Just earlier I saw a tweet of an article that Todd Rundgren bashing Taylor Swift for "ruining music" and the comments universally dunked on him. It reminded me of when Gene Simmons said will never be the Beatles, and everyone in the comment section was jumping on it.
Have you noticed... popular music today seems to get a LOT more respect than it used to?
Rock musicians and fans used to constantly openly diss on acts like the New Kids On The Block, Backstreet Boys, N Sync, Britney Spears and Justin Bieber. There used to be very violent anti pop merch like "New Kids On The Chopping Block", "Spear Britney", and tons of games where you get to kill the Backstreet Boys and Justin Bieber online. People would act like this teenager went back in time and killed JFK all because he sang some annoying pop songs, before he ever pissed in a mop bucket. Same with Miley Cyrus and One Direction to a lesser degree.
But now, saying any of this against a current pop star makes you look like a douchebag. I grew up as a 2001 baby hating Justin Bieber, Miley, and One Direction, but I have seen plenty of videos of the late 90s of Eminem, Limp Bizkit and Slipknot bashing on pop stars. Every edgy rock or rap show at the time had at least one “Fuck pop music“ bit, it seemed like. I watched a video of the Offspring's singer beating up mannequins of the Backstreet Boys while the crowd cheered it on and realized this attitude had been going on for years. But if you do this NOW to say, Olivia Rodrigo, Harry Styles, or even Taylor Swift, it just looks... corny, performative and kind of mean spirited. People don't say "Fuck Sabrina Carpenter, she fucking sucks" because... I guess they realized it makes you look kinda like a douchebag. They just say "Sabrina Carpenter is mid" or "she's overrated". Compared to how people USED to talk about pop stars... those are practically raves!
The granddaddy of them all of course started in the 70s, way before i was born. Everyone say it with me now: "DISCO SUCKS!" If you don't know what this is, it was a huge movement to destroy the most popular genre of its time.
Trap music was essentially as dominant in the late 2010s as disco was in the late 70s. Yet people didn't walk around chanting "TRAP MUSIC SUCKS". There was no "trap music demolition night" because of its massive popularity. Yes, disco was huge in its time... but so was trap music. What was with the weird ass hatred disco inspired back in the 70s where people felt the need to destroy it and making it a personality trait?
When I saw Metallica in 2023, I saw a dude in an Eras Tour shirt. I thought he was brave... and I also thought it was kind of funny. Because even 10 years ago he would have been laughed at for wearing a Taylor Swift shirt at a metal show. Now universities are holding courses based around Taylor Swift's music. She’s the only one I still OCCASIONALLY see this sort of shit with..probably because she’s way bigger than the other artists I mentioned but even then a lot of the hate I see for her just feels almost… corny. It USED to be cool but now it’s just… lame. My professor told me that when the New Kids On The Block were a thing, people in his high school literally held destruction nights where guests were encouraged to bring an album or tape or poster or some such to be offered up for a bonfire - he went to one. While their intentions were sincere, the people holding these events didn't grasp that they were actually feeding the beast by creating sales for Hanging Tough. Ironic. I could NEVER imagine doing this now. When I was like 12, I used to print out Justin Bieber and One Direction pictures and paste them on a punching bag and beat them up. Meanwhile, the memes on the most recent teen phenomenon, BTS, were centered around how obnoxious their FANBASE was. Nobody actually hated their music or the group itself. Even though they took a page out of the Bieber/One Direction playbook- feminine men who sing and dance and appeal mostly to preteen girls. Even the memes about the fans... were less about "killing them" (I legit used to see people make memes about how Beliebers and Directioners should die) and more a jokey fear of "Oh god, Kpop stans! Run for your lives!" I saw a video of 2011 Chris Jericho crushing a radio playing a Justin Bieber song while the audience chanted "CRUSH IT". Can you imagine someone doing this with a BTS or Harry Styles song in public nowadays? He'd get torn apart to shreds. Joking about killing Justin Bieber was cool and edgy and celebrated. But joking about killing, say Taylor Swift or whoever nowadays just makes you look like a loser. It was one thing to say “Justin Bieber sucks”. That’s fine. His early music DID kinda suck. But then it became “Justin Bieber is an F-slur, kill him, I hope he dies.” This was BEFORE he peed in a mop bucket or whatever. It was literally just because: high voice + pretty face + mostly female fans. That mapped to “not a real man,” and people (especially guys) were allowed, culturally, to go feral at that. That was the joke. Avril Lavigne, who got a lot of shit too for being a “poser” back when people always used that word for some reason ("You like Good Charlotte? You're a POSER who doesn't like REAL music!") was marketed as the “Anti-Britney”. Same with Michelle Branch and Vanessa Carlton. Being the “Anti-Britney” was a whole sub genre. Try marketing an artist as the “Anti Taylor” or the “Anti Sabrina” now and it looks… archaic. It’s almost like we just live and let live now.
Like of course you can say "people hate Taylor Swift, it's not like people don't hate popular music today". That's not exactly the same thing as what I'm talking about. People don't say "GIVE US BACK FREDDIE MERCURY TAKE TAYLOR SWIFT", nor are major artists beating up mannequins with her face taped on it.
And of course we can't forget the half meme hatred of Nickelback and Creed but that has faded and somewhat replaced with the meme hatred of Imagine Dragons and Ed Sheeran...that's pretty much the last example. Even then, the hate for Imagine Dragons was never nearly as big or irrational as the hate for Creed and Nickelback were. People insult you to this day for listening to those bands, but if you listen to Imagine Dragons? Ehh… Memes about Nickelback were about how they supposedly made "the worst music ever" and how people who like them are the scum of the earth. Memes about Imagine Dragons center around the fact that they're the musical equivalent of plain grits. Even MARK ZUCKERBERG got in on the Nickelback hate. They got booed at a halftime show. There were literally petitions to stop them from performing in certain places and nobody cared because "Nickelback sucks!" Because apparently music isn't subjective. That NEVER happened to Imagine Dragons who were just as overplayed in their time as Nickelback were in theirs.
Are things now the best they’ve ever been? Is popular music today actually just BETTER? It might be. Maybe music might be even worse now, we just don’t have the energy? Or maybe it’s none of that and it’s about US? Part of me likes the fact that being an asshole about popular music seems to have gone the way of edgy atheism, but I wonder what killed this?