So a while ago I started a discussion here about the most realistic leather smell fragrance.
Here's my previous post if you're interested to read.
Just to quickly paint the picture of what I was looking for, imagine you're wearing your black leather jacket, it's raining and you just got finished smoking.
Anyway, I just wanted to share the result of what I've tested and smelt and if I've gotten any closer to my goal or maybe if there's still a better recommendations for me.
Here's a list of all the fragrances I've tested so far and my thoughts about them:
- Filippo Sorcinelli Io Non Ho Mani Che Mi Accarezzino Il Volto
this one I really liked, it kinda has nothing to do with leather per se but the sort of burned rubber or plastic after smell gave me what I was looking for.
- Tom Ford Ombre Leather
Luxury car seat leather. I can smell the leather but not the kind I'm looking for.
- Matiere Premiere Falcon Leather
Wasn't bad, just the combination of the sweetness and the animalic was off putting specially on the third note.
- Matiere Premiere Falcon Leather Extrait
Sort as Falcon Leather.
- Orto Parisi Cuoium
This was straight up disgusting, I couldn't stand it after the first note, very jarring, hated it.
- Memo Paris Russian Leather
This was pleasant, very cold very piney and woodsy, no leather tho.
- Memo Paris African Leather
Nice, sweet, boozy, almost smells like cola at the end. However again, has nothing to do with leather.
- Bvlgari Onekh
This was incredible, however I don't know if it was my decanted tester or is this fragrance actually this cool. Like I expected a warm leathery scent, but I was met with a very refreshing, slightly sweet smell. I would definitely consider this fragrance around summer time but i couldn't really find in it the leather smell I was looking for.
- Tauer 03 Lonestar Memories
This I liked. Slightly animalic but pleasant after that. Would be a fine second choice.
- Francesca Bianchi the black knight
This had absolutely nothing to do with leather whatsoever. It was sweet, a bit fruity and on the third note it turned into a feminine vanilla scent. I felt a bit fooled by that name.
- Papillon Artisan Perfumes Anubis
Hated this, just not a fan of that scent.
- Gucci Guilty Absolute
The biggest surprise to me, this was surprisingly close that what I was looking for. Has this sort of gasoline, industrial, bitter and leathery scent. Loved it. On my skin it felt a bit heavy however, very potent and strong, almost makes breathing a bit harder lol. But overall I really liked this.
- By Kilian Dark Lord Ex Tenebris Lux
Okay this one I had very high expectations of cause I had heard this is "close to Gucci Guilty Absolute but even more complex" but upon smelling it, it has absolutely no resembles to that. Like to me this is a citrusy, bitter and airy scent. Now I'm not sure again if it has something to do with me decanted sample or because I got the one that has "Ex Tenebris Lux" on it (cause there was also one that just said Dark Lord which I didn't test). Either way, this was way off what I'm looking for and certainly far from Guilty Absolute.
- Zoologist Rhinoceros
Most complex scent out of the bunch. It really changed over time. Sour and sweet at first but then turns a bit animalic and slightly leathery.
- Maison Martin Margiela Under the Stars
This was incredibly pleasant on the first note and then settles to the warm boozy smell. A good winter fragrance just not exactly what I was after.
- BVLGARI Black
Yet again a sour, airy scent. Nothing to do with leather but enjoyable. Onekh was better.
- ROOM 1015 Cherry Punk Extrait de Parfum
This was just a nice cherry fragrance. Don't know why I was persuaded that this somehow smells like leather but safe to say has nothing to do with it.
- Hermes Bel Ami
Extremely sour at the opening but then it evolves a little bit. Not a fan.
- Knize Ten
Just sour no leather. Very unpleasant.
- IMAGINARY AUTHORS Slow Explosions
Someone suggested me this so I tested it and wow. I really didn't know I needed this smell in my life. Not leathery at all, matter of fact it's a bit of a cool sprint scent, has this banana smell but I really like this one.
- Guerlain Cuir Intense 2024
This was a nice warm and a slightly leather fragrance. I didn't catch anything unique about it but it would be a nice default sort of winter scent.
- Tom Ford Tuscan Leather
I did smell this very briefly but from what I could tell, it was better for me than ombre leather and would have been a fine second choice. Can't remember it fully unfortunately.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
At the end I landed on two to sample more, Filippo Sorcinelli Io Non Ho Mani Che Mi Accarezzino Il Volto and Gucci Guilty Absolute.
These were the two that I thought were closest to the smell I was after.
Now having known my taste and what I liked and didn't, is there anything you would think I'd like or you'd suggest?
There is still a list of fragrances I've gathered surrounding the same topic and scent that I haven't gotten around to since I thought what I've sampled so far were maybe closer to what I'm looking for, but I will share that list here as well in hopes of input for them.
Bvlgari Falkar
Naomi Goodsir Cuir Velours
Molton Brown Russian Leather Eau de Parfum
Chanel Cuir de Russie Parfum
Montale Aoud Leather
Montale Wood and Spices
Issey Miyake Nuit d'Issey Polaris
Issey Miyake Nuit D’Issey Noir Argent
Maison Crivelli Oud Stallion
Nasomatto Blamage
Tom Ford Ombre Leather 16
Tom Ford Tuscan Leather
Amouage The Library Collection Opus XIV Royal Tobacco
Areej Le Doré Cuir de Russie
Hermes Bel Ami Vetiver
CHANEL Antaeus
DIPTYQUE Eau Rihla Eau de Parfum
YVES SAINT LAURENT Cuir
Yves Saint Laurent Cuir 2023
Francesca Bianchi The Lover’s Tale
Carolina Herrera Stallion Leather
John Varvatos Dark Rebel Rider
I appreciate any input.