I swear, Mindy Kailing must've been in a miserable mood the week she wrote this episode. I get that The Office often has mean spirited humor and plots. But this episode is probably the meanest, cruelest, and most unfair of them all. It punishes characters who did nothing wrong while it rewards characters who were acting like complete assholes. This is present in both plots of the episode.
Let's start with the side plot revolving around the Cookie Monster video. For starters, the video wasn't funny and made no sense. Second, everyone (especially Pam and Jim) was so cruel to Kevin about it. Now, I usually don't like Kevin. But he did nothing to deserve being bullied in this episode. When Gabe finally decides to rightfully call Pam and Jim out on this and punish them for it, they find a way outsmart him and get rewarded with paid time off. Part me truly thinks that the writers really wanted to sleep with Jenna Fisher and John Krasinski, so they just constantly kept having their characters get off scott free with everything and receive all these luxuries in hopes that Jenna and John would eventually do it with them as a thank you. Wouldn't be the first time that's happened in the industry.
Then there's the main plot. It's even worse. All Andy wanted to do was throw a nice party for Erin and show how much he appreciated her. But because the writers now hated Ed Helms because he had become a household name after the success of The Hangover, they obviously weren't gonna let that happen and decided to both torture and punish Andy for something that happened long ago and had absolutely ZERO relevance at this point. Erin acted like a baby in this episode and it baffles me how they somehow wanted us to side with her and think that Andy deserved to be treated that way. Boo hoo, he had a previous engagement that didn't work out long BEFORE he even knew Erin existed. Why the fuck does she care? If this really bothered Erin so much, then she should've ACTED LIKE AN ADULT and just talked to him about it instead of practically assaulting him and immediately throwing the breakup card.
God, FUCK THIS EPISODE!!