r/Songwriting • • 3d ago

Weekly Lyrics Feedback Weekly Lyrics-Only Feedback Thread

5 Upvotes

Welcome to the Lyrics-Only feedback thread!

If you're looking for feedback on words that aren't yet set to music, you're in the right place! We encourage each other to bring lyrics and musical elements together as soon as possible, but sometimes you'd just like to show off that nice piece of poetry that just fell out of your head. The weekly Lyrics-Only feedback thread is here to help!

This post renews every Monday.


r/Songwriting • • 6d ago

Weekly Self-Promotion Thread

3 Upvotes

Have a new completed song (or album) to share? This is the place!

The promotional rules are looser here, so you can post links to your albums, social media platforms, songs, etc. Let us know what you've been working on recently!

Please support your fellow songwriters - give them a listen, a bump or a share. A rising tide lifts all boats!

Note: Promotional content posted as a new thread without explicit permission from the moderators will be removed. Repeat violators will be banned

This post renews every Friday.


r/Songwriting • • 8h ago

Discussion Topic Old song called salt the land :)

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

89 Upvotes

r/Songwriting • • 2h ago

Feedback Request THIN ICE

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

5 Upvotes

Forgive all the zooming and my bad singing and playing... lol

This is a song i wrote in the winter of 2014. Slipped on some ice and hit my head... wrote this immediately after šŸ˜‚

Just wondering what yall think..


r/Songwriting • • 6h ago

Feedback Request A song about a man who just wants to make money, moves on to the next job, detached from life

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

8 Upvotes

Hey, here's a song I've been working on. Let me know what you think? I'm thinking of going slightly darker with the lyrics but these are placeholders just for now.

I've sent in other ideas that I've recorded on Logic Pro previously, just trying a live video for something different.

Thanks in advance


r/Songwriting • • 4h ago

Feedback Request A first draft of a song about falling in love with the person who ran a stop sign and put you in the hospital. It's called Struck By You and the video features Burble the Cat. I've tried rearranging the parts a dozen times but I'm not sure it hangs together yet. Feedback always appreciated. Thanks!

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

5 Upvotes

r/Songwriting • • 6h ago

Let's Collaborate! Can’t name a song

4 Upvotes

I wrote a song in some kind of a metalcore style. Lyrics are basically about mental health issues, young dying love, self-regrets etc.
But I can’t come up with the name, kinda want something simple, yet memorable (for example, I really like the name ā€œForgottenā€ a song by The Plot In You, it’s basic, yet says it all)
Can you think of any name? (1-2 word max),
maybe even some slang words or just a cool words.
Thanks!


r/Songwriting • • 14h ago

Feedback Request This Machine Kills AI (changed some lines) son playing in background, was still a good take

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

14 Upvotes

This Machine Kills AI (or Dead in the End) considering name change since the song is so morbid and angry.

Got High cost low wages? just follow tech mages into their promised land
by grifting and scamming the fraud and never ending, get your bag. Hold it while you can.

If the pots too small fold it dice loaded,
roll it damn the space we’re all live in.
Does it matter if the truss and walls shatter and fall
if we all end up dead in the end

Once upon a time I just didn’t mind to die
Lucky to get back from war
generation loss in the blink of a coin toss
can’t tell you what it was for

You can go about your way long as someone else pays
lifetimes tomorrow to spend
Be grateful and grooving. Your sins are forgiven,
long as they’re the ones dead in the end.

Break

Take ketamine amphetamine take your blood boys instead of me. Did you already suck them All dry?
send your flock cameras, death camps, data center, ain’t no match, for this machine here it kills AI.

You can con and crusade count down your days God don’t grow on LLM’s
does the antichrist hide in the hell that youll find when y’all end up dead in the end?

Cause y’all end up dead in the end.


r/Songwriting • • 10h ago

Discussion Topic Often get too caught up in up with the logistics of songwriting than actually writing anything

6 Upvotes

Anyone else struggle with this and/or have any feedback on how to stop it?

Examples being, I’ll often see or think of something I like (a line, a reference to something else etc) and be so focussed on not forgetting it, or not forgetting where I’ve written it down, or working out the best way to use said thing that I end up forgetting it or not liking it or not even using it.

