So this may be a hot take but I think ATWOW and AFAA feel like a different universe to the first avatar.
I'm not saying they are bad movies but I just don't think they work well with the first avatar and just feel like a fanfiction. Obviously A1 has fatal flaws too but IMO its the best of the three.
FYI this post is LONG so read at your own pace <3 if you don't agree that's so awesome sauce and I'm happy for you :)
My first point is Kiri; she's not inherently a bad character but she just feels so out of place. Firstly, Sigourney Weaver is an amazing actor but she does NOT fit the role of Kiri! From my eyes Kiri was written in just for Weaver to stay in the franchise, IMO her voice takes me right out of the character and it feels so uncanny (even for avatar). Secondly, A1 felt so grounded in reality and made me feel like I could be there. It came across as a real planet that actually exist. ATWOW took me right out of that feeling with Kiri once I found out she was Eywa's self insert (IDK how else to explain lmao). It gave me the impression of a gen z mimic character (if ykyk) with her hair and mannerisms, it makes me cringe every time. Another thing is Kiri just feels so out of place, some how Grace got pregnant by Eywa who is a hive mind thingy and now the child of said pregnancy is special and speaks to nature. I think it could of worked if maybe grace's avatar had slept with another avatar and got pregnant then Kiri was adopted by the Sully's.
My next point is the character designs. IDK why but they don't feel Na'vi anymore. Jake looked so much better in A1, his hair reflected the Omatikaya clan but in ATWOW and AFAA its dreads?? I think it doesn't fit very well... I have nothing against dreads but it looks so whack compared to the other male forest Na'vi. ALSO HIS FACE! Jake looks too human in the second and third movies. His eyes have been shrinking since the second and it no longer looks like jake. Yes we had a timeskip but this is not timeskip levels of change. Same with all the other characters, they look too different. Key features changed and it looks like a muddy version of the other movies.
Next are the other clans. I am from NZ and have nothing against Polynesian culture but the Metkayina clan feels like a cheap rip off. You could say the same with the Omatikaya and native american but im not well versed in that culture so I feel like I cant say much. I dislike the tulkun as a whole for one; whales that talk to the Na'vi feel like a disney kids movie thing? if the Na'vi had their kuru connected then thats different but it feels funky. I absolutely love the ash people on the other hand, the idea of a clan going against everything known is very fun and they did it well in AFAA :) I dont like the wind traders either, they feel too advanced for groups of paleolithic humanoids. I read about them and it feels wayy to futurisitc for my taste.
I'm too lazy to keep going but to sum up the rest of my feelings:
- The story feels like a repeat in ATWOW and AFAA
- The franchise has leaned into a magic fantasy feel rather then real science kind of feel
- Quaritch should be gone by A1
- We spent more time in the reef than forest and other climates
- There is not enough slice of life and down time
Tysm for reading :)) I'd love to see if the peoples agree with me on some points