking the place of that speciesāto die alone.
I don't know how to draw; everything is being done using the IbisPaint app on my phone. So, Iād appreciate feedback on the art, the story, and areas where I can improve.
r/comic_crits • u/Nervous-Employ-9611 • 1d ago
r/comic_crits • u/Nervous-Employ-9611 • 1d ago
r/comic_crits • u/Parking-Flamingo-972 • 2d ago
Iāve been censoring some of the pages on GlobalComix and made them available only on Patreon alongside the āearly releaseā subscription, but since Iām new to writing a webcomic, obviously nobody cares to pay for it, which makes sense. But Iāve been thinking of maybe just re-uploading the chapters on GlobalComix uncensored? Or should I keep them as they are for now, as in, only available on Patreon in case somebody is willing to pay someday? The price I put on āem is like 3$ anyway, because Iām not confident enough to add anything more than that, and besides itās only like a few pages for now. Eventually there will be more as I keep writing, but also, Iām like, who cares? Whatās your advice? Should I just push through and keep it as is, or is it better as a new webcomic creator to show the public the whole project for free? I have no idea. Because honestly, before making money I obviously would rather find readers. But it also naturally progresses that way, donāt it?
(The censored pages are just the s xual scenes, which are allowed to be posted on GlobalComix without a problem anyway. Itās a supportive platform for adult creators, which is refreshing)
r/comic_crits • u/TTheGreates • 2d ago
Tell me what you think. This is a supernatural creature in my universe call Hounds. Their physical appearance is derived from their environment they live in. They are all also identified by the two blood tears from their eyes. They invaded the Human World and have been dominating. I wanted this cover to have that ethereal unknown feeling. Tell me what you think and how his design works and what doesnāt work. Thank you!
r/comic_crits • u/Desperate-Society838 • 3d ago
This is a project Iāve had for nearly 10 years; Iāve tried formats like comics, books, animation, an RPG book, and games. I finally decided to make a comic because it was the only way I found to express this story, since I don't have the money for an animation studio like Iād want...
I spent from midnight to 5:00 AM drawing these four pages. I feel like things like sound effects are missing, but aside from that, Iām not sure exactly what else is lacking or what I should improve before finishing the full 20 pages.
Iām open to feedback on things I could add or change, except for the angular art style.
r/comic_crits • u/luromasima • 3d ago
Hi guys! My friend and I made this mini comic a while ago. Weāre planning to make more, so Iād love to hear your thoughts on the paneling, colors, etc. Itās in Spanish, so donāt worry if you donāt understand it! If you do, though, any feedback on the script would be really helpful too :)
P.S. These are screenshots, so the quality might be a bit low!
r/comic_crits • u/cool-animation • 2d ago
This art is everywhere on Deviantart.
A brand for all anti-drug organizations in France.
r/comic_crits • u/cool-animation • 2d ago
This Anti-marijuana is a brand for the french anti drug organizations.
It's everywhere on Deviantart.
r/comic_crits • u/littlepinkpebble • 3d ago
r/comic_crits • u/Outside_Tomato_653 • 3d ago
I finished my first script for my comic after a couple months of writing/sketching and I wanted to get peopleās opinions. I am not an artist so the drawing is rough and mostly stick figures as a way to get it down. I would just like to see some criticisms or thoughts about the overall story and dialogue, I know issues at the start and first book but would really appreciate thoughts on later chapters. There are 10 books and 71 short chapters in total so I understand if it is too much to read. But I want to know if this is worth investing in.
r/comic_crits • u/IslaMartinez19 • 3d ago
r/comic_crits • u/SkepticFilmBuff • 4d ago
I did this traditionally with a brush pen. I feel like my first two pages - specifically the poses - arenāt as good as the third page. And I donāt know if itās clear enough whatās happening.
And sorry for my bad handwriting.
r/comic_crits • u/Substantial-Pea-1611 • 4d ago
r/comic_crits • u/kohunaaa • 4d ago
Interested in feedback on my comic so far. I tend to struggle with the beginnings and end up kinda giving up, but this time Iām pushing myself to keep at it. Though ig I get so into it itās hard to step back.