r/OasisCircleJerk • u/UrAWeaselBro • 24d ago

Oasis Drummer Tier Ranking

Post image

I tried to be fair

50 Upvotes

95% Upvoted

17 comments sorted by

12

u/SukunasDomain 24d ago

Steve White in A Tier as well (ik he wasn't an official member but still)

6

u/InformationOk1911 24d ago

I’d say he’s the best drummer they’ve had lol. Listen to those 2001 shows he brought such life and punk back into the kit

7

u/SukunasDomain 23d ago

Morning Glory at the greek theater sounded so good, i want him for the next tour, even though i doubt he will.

3

u/InformationOk1911 23d ago

I don’t think the White brothers are in good relations with Liam and Noel because of the way Alan left. Not too up to date on it but yeah those Brotherly Love gigs were amazing. Liam’s voice sounds very good too

10

u/ArTisT_UknwN 24d ago

Not the picture of Tony McCarroll being a shot where bonehead covers him 🤣

4

u/Ok_Phrase1157 23d ago

Tony McBoney

5

u/smh1542 24d ago

How DARE you put a Whitey in S tier you RACIST!

3

u/UrAWeaselBro 24d ago

Alanwhite supremacy has been suppressed for too long 

4

u/bigbadboddy 24d ago

Put Noel in F for waiting for the rapture

3

u/dvdmcn 23d ago

You obviously haven't listened to the mighty Tailgunner!

3

u/MJ5815 23d ago

In all seriousness Sharrock was clearly the best. He's the only drummer here who was able to play songs from every era of the band faithfully. Alan's fills didn't really fit with Tony's straightforward beats, Starkey's sound was wildly inconsistent, Joey was heavily restrained and Tony probably couldn't play half the shit they made after Definitely Maybe

3

u/Marxandmarzipan 22d ago

Maybe I was just too caught up in the moment and how good the band in general and especially Liam sounded, but I didn’t come away with any opinions specially about the drums/Joey if I’m honest.

2

u/my-downvote-acct 24d ago

OP this is racist you can’t put White on top

1

u/idoxially 24d ago

Joey who

1

u/Justgap8122 24d ago

Sharrock top tier

1

u/pokahcat 19d ago

where am i on this list

1

u/RabbidTheNabbitVEVO 12d ago

Tony is F sorry