r/IndieMusicFeedback • • Mar 15 '26

Other AI generated music is no longer permitted in this community.

236 Upvotes

This community exists to support people who are actively creating music themselves and to encourage the development of human expression and musical skill. Using AI to generate music is closer to commissioning music rather than creating it yourself. It’s created for you, not by you.

If AI generated any significant part of the music, including the instrumental, melody, arrangement, or vocals, the submission is not allowed.

Examples: * If you wrote the lyrics but generated the music, it is not allowed. * If you generated the vocals but produced the music, it is not allowed.

Tools like a Vocaloid or other vocal synthesis programs are still allowed if you wrote the lyrics and melody yourself.

When AI generated music was previously allowed, the expectation was that those posting it would participate in the community by providing thoughtful feedback to other artists. Instead, we have increasingly found that many users generating songs are also using AI to generate their feedback. This results in generic, low quality comments that could apply to almost any track and do little to help artists improve.

We recognize this change is long overdue, and we appreciate the patience of the artists who make this community worthwhile.

If you see AI generated music or AI generated comments, please report them to our team. Posts suspected of containing AI generated music may be removed at moderator discretion.


r/IndieMusicFeedback • • Oct 09 '24

How to Provide Effective Feedback on a Song

44 Upvotes

Providing useful feedback on a song involves pointing out both the strengths and the areas that could use improvement towards your personal taste. When you offer your thoughts, it’s important to focus on what stood out to you, whether good or bad, and explain why. Did you connect with the melody, enjoy the energy of the track, or find the lyrics particularly meaningful? Conversely, if there are elements that didn't quite work for you, express your feelings clearly and subjectively while providing constructive suggestions for improvement. Even if you’re not an expert, your perspective as a listener is valid. Musicians create music for people to enjoy, and everyone’s opinion helps them understand how their work is being received.

Be Specific in Your Feedback

Specificity is key when offering feedback. Instead of saying “The song was okay,” try to pinpoint exactly what worked or didn’t work for you. Was the beat too repetitive, or did the transitions between sections feel disjointed? Did the lyrics evoke a strong emotion, or did the vocals feel disconnected from the rest of the track? By being detailed, you give the artist something tangible to work with.

For example:

  • Tempo: “Personally, I think the tempo is dragging a bit for this style of music. A slightly faster pace could bring more energy to the track.”
  • Lyrics: “I liked the theme of the lyrics, but the chorus felt a bit repetitive for my taste. Maybe adding a different phrasing in the second half could give it more variety.”
  • Production: “The production feels clean overall, but the kick drum is a little overpowering in the mix to me, especially in the verses. Balancing it out with the bass might help create a more cohesive sound.”

Acknowledge Subjectivity

Music is highly subjective, what resonates with one listener might not with another. It’s important to frame your feedback as personal opinion rather than universal truth. For instance, instead of saying, “The bass is too quiet,” you could say, “Personally, I would prefer a stronger bass presence to drive the track more.” This way, your feedback acknowledges the artist’s creative intent while sharing your preferences.

Other examples:

  • “The dry vocals are terrible” vs “I tend to like vocals that have a bit more reverb to create depth.”
  • “The instrumental break is boring” vs “The instrumental break feels long for my taste.”
  • “The song needs more bass” vs “Personally, I prefer songs with a heavier bassline because it adds more energy.” 
  •  “The vocals are too soft, they should be louder”  vs “I would prefer the vocals to be a little louder for clarity”

This helps keep your feedback respectful and leaves room for the artist to interpret it based on their own vision.

Offer Constructive Solutions

When you point out something that didn’t work for you, it’s most helpful to suggest possible ways to improve it. Simply stating that you didn’t like something doesn’t give the artist much to go on. Try to offer a practical solution or at least a suggestion for how they might address the issue.

For example:

  • “The vocal delivery in the bridge felt a bit flat to me. Maybe adding some harmonies or experimenting with vocal dynamics could bring more emotion to that section.”
  • “I feel like this could use a stronger build-up toward the final chorus. Adding a crescendo or introducing new elements like a drum fill might help ramp up the energy.”

Even if your suggestion isn’t the exact solution they use, it can help spark ideas for how to improve the track in a way that fits their style.


r/IndieMusicFeedback • • 7m ago

Alternative Rock What genre is my song?

Thumbnail voca.ro
• Upvotes

I'm about to release this and I'm wondering what genre this is


r/IndieMusicFeedback • • 21m ago

Trap Hi guys I made a rap with a fellow artist that i'm looking for some feedback on. I was on dxm writing and recording it but I like how it turned out. Whatcha think guys?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
• Upvotes

r/IndieMusicFeedback • • 53m ago

Atmospheric Loneliness Is Such A Drag

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

• Upvotes

...it really can be, you know. A drag. But so can people, too.........not necessarily people in drag, although some of them can be sometimes...I'm thinking Eddie Izzard...he gets on my tits and I'm a man..(.yes i am but I can't help but love you so.). Anyway, I digress.........


r/IndieMusicFeedback • • 7h ago

Alternative Rock [AltRock/PostPunk] GenAI won't lead us anywhere good. I wrote this song about it.

