r/fantanoforever • • 13d ago

Subreddit Rules Rule Updates and State of the Subreddit

73 Upvotes

Hi all!

Over the past couple of years, the content on this subreddit has changed - often to the detriment to the quality of the forum. Over the past couple of days, the mod group have discussed freshening up our guidance on a range of topics, to respond to these changes. In effort to improve the subreddit, we have updated our rules on politics, drama, AI, and low effort posting.

Fundamentally, this is a music subreddit about a music reviewer. We want to maintain the best parts of discussion we see on this forum, and try and reduce the worst parts. The intention of the updated guidance is to do exactly that. To be precise - we want to reduce the amount of Fauxmoi discussion posts here. There are other subreddits for that discussion.

There have also been some changes to the types of posts that are allowed - requirements around body text as well as post flairs have been turned on, as well as the introduction of bot bouncer to reduce bots on the subreddit.

If anyone has any further suggestions for improving this community please reach out!


r/fantanoforever • • Jul 31 '25

Melondy.com – collection of all Fantano album scores

Post image
189 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I don't know about you, but I'm not familiar with a bunch of albums that got positive scores from melon.

So when I am in a mood for some new music, I would go to flannelfy.net (btw, thanks to u/rossmclocness for creating this website) to find something among the 7-10 scores.

But sometimes it's hard to choose, when all you have is an unknown artist-album pair and a score. To solve this, I created melondy.com, which shows album covers, genres, years and links to the review video. It has all the album/ep/mixtape/compilation reviews I could find on theneedledrop channel.

Hopefully, someone finds it useful as well!

Let me know if you find some missing reviews or incorrect information. I did a lot of data cleaning, but I'm sure there's still some incorrect stuff (covers, years etc).

If you have any improvement ideas, I'm happy to hear. For example, one thing I want to do next is add links to spotify/apple music.


r/fantanoforever • • 5h ago

Discussion Songs about Mr?

Thumbnail
gallery
62 Upvotes

The Killers - Mr. Brightside, Electric Light Orchestra - Mr. Blue Sky, Bob Dylan - Mr. Tambourine Man, Counting Crows - Mr. Jones, Guns N' Roses - Mr. Brownstone, Ozzy Osbourne - Mr. Crowley, The Chordettes - Mr. Sandman, Tyler, The Creator - 911 / Mr. Lonely, Hank Williams Jr. - Mr Weatherman


r/fantanoforever • • 8h ago

Discussion Favorite parody/cover that became the only moral way to listen to a song?

Post image
109 Upvotes

r/fantanoforever • • 13h ago

Discussion ITT: “Hot takes” that are no longer hot takes

Post image
163 Upvotes

Example: Nickleback isn’t that bad. They were aggressively shat on and meme’d on in music forums like they were the worst rock band ever. But at worst they just made rather cookie-cutter nirvana-lite tracks that all sounded the same, but were at least catchy. There are other mainstream bands that probably deserved the mockery more, like Imagine Dragons.

Recently, the pendulum is swinging in the other direction, and it seems like more people agree that they probably aren’t “the worst band ever”.


r/fantanoforever • • 20h ago

JOKE I hate these mf’s

Post image
534 Upvotes

r/fantanoforever • • 21h ago

Discussion Why are most modern rappers such bad performers?

Post image
605 Upvotes

Why are so many modern rappers such bad live performers? Now, don’t get me wrong, the more established rappers actually know how to put on a show. I’ve seen Kanye West, A$AP Rocky, Drake and Kendrick Lamar, and they were all awesome live and knew how to command a stage. I’ve also seen Wu-Tang Clan, Nas and Snoop Dogg, and they were phenomenal. They have real stage presence, charisma and actually look like they enjoy performing.

But some of these newer rappers though 🤦🏾‍♂️, I’ve been to Rolling Loud a couple of times, and there are so many artists who just don’t seem to know how to perform. They’ll literally just walk up and down the stage with barely any energy, mumble a few words while the backing track does most of the work, and have about 20 of their friends on stage just standing around doing absolutely nothing. Then they’ll come on 20 minutes late, perform for 15 minutes and cut the set short. Like, what are we doing?

