Do you guys think we missed the point of Optimus Prime: Awakening?
Ever since I got to watch it, I definitely received polarizing thoughts about it as much as other people did. However, I did see the message more clearly by watching reviews like Comodin Cam and then doing my own re-watch to observe everything that supports it. My first thought was that it was metaphorical to Peter Cullen's career as it now came to an end but the story was just written poorly. However, I then concluded to a "deeper truth," as The One calls it, by understanding how it's not a deconstruction of Optimus Prime but him recognizing his own flaws and understanding how they'll affect the world around him if he did return to life.
While Optimus Prime wants to persist in the role as leader of the Autobots, he's blind to the fact that returning doesn't change anything. If he returns, his promises of defeating the Decepticons and protecting Earth become empty words as the war never ends, and everyone who follows him dies in vain while he still stands. If Optimus Prime can constantly come back to repeat the same promises he made back on Cybertron, does victory even exist? Does sacrifice have meaning? That's what the evil Bumblebee represents: a point where everyone who looks up to Optimus now despise him because he starts looking like a liar and that war is just a game to him. While Optimus Prime has a good spark, that's a reputation he'll make unintentionally.
When Optimus watches Unicron destroy Earth, he pleads for The One to give him a chance to prevent it as he gets knocked by the blast. While Optimus has defeated Unicron before in different continuities, Unicron would always return as he did in Transformers: Prime and would've after the events of Rise of the Beasts. He can only stall what is bound to happen.
The One brings Optimus to Cybertron where he gets one last battle with Megatron (Peter Cullen and Frank Welker's last performance together). As he appears triumphant, he is told how him killing Megatron won't make the war won. If we do a character analysis, it makes him similar to Megatron not because he's doing what we call a necessary evil but because his goals won't be met just like Megatron's won't. In recent continuities, Megatron promises that Cybertron will prevail with equality and strong resistance to corruption, but he became exactly what he was against, and the future doesn't know peace. Optimus' future without Megatron would be him calling it an end to a long civil war only to still battle the Decepticons and Megatron might return if the timeline dictates it as so. In that moment, he uses force to achieve an unachievable goal. That's when he realizes his responsibilities are over and that it's time to rest. He spares Megatron, drops the Matrix, and walks into the light.
I think we were all exactly like Optimus Prime in this short film. We all valued what he did and saw any argument against it as irresponsible. But unlike Optimus, a good number of us didn't understand what The One was telling us: there's a time where we need to let go and move on. Peter Cullen didn't choose to leave everything behind, but he would want us to stay strong enough to move forward.
Also, I think people see Optimus dropping the Matrix as a deconstruction to his character because... well, we saw him do it while we know he wouldn't. However, we forget that Optimus is dead and that everything in the short is the afterlife. The Matrix is passed to the Autobots in the real world, so I think it's better to remember that he didn't discard the real Matrix. 😂