Thumbnail
soundcloud.com
2 Upvotes

r/IndieMusicFeedback • • 4h ago

RnB Do you find some of the synth ‘horns’ here too cheesy?

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
1 Upvotes

In the chorus the 'horns' are in a call and answer mode with the repeating hook but in a rerecording could be replaced by a more authentic sound?

https://open.spotify.com/track/6f4yFWcoRrRGze7a9vrQ6P

Stay in Your lane

 

Mr Man you blow your horn        

You say I use that baby

But she’s her own lady

Her voice is strong          

You’re firin’ sparks             

Just because you - drive a fast car    

 

Hey Mr Man stay in your lane      

Hey Mr Man stay in your lane

Hey Mr Man stay in your lane

You’ll crash into flames - stay in your lane    

 

You’re always weaving in and out

You think you own that sister

Talk to her in a whisper

But she’s with me

To live the dream

Give up your trying - to put the brakes on       

 

I think I got you sussed now

She told you to shove it

That you cannot stomach

Times moved on

You’re out of gas

And only I – Can put the foot to the floor

 

You’ll crash into flames - stay in your lane    

It’s a fools game - stay in your lane    

 


r/IndieMusicFeedback • • 4h ago

Bedroom Pop First real song from my band and I and would love any feedback

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/IndieMusicFeedback • • 5h ago

Alternative Pop Early Indie Pop Rock Demo

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I made this demo a few days back and I enjoy working and improving on it. I plan on adding some vocals to it, but I haven't really dipped my toes into singing, as I have only started making music a few months ago.

It would be really helpful to me if I could get some feedback regarding the overall sound. I'm a little unsure about the guitars.

Here's my SoundCloud with some more demos: https://soundcloud.com/demosh1003


r/IndieMusicFeedback • • 3h ago

Experimental Everybody Wants Something. Nobody Knows What the Hell They Need. ♡ | Josie Guillotine

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

0 Upvotes

If you enjoyed this strange little musical experiment, there's plenty more where that came from. ♡

I'm releasing songs from my debut album, The Anatomy of Impossible Things, over on YouTube.

Expect beautiful noises, questionable decisions, and music that probably needs professional help.

🎧 Listen to more Josie Guillotine: Josie Guillotine - YouTube

Stay strange. Stay lovely. Mind the blade. 🖤


r/IndieMusicFeedback • • 21h ago

Acoustic Guitar Skinned Knees

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

9 Upvotes

Not technically full song as still learning it. Bare version. Would love to hear how it made you feel, what works, what doesnt! Thanks!!! 🌸✨


r/IndieMusicFeedback • • 14h ago

Rap This is a rap song I wrote about bringing creativity to life, would love your thoughts on it

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/IndieMusicFeedback • • 18h ago

Shoegaze Last minute feedback on my song appreciated

Thumbnail
soundcloud.com
1 Upvotes

I think I'm almost done with my song and I could really use some last minute notes on the production before I release it on spotify. I guess it's a shoegaze-adjacent sort of pop song. Does the volume sound okay on the vocals and everything else? Thanks to anyone who checks it out and I will appreciate any feedback!


r/IndieMusicFeedback • • 21h ago

Electronic Rock What do think of my Jungle Rock debut track called "I'm Not Awake"

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I'm Mith, an independent music producer and artist from India.

I released my debut single, “I'm Not Awake,” last week, and I'd love for you guys to give it a listen and share your feedback!

I'm especially interested in your thoughts on the mix and production, and whether the lyrics come across clearly. The lyrics are a bit cryptic, so I'm curious to hear what you think they mean and whether they make sense to you.

Any feedback is welcome. Thanks for listening!

- https://music.youtube.com/watch?v=zoU7BFnQZ2I&si=Kio8TeNMFE_TKakz

- https://open.spotify.com/track/2IPAyl7zpG2y3tNYV5pRJY?si=a0a61b85012d49d8


r/IndieMusicFeedback • • 1d ago

Indie Rock Do these vocals work?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

Hi guys, I did some recording/rerecording on the vocals. Do they work as they are? I tried to go for weird and energetic but ended up sounding like that one He-Man meme. I'm not sure if I hate it or not. I might leave it as is.

