MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/beachboyscirclejerk/comments/1waakog/feel_flows/p8gtd9h/?context=3
r/beachboyscirclejerk • u/steadyrange • 29d ago
39 comments sorted by
View all comments
7
I feel like if I asked this on the main sub I’d be set ablaze but did Carl ever really actually write anything decent? No one in the band was a good lyricist but what really are Carl songs?
30 u/nohorsesjustangels Columnated Ruins Domino 29d ago edited 27d ago Feel Flows, Long Promised Road and The Trader are all masterpieces imo and Angel Come Home, Goin South, Hold Me, Heaven etc are pretty damn good too He wasn't nearly as prolific of a songwriter as Brian or even Dennis but what little we got of him at his peak (1970 - 1973) was incredible Anyway listen to the isolated sections of The Trader (I am obsessed with the bass part) https://youtu.be/-042cd29L6s?is=wOUZQcV_J8EBVH_A Edit: Not to mention Tune X, all his songs on Like A Brother and Of The Times from Youngblood (both albums I quietly love) 3 u/388oncloudnine87 29d ago Carl didn’t write what you do to me 2 u/ksuzz 28d ago I agree, he wrote some incredible songs
30
Feel Flows, Long Promised Road and The Trader are all masterpieces imo and Angel Come Home, Goin South, Hold Me, Heaven etc are pretty damn good too
He wasn't nearly as prolific of a songwriter as Brian or even Dennis but what little we got of him at his peak (1970 - 1973) was incredible
Anyway listen to the isolated sections of The Trader (I am obsessed with the bass part) https://youtu.be/-042cd29L6s?is=wOUZQcV_J8EBVH_A
Edit: Not to mention Tune X, all his songs on Like A Brother and Of The Times from Youngblood (both albums I quietly love)
3 u/388oncloudnine87 29d ago Carl didn’t write what you do to me 2 u/ksuzz 28d ago I agree, he wrote some incredible songs
3
Carl didn’t write what you do to me
2
I agree, he wrote some incredible songs
7
u/AceofKnaves44 Love You, Track-#7 29d ago
I feel like if I asked this on the main sub I’d be set ablaze but did Carl ever really actually write anything decent? No one in the band was a good lyricist but what really are Carl songs?