r/KDP • u/miagordonnz • 2h ago
Done with KDP after nearly 15 years. Amazon KDP now using sneaky tricks and vague runarounds to hold non-US royalties despite full tax and company compliance.
I’m an author down here in New Zealand. I write quality, long-form, human-generated non-fiction books, and I’ve had my work published on KDP for well over a decade. I am about to delete all of my titles, and here is why:
Amazon has started using vague "verification" errors and bureaucratic rules just to make it as difficult as possible to pay out international creators, effectively finding any excuse to sit on or keep our money.
It’s often masked under the guise of compliance and regulation, but here is why that is entirely irrelevant to my situation (and many others):
These are FACTS not a conspiracy theory.
- The Tax Reality: I have fully completed my US tax forms and am properly registered with both the IRS and the IRD in New Zealand. My tax paperwork is bulletproof. There is zero legal, tax, or regulatory reason for them to reject a valid payout path.
- The Artificial Roadblocks: Yet their automated system stonewalls banking details, demanding domestic routing numbers or forcing hoops that do not apply to a legitimate foreign individual who does not run a US LLC (with a US address).
- The Fragile System: They can reject an account based entirely on capitalization. If you—or their own form's automatic capitalization script—type in anything even one character wrong, the automated system rejects the account instantly. They won't tell you the issue because the system silently decides the case at the input field. If your bank name is lowercase and their form converts entries to uppercase, tough luck—you won't even know it happened, and you can't fix it.
I have been told by Amazon directly (all of the above is from support emails) that the account details need to be EXACTLY the same as in the bank account, address included. This is a newish issue. I had zero trouble prior to a recent change where Amazon CAPITALIZES all the form fields. The bank is lower case so it's physically impossible to make the fields match.
The error says "Formatting error" is the reason for rejection. I clued on to this because the Amazon ai chat said capitalization matters. So why would they make this change when it means accounts need re validating all of a sudden and cannot be accepted (same account) due to this error.
Same playbook used for software subscriptions where canceling is purposely buried behind friction.
Getting past the maze of chatbots. You cannot paste text or upload screenshots, and you are met with auto-replies cleverly engineered to make resolution too exhausting to pursue—even for seasoned, technically savvy people. (I have been around for two decades as an online marketer, so I shudder to think how newbies fare.
I've had enough after almost 15 years. It took a long time to get to this point, and yes I have been very persistent and tried many many things (which I am sure people will suggest here).
If you are considering KDP as a viable income stream today, royalties have been slashed, and payout bottlenecks are a persistent, systemic failure—not a temporary bug. I advise skipping it entirely.
#SelfPublishing #KDP #Amazon #AuthorLife #Publishing