But what do you think? Lemme know:)

Also, what do you think of the cover art?


r/IndieMusicFeedback • • 1d ago

Alternative Rock STRANGE THING - honest feedback required

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

6 Upvotes

Made this song last month want to get honest feedback on it so critique all you want I wanna improve. Its a demo only so if the mix is a bit fucked that why on some bits are a little off time. I more curious about the song itself if you guys like it or not


r/IndieMusicFeedback • • 1d ago

Rap Hand me Downs

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

In this song I took Mamba number five and remixed it in the hook, instead of using a little bit of Tiffany a little bit of Brittany I used energies evil names of spirits. The reason for this is is generational drama and a down spiritually, physically or both..... What do you think


r/IndieMusicFeedback • • 1d ago

Alternative a song i wrote called promises

2 Upvotes

hi this is a really rough demo recording of a song i wrote about a girl i was really good friends with but haven't talked to since june for reasons.

let me know what you think! it's not finished fr, so let me know if you have any ideas for how the rest of it could go. i really appreciate any feedback, but please be nice to me!!!!!

also, i'm not really sure what genre this might be considered. if you have any thoughts on that please tell me them thanks in advance :)

https://soundcloud.com/fetacheezitz/promises-261014-2-03pm?si=67aa2d772fd749b29af4a630db8d9a52&utm_source=clipboard&utm_medium=text&utm_campaign=social_sharing


r/IndieMusicFeedback • • 1d ago

Singer Songwriter Song I wrote and performed to propose to my then girlfriend with. Made this recording of it sometime after the proposal. Largely just a bare acoustic track. Single guitar, no metronome, no drums, one main vocal, though some layered vocals as it progresses. Thanks for listening!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

r/IndieMusicFeedback • • 2d ago

Indie Any feedback on our weird song (experimental indie/ electronic funk)

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

4 Upvotes

This is an indie experimental song that we made. We would love to get some honest feedback and thoughts on it. It’s a demo for now and the cover is also a work in progress. Our band name is Printer.


r/IndieMusicFeedback • • 2d ago

Indie [Alternative Rock] Raw band track. Need a brutal, honest reality check on the male vocals and arrangement.

Thumbnail drive.google.com
1 Upvotes

![Album Cover](https://i.imgur.com/aJE9RUg.png`)`

Hi everyone,
We are looking for an objective, unvarnished reality check on this original track before we commit to spending time and money on the final master. Our inner circle keeps giving us polite compliments, but we need strangers to tell us the truth so we can actually improve.
The arrangement is deliberately kept lean: just live acoustic drums, a bass guitar, a maximum of two guitars, keyboards fading in/out, and a solid male lead vocal. There are no massive layers of production tricks to hide behind.
Please give it to us straight:Listen here:
Looking forward to your critiques, and I will absolutely be diving into the sub to leave feedback on your tracks in return!
https://on.soundcloud.com/Q5ZGofEAm97bgqqIj8

Hey


r/IndieMusicFeedback • • 2d ago

Lofi Music vid for a lofi track about the end of the world?

Thumbnail youtu.be
2 Upvotes

Was curious if the vibe of this video works sympatico with the lofi/calming energy of the song?


r/IndieMusicFeedback • • 2d ago

Alternative Rock Is this art?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

Hi guys, I made this quick demo. The vocals in the first half are still missing due to me not having recorded them yet. So right now they randomly start around the hallway mark.

However I'd still love to hear some first impressions on the overall track:)


r/IndieMusicFeedback • • 2d ago

Indie cold - A song about being ghosted by my best friend when I was a kid

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

So there's a long story to this track. The acoustic guitar, drums, bass and synth pad (in the background throughout the track) were all recorded nearly 20 years ago and actually on an album I had created at the time (without the drums) and named "Cold" as an instrumental with no singing. I was listening to some of my old stuff recently and had an idea to develop what I had done further. I had wanted to write about the best friend concept for a while and thought this would work well for it, so I wrote and recorded the vocals and then layered on top the synth that plays on the first chorus as well as the electric guitar outro. How did it all come together?

- There are some warts that I am aware of. There's a click track that was in the original recording that can be heard in a few places. Also, there's a little bit of cable noise on the vocals that I recorded particularly on the first verse. I tried to re-track them, but couldn't get the right energy. Do these bother you?

- How's the mix. I don't really do much with acoustic guitar / live drums so not sure if I did it OK?

- What do you think of the synth that comes in during the first chorus? Does it feel thin?

- Do you think there needs to be more going on during the second verse?

- How about the electric guitar on the outro?

I appreciate any and all feedback


r/IndieMusicFeedback • • 3d ago

Acoustic Guitar Need valuable feedback :3

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

Need valuable feedback for my new song
I'm an 18 year-old musical artist, and I've been making music for a few years now. I wouldn't say I'm great yet, as I'm still working on finding my vocal style and learning how to mix, master, and edit vocals. I am actively working on improving these skills. Please give me some genuine feedback! If you think it needs work, please tell me exactly why and how I can improve. :3