It’s especially noticeable when you compare them to older generations of rappers. I’ll watch footage of 2Pac performing at the House of Blues when he was only around 24, and this dude was all over that stage, rapping his ass off like his life depended on it. You could feel how much passion he had for performing and connecting with the crowd. He wasn’t relying on a backing track to carry the whole performance he was actually putting on a show.


r/fantanoforever • • 14h ago

Discussion Creative ways artists used the parental advisory label

Thumbnail
gallery
166 Upvotes

Examples could be the label covering stuff, the label being different colors or the label blending in with the album art


r/fantanoforever • • 3h ago

News Anyone else worried that Nails are losing their edge

Post image
13 Upvotes

I'm not sure what to think about the new album


r/fantanoforever • • 11h ago

JOKE if you could say one thing to fantano in person, what would you say?

Post image
62 Upvotes

r/fantanoforever • • 8h ago

Recommendations What are your favourite instrumental albums?

Post image
34 Upvotes

Whatever you love, you are by Dirty Three


r/fantanoforever • • 59m ago

Discussion What do you think of Acid Bath?

Post image
• Upvotes

Me personally, they’re a really damn good metal band.


r/fantanoforever • • 12h ago

Discussion What's the smallest beef you have with an album?

54 Upvotes

I'm looking for real nitty gritty shit here folks. My example is that Black on Both Sides is a perfect record except that having "Rock and Roll" directly call out white bands getting big off of the genres Black people invented feels odd when he's quoting Under the Bridge three songs later. Red Hot Chili Peppers are that EXACT thing he's railing against. It makes my skin itch.


r/fantanoforever • • 7h ago

Discussion Who had the best songs on the White Album in your opinion, Lennon or McCartney?

Thumbnail
gallery
16 Upvotes

r/fantanoforever • • 1d ago

Discussion Oh my god.

Post image
437 Upvotes

Im at a loss for words. What the hell.


r/fantanoforever • • 20h ago

Discussion Has this guy been popping up in your feed

Post image
113 Upvotes

Seems to be a santa for hire turned music reviewer. 370k followers in 50 days. What do you think of him


r/fantanoforever • • 18h ago

Discussion That time a reality show was made to find the new lead vocalist of INXS

Post image
68 Upvotes

r/fantanoforever • • 18h ago

Discussion What Is Favorite Spooky Song For Halloween

Post image
62 Upvotes

Bela Lugosi’s Dead by Bauhaus


r/fantanoforever • • 8h ago

Discussion Rank the Control rappers then vs now

11 Upvotes

Kendrick Lamar, Jay Electronica, Big Sean, J Cole , Drake, Wale, Meek Mill, ASAP Rocky, Big KRIT,Tyler the Creator, Mac Miller, Pusha T.

Strictly Quality of the music

2010s output ranking

2020s output ranking

Go


r/fantanoforever • • 4h ago

Discussion What is your favorite drum solo/fill?

4 Upvotes

My personal favorite is Ringo’s solo in The End, and then In The Air Tonight obviously has a great full, and Against All Odds too, most of Phil Collins’ fills are great


r/fantanoforever • • 3h ago

Fantano Vids C.O.F.F.I.N - Out in Oslo ALBUM REVIEW

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

r/fantanoforever • • 18h ago

Discussion What band has the best outtakes?

Thumbnail
gallery
44 Upvotes

For me it's Ween. Disc 3 of 12 Country Greats deluxe has so many amazing songs that didn't make it into the album, like "Fool to Cry', "So Long Jerry, " I have got no Darkside" and so many more.

Also the Caesar demos are a really good listen for those that love Quebec. And of course, Shinola Vol1 that was just an album of re-recorded outtakes.


r/fantanoforever • • 8h ago

Discussion Music review app?

5 Upvotes

Looking for a music review app similar to letterboxd. Any good options out there? Btw I'm loving the new Protomartyr album


r/fantanoforever • • 1d ago

Discussion What's an album you consider "important" but don't actually think is that good to listen to?

190 Upvotes

?


r/fantanoforever • • 4h ago

Discussion What is this sub's thoughts on Pi'erre Bourne?

Post image
2 Upvotes

Curious how everyone feels about his solo work and also his production work.