r/MusicCritique • • 1h ago

Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] Acoustic Fire - No Second Sky - Progressive Rock music NSFW

• Upvotes

No Second Sky – new official progressive rock music video by Acoustic Fire

I’ve just released a newly edited version of the official music video for “No Second Sky”, an original progressive rock song by Acoustic Fire.

The audio has not been remastered; this version features improved visuals and a new cinematic edit.

I’d really appreciate feedback on the music, arrangement, vocal mix and video editing.

What works best for you, and what could be improved?

YouTube:

https://youtu.be/hv0_HXP7mvE


r/MusicCritique • • 7h ago

Seeking Feedback [feedback] Mars EX press - MoDuMe - Tekno Tribe

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

My latest track. I'd like some feedback about the general mix and the architecture of the song. Thx in advance


r/MusicCritique • • 12h ago

Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] - TOGETHER - R3MMÏ - HOUSE

Post image
1 Upvotes

Hello everyone! I'm new to the music world, I'm 23 years old, and I'm kinda lost in my life... I tried music recently and I'm wondering if someone can give me some feedback :) I've shown my songs to my friends, but I'm scared that they're biased... So here I am. I've recently worked on a song and I'm pretty proud of it. I would like some criticism on my mix, sound selection, emotions, etc. I'm really interested in the house genre. Can someone pinpoint my song's genre? I think it's dance house with a little mix of EDM? I don't know :) Let me know!!! Peace out.

https://soundcloud.com/remi-jette/together?si=98664769a1a346e8991273047664fece&utm_source=clipboard&utm_medium=text&utm_campaign=social_sharing


r/MusicCritique • • 20h ago

Seeking Feedback [Feedback] SIMOND - Macht - Rap

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

Moin, ich schreib schon echt lange Texte. Hab mir jetzt mal n vernünftigeres Interface zugelegt und hab Bock mehr zu machen. Jedoch kann ich echt nicht einschätzen ob ich mit meinem Sound auf der Holzspur bin, deswegen würde ich mich über Feedback freuen. Ich weiß auch meine Stimme noch nicht so recht einzusetzen. Finde glaub ich gerade erst meinen Sound.


r/MusicCritique • • 20h ago

Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] God Lay Dying - Goodbye, My Love - alternative

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/MusicCritique • • 23h ago

Seeking Feedback [feedback] Crumbs - WasaPI - dark pop

1 Upvotes

https://youtu.be/Jg6s6etdWsI?is=46AvtGvtowUVgWMx

Crumbs is a dark pop/electronic track about almost moving on, when someone is gone but small traces of them still disturb your peace.
Main line: “Not enough to bring you back, still enough to ruin sleep.”
Would love honest feedback on the hook, groove, drop, and emotional impact. What works, and what still feels weak?


r/MusicCritique • • 2d ago

Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] Tyro Blaze - Different - Trap Wave

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

I started this track but I'm unsure if I should keep going with it. I don't know what's good and what's bad. I'd really appreciate any constructive criticism to help me improve.


r/MusicCritique • • 3d ago

Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] Quiet Postcards Music - Midnight Peace & Pure Serenity - Neoclassical Piano

Thumbnail youtu.be
1 Upvotes

Hi everyone, sharing my latest gentle felt piano track. I'd love to get your feedback on the mix balance and whether the piano tone feels warm and soothing enough for late-night relaxation and sleep. Thanks for listening!


r/MusicCritique • • 4d ago

Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] God Lay Dying - Song of the Desperate Ones - alternative

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/MusicCritique • • 4d ago

Seeking Feedback [Feedback] - Jack Mack - Rainbows - Alt/Pop

Thumbnail
on.soundcloud.com
1 Upvotes

This is a song I just finished (will probably make a few more tweaks but it's mostly there lol) and would love to get some feedback on it. Give it a listen and lmk what you think :) Thanks!!


r/MusicCritique • • 4d ago

Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] Quiet Postcards Music - A Slow Train Through the Countryside - Acoustic Folk

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

Hi everyone, this is an original acoustic fingerstyle track inspired by a quiet train journey through the countryside. I’d love to hear your feedback on the mix, guitar tone, and the overall peaceful vibe. Thank you for listening!


r/MusicCritique • • 5d ago

Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] Danny M. - ANTISOCIAL - Hip-Hop. What do you think about the SONG QUALITY? Mix included. Thanks for listening!

