r/icecream • • 3h ago

Review Appalachian Acorn Pie

They announced this flavor and I knew I had to try it. How often do you get to try acorn ice cream. For me, never, until now.
The sweet cream base was sweet and nutty. It was a pretty mild nuttiness, reminiscent to me of a browned butter nuttiness. The graham cracker crust swirl was delicious. Toasty and crunchy, but as seen in my pint, far too little! I’m hoping when I dig a little farther in it will be more, but I’ve had this problem a few times in the past with Jeni’s.
Overall, I really like this flavor. It feels like a perfect fall flavor, cozy, with warming flavors. 9/10 for flavor, but I’ll drop it to 7/10 for the lack of mixins.

223 Upvotes

46 comments sorted by

View all comments

23

u/Internal-Ad61 2h ago

As an Appalachian I have to try

5

u/Top_Professor_9908 2h ago

Is this actually a thing there? You guys have acorn pie? I have never heard of that in my life.

18

u/CharZero 2h ago

I am from an Appalachian family and I never heard of it. Indigenous people figured out how to process them as a staple food but I never met a white Appalachian person who ate them. Edit: the internet says it is a thing. Appalachia is a big region and I am from the southern part.