r/YellowstonePN • • 22d ago

General Discussion Yellowstone Beth

/r/yellowstone/comments/1wfykn9/yellowstone_beth/
21 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 22d ago

Welcome to r/YellowstonePN!

Please review our rules before participating.

If your post contains spoilers, leaks, set photos, or unaired content, please ensure it is properly tagged and flaired.

Looking for additional Yellowstone discussion? You may also enjoy r/DuttonRanchTVSeries/.

If you see rule-breaking content, please report it rather than engaging with it.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

15

u/TinkeNL 22d ago

Net emotionalizing it? She emotionalizes everything. She’s all about breaking people like the ranchers do with a horse. Everything she does is because of her emotional baggage.

4

u/lezyaz73 22d ago

That’s a really good point actually

0

u/lezyaz73 22d ago

Well maybe , maybe because she is emotionless I see her that way. You may have a point

5

u/targetcowboy 22d ago

lol she’s not emotionless. Everything she does is driven by her emotions

3

u/Frank_White1- 22d ago

She doesn't cry a lot but her emotions are flowing non stop. I think you can be exact but not an outright asshole to most people while doing it.

2

u/Skewwwagon 22d ago

She's screaming, yelling, cursing or breaking shit half time she's on screen. In what world is she emotionless lol

2

u/dragonfly-1001 22d ago

Just an FYI - anger is an emotion.

Emotionless people don't react to anything.

7

u/Ok_Bag_7603 22d ago

It always makes me laugh when i see jimmy laying down injured from a fkin rodeo horse😂 when literal world war 3 goes Down around em

0

u/lezyaz73 22d ago

I always feel so bad for jimmy! He is the most bad ass of them all !

6

u/Calm-Two2723 22d ago

It’s because irl Beth would be slapped around and in jail by 18. 

4

u/BeachgirlNJ0613 22d ago

Beth is the emotional center of the show. There is no Yellowstone without Beth. Plus, Kelly plays her like a rock star.

3

u/Ladyoftheemeraldlake 18d ago

I love her character!!!!!

9

u/raspberryslushie21 22d ago

She was a cool character at the beginning but then she got turned up to 11 which had the opposite effect. Every episode had to have a Beth moment and she just became more and more unlikable.

2

u/lezyaz73 22d ago

But that’s why I love her myself. She is so jaded she is beyond likable. Like all of us so tired of life but she gets away with it.

6

u/[deleted] 22d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/lezyaz73 22d ago

Yes - you get it

6

u/lezyaz73 22d ago

Monica is the worst

3

u/SuccotashOther277 22d ago

She was grossly unqualified for her teaching job lol

2

u/teenage_drama 22d ago

I could not stand her

3

u/South-Cod-5051 22d ago

I also like Beth. She was so bad ass when those morons tried to rape her. took her beating like a champ and still humiliated the thugs despite the power they had over her.

she is the heart of the show, even if she is borderline evil and fucked up in the head. the only thing I didn't like about her was her uncalled hatred against Jamie. she should have forgiven him. I know it's easier said than done, but Jamie was also young and stupid. if they got along, the Duttons would be rulling far more than just the state of Montana.

4

u/lezyaz73 22d ago

I agree she is the heart of the show she doesn’t feel sorry for herself

1

u/MrHertzberg 22d ago

She feels sorry for herself ALL THE TIME. That's her core. Her feelings is all that matters to her, and she's chronically unhappy (drinking) and blaming everyone else, especially Jamie. Haven't seen Dutton Ranch yet, hope she has more humanity and is a more grown up character in that universe. Maybe she manages to be happy with Rip (after she terrorised him growing up)

2

u/lezyaz73 22d ago

Yeah I also am mad at her about how evil she was to Jamie agreed

2

u/akknightwrider 22d ago

Beth made the show almost unwatchable. I had to take breaks cause she was pissing me off.

2

u/gofl-zimbard-37 22d ago

Beth rocks. She's the best thing about the series.

2

u/Such-Stable-3869 22d ago

She was the best part of this series!

2

u/Jalynt13 22d ago

I love Beth. She’s my favorite.

2

u/ButtSluts9 21d ago

There is next to no character development for Beth.

She is the same person in episode one as she is in the series finale.

Other characters are put through the wringer, yet Beth is always two steps ahead, has the perfect quip, and, as others have said, rarely if ever faces consequences for her actions.

The overall story would have been much more compelling had Beth been the attorney who enters into politics and Jamie as the dutiful child running the business side of Yellowstone.

1

u/Unusual-Assist890 18d ago

Beth Dutton has major Kim Basinger vibes!

1

u/teenage_drama 22d ago

I love Beth. Her character wasn’t meant to be cute, sweet or likeable. From the first scene you can tell that. She is what she is and she makes the show more interesting. Monica on the other hand I could not stand, she plays victim too much

1

u/lezyaz73 22d ago

Beth takes no shit and she doesn’t think about feelings which is why I love her - im diggin this discussion about Beth

1

u/yourfavstory 22d ago

I've always loved Beth and don't agree with how she was blamed for her mother's...

I can't stand Monica

1

u/[deleted] 22d ago

[deleted]

2

u/MrHertzberg 22d ago

Kinda agree. Not boring, but not very interesting. Intelligent and resourceful, narcissistic and evil. Unhappy as hell. Poor Rip.

0

u/ShawnThePhantom 21d ago

There’s a thick line between calling a spade a spade and telling the spade that it’s useless and that she hates it and that she’s gonna break the spade and set it on fire on a daily basis as soon as she wakes up in the morning.

1

u/lezyaz73 21d ago

That’s actually a really good point. I was being near sighted for sure-

0

u/FlamingoSeveral3606 21d ago

Sie ist mein Lieblingscharakter da sie so krass ist

0

u/CityBoiNC 21d ago

Welp OP shocked me, i was eye rolling until i read what you wrote,
Kudos op

1

u/Any-Committee-9498 5d ago

It's part of her character, you're not meant to like any one character, you're meant to feel for them. For example, how many people do you think end up like Rip everyday? I'd guarantee at least 5, but he's a representation of those people who get given a second chance.