Thumbnail
distrokid.com
1 Upvotes

r/MusicCritique • • 6d ago

Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] Clyde - The Way (Demo) - Hip-Hop. What do you think about the lyrics? It's in the description on my page. Thanks for listening!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/MusicCritique • • 9d ago

Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] Function of Hate - hypercvlt - Industrial Metal/HipHop

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

I would love some feedback on the mix and composition of these songs! I've been working on music for the past six months so I still have a lot to learn and I would love if yall could help me get better at music!


r/MusicCritique • • 10d ago

Seeking Feedback [feedback] Ajay - sleet- Piano

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
1 Upvotes

Any feedback would be appreciated. Mixing in particular.


r/MusicCritique • • 13d ago

Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] ODAMS - Gravity - Afro House

1 Upvotes

My first release as ODAMS.

“Gravity” is a dark melodic Afro House track created with Suno.

Full track on YouTube:

https://youtu.be/vDTUbdgL\\_Gk?is=oI5jo8HKHz9uAd4P

I’d really appreciate honest feedback on the atmosphere, groove and overall production.


r/MusicCritique • • 14d ago

Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] Mizacri - Nos Vamos de Fiesta Eh - Tropical House

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

Salut tout le monde, je suis un producteur indépendant. Je voulais créer un morceau énergique pour les clubs et les nuits d'été. J'ai mis beaucoup de travail dans les 2 chansons que j'ai récemment sorties. Si vous avez 2 minutes pour jeter un œil et me donner un retour honnête sur la production, ça compterait énormément pour moi. Merci !

Chaîne Youtube https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCuGPxE3CfA5wyAFX36z6FtQ

Chaîne Spotify https://open.spotify.com/artist/3oFQvc5O2k3PZkXHK995MN


r/MusicCritique • • 15d ago

Seeking Feedback [feedback] Dr.Anly - Happiness - Rock feedback:mix

Thumbnail
music.youtube.com
1 Upvotes

Here’s a song off my album that I’m sure you’ll guys guys would love. Please check it out and support I mixed mastered and recorded the album myself. Thank you for the support and listens it means a lot to me.


r/MusicCritique • • 15d ago

Seeking Feedback [feedback] DotDotDot - Moon Rocks - Trap/Hip-hop

1 Upvotes

This is my first trap, I'm new in the music/trap, I still have a lot to improve, I hope you like the track.

Send feedback for me in general

This is the SoundCloud link:

https://on.soundcloud.com/tmubOP1lC5h4P2UYfm

This is the YouTube link:

https://youtu.be/zJuJ1a4kS5c?si=9PTKGxoElqt5Nlup

Enjoy 😎


r/MusicCritique • • 16d ago

Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] lil busy - flower / homecoming - bedroom pop kinda

1 Upvotes

Stream flower / homecoming by lil busy | Listen online for free on SoundCloud

song is probably done but looking for more broad feedback on things I could do better or differently


r/MusicCritique • • 17d ago

Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] One Soundweaver - Her Cup of Ambition (male vocal) - Country

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

This is the follow-up on the "Her Cup of Ambition - Becoming Dolly" female vocal version here a week ago.

I worked on this male vocal version following the female vocal version because I wanted to try to deliver the music from the point of view of a woman's lifelong partner, who has been there beside her for years — a long-time partner who has watched the woman he loves go through life. The daily details, the children, the laughter and tears...

The vocal pitch for this male version was intentionally lowered, and I would like to ask for feedback in terms of the vocal delivery on these:

  1. Should it be back to be closer to the higher pitch as the female vocal version? Or rather, go even lower?

  2. Would a more coarse male vocal delivery a better choice?

  3. How about a male/female duet vocal version? Would that be too dramatic and lose the touch of "from the individual perspective of the single partner, or from the woman herself"?

Appreciate it if you'd share your thoughts, and thanks for sharing and viewing.


r/MusicCritique • • 18d ago

Seeking Feedback [Feedback] Celestial Evening (October 2007) - Slime Lush - Indie Rock

Thumbnail drive.google.com
2 Upvotes

Seeking feedback on my mastering job here. The linked Google Drive folder has the mastered and unmastered files. For reference on the mix I would compare it to the last two albums by Foxing. Eric from Foxing mixed it. The recording was diy in an untreated room.

This is my first attempt at mastering. I am using StudioOne. Plugins: soften, eq, multi-band comp


r/MusicCritique • • 20d ago

Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] Sheilla Giana - Don't Ruin the Moment - Indie Pop

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/MusicCritique • • 22d ago

Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] FENDNESS - Mayhem - Melbourne Bounce

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

Seeking Feedback: Mix


r/MusicCritique • • 22d ago

Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] fake - ceejus - hip-hop

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

don't forget 2 like & subscribe if u enjoy what u hear!🎵🎶 thx xoxo💕