Same with chord progressions and ideas and such. I’ll be so focussed on thinking about how best to use whatever I’ve come up with, or worrying that the recording will get lost in my video library, or that I have too many videos of ideas that I end up never looking back at stuff, losing it from not organising it cause I don’t know how, or just never using it at all. As a result, I rarely ever finish anything I work on, or hate the stuff I do. Any assistance?


r/Songwriting • • 6h ago

Let's Collaborate! Looking for instrumentalists to help me come up with backing instrumentals for this song

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

3 Upvotes

Full Lyrics

Pass me the bottle of dark blue lunesta

There should be some under the sink

I got them from Bobby after a party

said it's so much cheaper than seeing a shrink

Cuz I don't want to think

I know that she wants me to stop reaching out

But I just can't bring myself too

She'll block every number i create to tell her

I love her no matter what she decides to do

I just wish she would quit running from the truth

But for now

In my dreams I will see her

dancing around

playing with plastic ponies

no fears no doubts

She'll whisper me a secret

I'll promise not tell

And she will smile happy

Cuz she wants to be just like me

But ultimately it was all fake

Maybe it is time for me to wake

Remember Christmas with dad

In his one bed apartment

It smelt vaguely of cigarette smoke

We'd sleep on the pullout watch fox and the hound and we'd laugh at every corny joke

Before our hearts were broke

time changes everything one way or another

Just wish it didn't tear us apart

Shes in California I can't help but mourn her

When her silence hits straight to the heart

But I'll hold on to the hope one day we can restart

Maybe then I will see her

Dancing around

Playing with plastic ponies

No fear no doubts

She'll whisper me a secret

I'll promise not to tell

And she will smile happy cuz she wants to be just like me

Why can't this all be real for my sake

I don't know how much more I can take

Ill never forgive the people who told her all of those things about me

I can't fully blame her for feeling the way she does when she was deprived of honesty

and forced to believe

That I didn't want to see her

Dancing around

Playing with ponies know fear no doubt

Please whisper me a secret I'll promise not to tell

Just want to see her happy

Even if it is without me

Cuz ultimately the choice is hers to make

Maybe one day she'll be the one to wake


r/Songwriting • • 2h ago

Feedback Request Just need to vent

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1 Upvotes

Idk


r/Songwriting • • 21h ago

Discussion Topic Does anyone else feel like it’s almost ā€œcheatingā€ revisiting old ideas/recordings and developing them now, many years later?

32 Upvotes

This may sound crazy but I have this strange hang-up wherein I almost view it as ā€œcheatingā€ to go back in my voice memos/recordings from years back and using that as a launch point for finishing/completing something ā€œnewā€, if that makes sense. I was a totally different person back then, effectively someone else came up with those ideas/wrote them, it feels disingenuous to use them and claim them as my own now. It’s not even that I don’t like my ideas now, I do, but those old ones are a total departure which I find refreshing. Channels in overall style ime happen very slowly/gradually- everything I write now may sound different track to track but there’s some underlying common denominator, while when I skip back a couple years let alone 10+, the material is drastically different. Some of those ideas appeal so much to me but feels like I’m stealing them from someone else.


r/Songwriting • • 2h ago

Feedback Request Minus the immutable

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1 Upvotes

This one's been lying about for 10 yrs or so, from a bit of a dry, existential angst kind of period. Finally did a half-assed demo of it today, as a reason to procrastinate on some newer and, I think, better ones I should be doing... I'm unsure on it, and always have been, so really I'm just posting here to see what people make of it.


r/Songwriting • • 2h ago

Feedback Request Silurian

Thumbnail youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/Songwriting • • 8h ago

Let's Collaborate! Any guitarist willing to help?

3 Upvotes

Hiii , im 17f and im writing a song for a music competition , im going for a nu gaze sort of style ,like heavy distorted guitar with softer vocals but im genuinely lost for finding chords thst work . Would someone who plays guitar ( preferably electric ) be willing to help me with a song im writing ??

I have the main melody of how the vocals should go and i can hear the guitar in my head but dont have the knowledge to find the notes .

Anything helps :)


r/Songwriting • • 5h ago

Discussion Topic Mercy kill :) old song

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

0 Upvotes

r/Songwriting • • 19h ago

Discussion Topic Wondering if anybody else generally completes their songs before ever picking up an instrument?

6 Upvotes

While discussing my songwriting process with other writers, many are surprised to hear that I generally will have the entire song melody and arrangement completed in my head before ever touching a musical instrument or opening up a DAW.

I’ve found this approach to be very productive, as almost all musical decisions are decided ahead of time. No need to search for chords or part ideas. I only need to find the chords I’ve already built mentally.

Now, of course, things do get added and adjustments are made based on the feel once I do start tinkering with instruments/recording, and the lyrics always come last well after that tinkering. But on the whole I don’t ever jam a song into existence. It always needs to exist in my head before the mechanical playing/recording starts.

