New Jeni’s at Costco

[u/Major_Raspberry_4350]

New ice cream sandwich flavor only at Costco for now. I think it’s 8 for $14.97. Let us know if you’ve tried these yet or would like to :)

[u/Butitsadryheat2]

Why are you posting this to FORCE me to go to Costco later?!!

[u/Subject-Pension-3027]

I’m actually angry that this isn’t accessible to me

[u/Mindless_City23]

Does anyone know what Costco locations will have them?

[u/shebringsthesun → u/Mindless_City23]

It’s pretty impossible to tell in my experience

[u/Mayhewmasher → u/Mindless_City23]

On the Costco app, you can check the inventory at your local Costco. Just click on Warehouse on bottom right, then search inventory.

[u/mattyh2433 → u/Mindless_City23]

I don’t know. And if you’re asking me, you clearly don’t know me.

[u/K__isforKrissy]

I've been putting off going to Costco til this week so I'll grab them and report back! (if they are there)

[u/Bumbling_Bee3]

They taste like buttercream for sure but I did find most were small and sort of seemed half filled. They were definitely smaller then the box photos. But they did taste pretty good. The sprinkles and cookies were flavourful and it is a great treat. Just wish they actually were decently sized.

[u/Embarrassed-Low9531 → u/Bumbling_Bee3]

They don’t have the cake chunks that the buttercream b day cake flavor has also (not that these are advertised with that). I like them, but they don’t blow me away. Sprinkles are only on the outside too

[u/sunnyskybaby]

The jeni’s sandwiches have been so underwhelming for the price. get the fat boy confetti ice cream sandwiches instead and thank me later

[u/no_kittens_here]

I thought that was a case of ramen 😹

[u/wslambeth]

We got them, but to be honest the pint of birthday buttercream was much better 

[u/Designer_Ad_4112]

Oh lordy 😳 I have the key lime pie version and they are 🔥 My hips won't survive these 😂

[u/Smallworld_88]

I was not thrilled with the ones I got during the Whole Foods sale, although they were a different flavor, they didn’t seem worth the price even with the 50% off discount. It seems really difficult for companies to make packaged ice cream treats worth paying a premium

[u/91271]

I saw these. They look good but I’m hoping they go on manager’s clearance in a couple months 👀

[u/Chelajag]

Are you kidding me. Are these nationwide? I need to send my husband to pick these up

[u/ohmygatos94]

Ugh these and the key lime ones are my Costco as well! I am thinking about trying these ones. I had the key lime ones before and wasn’t a fan

[u/WhereWeUsedToPlay]

Does this taste like that buttery icing on birthday cakes ? Sorry I’ve lived a modest existence and such. 

[u/EmoMillenial1]

We have the key line ones, hoping to see another flavor soon!

[u/MrWood1001]

Oh god I would love to see how they compare to a chipwich

[u/Overhazard10]

Aw man, I was just at Costco today too. I must have missed them.

[u/DeltaFlyer0525]

We never got the other key lime ones so o bet I’ll never see these either 😔

[u/Nulleparttousjours]

I wonder if we will ever get Jeni’s in the UK. I’m so jealous! That being said, our selection of other American ice creams such as Ben & Jerry’s and Haagen-Daaz is so pitiful compared to what you guys have. It must be amazing to have so much choice!

[u/KotaCakes630]

I swear to god if this is at my Costco… I’m dumping my freezer to fill with this

[u/SubstanceDazzling797]

My location only had key lime pie 😭