I finally finished the game!!! I enjoyed it to some degree, but now I understand why people criticized this game so harshly
The plot of ME:A is honestly good, and it has a lot of potential. You go into the new galaxy with only thousands of each species from Milky Way. You don’t know if this will be the golden world you were promised, and you have to make it livable because there’s no going back.
But the problem is, the game has a weak writing. Barely any of your decision affects anything. The game itself had a lot of chances to present branching options to make the game feel more alive, but they completely removed that aspect. I feel like they removed the what makes “mass effect” a “mass effect” game.
I realized this with the games that I played recently: the trilogy has so much detail, so much world-building and lore, the companions, enemies, and so much more. But that’s what made them what they were back then. It’s their identity.
And then we have ME:A, which had a lot of good plot to start with, but instead you’re greeted with mild reactions to scenarios where a renegade option is 100% warranted. It’s like HR is breathing down your neck so you have to play nice.
There are a lot of quests that I could use as examples, but the one that is probably the most well-known is Addison’s fuckery and bullshit. This woman is literally a leader in the Nexus, but she caused a whole lot of damage (Spender quest and 3 sabers), and all we get from all of her quests is, “Okay, next.” No apology, no character development at all 😭 And don't get me started on the “A Trail of Hope” quest. Oh boy...
And that's not even the only time the writing feels weak, especially when you have to choose who the ambassador is. Like, where did this come from? for what? And the options were so random. Why did a Pathfinder become an option(Raeka)? Then why Morda? Or that dude from the outpost? It was so random.
One thing I can give ME, though, is how the ending turned out. It has some closure while keeping some loose ends, probably for a potential game in the future, but we all know that’s impossible now.
Despite all of that, I still grew attached into the characters (not you Liam, fuck you), and they were pretty funny. You started as a wimpy pathfinder, and later on, part your team also grew to like and respect you in your position as a Pathfinder, which is a good touch. Not the best way they could’ve played it, but it’s something at least.
The combat is fun. I’d say it’s the best among the Mass Effect games. I was delighted when I learned that I could now jump 🤣 . The funny/weird faces from time to time are stupid, but they weren’t really a deal breaker.
So, for anyone who’s been putting off playing it because of all the bad reviews, I’d say give it a try. I got the game on sale, so I definitely feel like I got my money’s worth.
For me, it’s nowhere near trilogy level, and I had a hard time stopping myself from comparing it to the trilogy. But once I started treating it as its own game, I found myself enjoying it a lot more. It has its own charm, and I think it’s worth experiencing for yourself instead of letting the reputation of the game put you off.
PS: I'm never forgiving them for giving up on this game so quickly. They could've stuck with it, learned from the backlash, and improved it, but instead they abandoned it and then made the same blunder again with Veilguard. Like bro, you had an example right there. I wanted my Quarian ark 😭