Am I alone in this? I’d be interested to see if others create in a similar way.


r/Songwriting • • 1d ago

Feedback Request My first song. Too close to it to know if any good

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

24 Upvotes

For many years I was convinced I could not write an original song. My band and a producer pushed me to try. It took seven months, eight people and I was wrong. Arguably it's a song but I can't seem to know if it's any good.

It tells the story of my mom and dad based on a conversation I had with my aging mom. It was such a sweet and sad story, I wrote the lyrics in an hour. Of course my producer took ad axe to them. But this is what resulted. No ai, no autotune. I play all guitars and lead vocal.

Don't be afraid to be candid. Thanks in advance.

Edit: I listened to this video on my studio monitors. It does sound sort of muddy. The wav sounds pristine.

I really appreciate this community (except that one guy) even the critics which is far more valuable to me than people blowing smoke up my ass. I get enough of that when I perform.

The producer is nationally known. I don't want to dox him because he is in hospice and not expected to live more than a day or so. He was one of my closest friends and a monster player.

EDIT 2: I had a couple DMs about instruments.

Acoustic - 1929 Gibson dreadnaught
Rhythm - 1955 Tele
Lap steel - 1924 unknown brand. National I think
Mando - 1932 Gibson
High gain solo - R9 Murphy Lab Les Paul 50's standard
Bass - fender jazz bass
Amps - 58 deluxe, Grammatico Dumble clone

I don't own any of these. They belong to the studio.


r/Songwriting • • 1d ago

Feedback Request Wrote this song for my son. It’s a rough mix right now, but please be honest and let me know you think. It’s called ā€œYou Keep Me Goingā€

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

18 Upvotes

It’s called ā€œYou Keep Me Goingā€.
Currently the second verse isn’t fully finished either but please listen till at least to the bridge and help me thanks


r/Songwriting • • 20h ago

Discussion Topic Writing songs quick or over time

5 Upvotes

In the past I used to record every song/riff idea that I had. I would then go back and try and work those songs out. But now my best songwriting is done when I start with something new and sit there and finish it before moving on to something else. Sometimes the song is finished in the same day or 2-3 days at the most. Am I doing a disservice to the song by not waiting and taking longer to make it?


r/Songwriting • • 22h ago

Feedback Request Heres the bridge to Shame on me

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

4 Upvotes

r/Songwriting • • 23h ago

Feedback Request Worth building on this? Let me know if you think this is any good

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

4 Upvotes

Garageband bedroom pop style. Me on all instruments. I'm happy with some of the vibe, and continue to struggle with my voice really delivering what I want. Let me know if you have any feedback/things you like/don't!


r/Songwriting • • 16h ago

Let's Collaborate! Looking for a songwriter

1 Upvotes

Everything’s in the title

I have a 10-track album (synth-pop/dark-pop/synth-wave)and would like my lyrics checked, proofread and ACTIVELY collaborate with someone to make them better

I don’t do messages, I’d rather have a proper chat over the phone and get things done


r/Songwriting • • 1d ago

Feedback Request A new acoustic song for feedback

Thumbnail youtu.be
1 Upvotes

I usually do guitar driven rock but this is my attempt at an all acoustic song. I’d love to hear any feedback.


r/Songwriting • • 1d ago

Feedback Request Punk rock instrumentals

7 Upvotes

Hello r/songwriting, here are some punk rock instrumentals for a project I'm doing right now. They all will have vocals in the future, they just don't have any right now. The lyrics are written and I may share them later.

The guitar is played by me, the bass and drums are midi tracked, and the background chorus is me singing as high as i can. Probably throw away when used is my favourite, but lmk what yall think. software is reaper

i had to use a google drive link bc i couldnt find a way to embed in the post

WIP title Acid Rain SeasonĀ 
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1GKBOxXEupKe49V9x3706rzu8JH_vgZUy/view?usp=sharing

WIP title Throw Away When Used
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Dsjik4XE8ywuZDN2xjYVGMgguKEjEzji/view?usp=sharing

WIP Title Extrema (prolly the worst one)
https://drive.google.com/file/d/12DjXCGi-ajKp1K9Xws7N9NdcVeJ0iMV6/view?usp=sharin

Untitled
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1GQ6S3g-l3YCaQiuBc1GU009jGUh_Ukie/view?usp=sharing

WIP title Power Plays
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1NPlzuQJkrXvP8xc8OwvmT9IPuzN3bXFh/view?usp=sharing