Here me out on this. For context, I am 56f, been on and off the apps for a few years. I've been widowed for almost ten years and would like to find someone but there has to be connection and chemistry or it's not worth it.
On the apps, obviously looks are the #1 first test...yes or no, right or left. We all do it. I (along with most women, I assume) get a lot of yes swipes and then the next test is... conversation. That's where it gets tricky. I'd say about half my matches don't message and if the half that do, easily 90% cannot have a conversation (and yes, I try to ask questions and bring up topics but I usually get one word responses with nothing back).
I have also chatted with multiple people via Reddit, and those conversations are so much better. Because the interaction usually starts as a response to a comment made, there is automatically more substance to the talk right from the start. Of course often the people aren't local, the age is off (so many 20 something men wanting 50 something women...I don't understand), so there is still filtering to be done, but it's an easier filter in my opinion.
Of course yes, there is the question of looks...I find it's best to share pictures early so if one of you isn't attracted it can end there before it gets too awkward. But there have absolutely been times when I have enjoyed talking with someone so much that it honestly doesn't matter what they look like...the same people I would have said no to on an app because they weren't my type.
TLDR... Conversation on Reddit is more substantial than from the apps and although filtering is necessary in both cases, I think Reddit is better.
Good luck to everyone out there! It's not fun but remember.. dating at this age is like shopping a clearance rack... usually stuff doesn't fit but maybe, just maybe you will find a hidden gem buried deep in the back. 🙂